XBox icon Dream matchup debate!

Started by TP-BigWill September 1st, 2009 12:32 AM
  • 1709 views
  • 5 replies
  • Poll

Who would win in a fight?

Age 33
Male
Goldenrod City with my best friend Officer Jenny
Seen March 30th, 2012
Posted August 24th, 2010
168 posts
15.5 Years
As you might have figured out, the constant argument of who would win in a fight between Master Chief of the Halo Franchise and Marcus Fenix of the Gears of War franchise has finally hit Pokecommunity! And brothers, its your turn to decide.



Who wins this?

The rules to this argument are simple. I will provide facts about 1 of each catagory weapon and we will base the fights on just the facts, and not the "what ifs" or training aspects. Master Chief's shield and Marcus's active reload ability will not count in the arguments. So lets roll the dice!

Master Chief- Protagonist of the Halo fps series



Weapon set (as of Halo 3)
Close Range: M90 Shotgun
Far Range: Human sniper rifle
Medium range: Assault rifle/ BR55 Battle Rifle
Special weapon: Rocket Launcher/ Brute Shot
Grenade: Plasma Grenade

Master chief as many knows, has been the sole face of xbox. Singlehandidly carrying the consloe in its previous generation, he makes another appearance in Halo 3 with a fresh coat of paint. The only known survivor of a dominant race of cyborgs called the spartans, Master chief (Spartan 117) must team up with the arbitar to take out the last of the flood and halo ring threats. His cult following is up around 8 million platers with multiple books and an anime show in the works.

Marcus Fenix- Protagonist of the Gears of War 2 tps game



Weapon set (as of Gears of War 2)
Close Range: Gnasher Shotgun
Far Range: Longshot Rifle
Medium range: Lancer/ Hammerburst
Special weapon: Tprque Bow/ Boomshot
Grenade: Frag Grenade

Marcus Fenix as the leader of Delta Squad, as well as his opponent, is Humanity's last life line to survival. As Halo's origional trillogy colses, many people suspect Fenix to repalce Master Chief as the new face of XBox gaming. With 2.5 million copies of his latest game sold in its first month of relese, 2 books, a comic book series and a movie in production, the franchise is opening itself up to many marketing stratagies.

Close Range weapons
M90 Shotgun (halo)


The M90 shotgun is a powerful closerange weapon for Master Chief. With consistant damgae from close range, It can shread up; an opponent's powershield in pointblank range. Often times durring a match, if the shooter does not shoot pointblank a melee must follow suit for the kill which raises questions about its power. 8 bullets fit in a clip.

Gnasher Shotgun (Gears)


The gnasher shotgun os the most commonly used weapon in the Gears of War game to to the close range combat. Up close it can blow apart a player and can down a person from short-mid distance. However,there are issues with inconsistancy with it. Although a person can inflict a lot of damage with it to an opponent, that same opponent can kill the person with one shot. A Melee following a shot (Two Piecing) is a commonly practiced move to combat the inconsistancy with the gnasher. Shotgun fits 8 rounds


Mid Range weapons
Match ups:
BR55 battle Rifle vs. Hammerburst
Assult Rifle vs. Lancer assault rifle
BR55 Battle Rifle and Assualt Rifle (Not Pictured)(Halo)


The battle rifle and assualt rifle are the most commonly started weapon in multiplayer of Halo. While the assualt rifle is often reffered to as the spitball launcher, its companion is one of the more consistantly dominant weapon with scoping abilities for long range and low recoil. However it is a burst fire automatic weapon. The assualt rifle is fully automatic.

Lancer assault rifle and Hammerburst rifle (Gears)

Players can choose between the lancer and the hammerburst prior to any multiplayer game. The lancer is the trademark weapon of the COG soldier. Although weaker in firing than its counterpart the hammerburst, lancer rounds can and will impede speed and movement of anyone taking direct fire from it. The lancer has no recoil what so ever and its chainsaw melee is in instant kill, however it leaves the user vulnerable for several seconds. Hammerburst is a very powerful kit weapon that is both semi automatic and fully automatic. Although it has zooming capabilities, the hammerburst has a considerable amount of recoil in the quicker semi-automatic made therefore making it moderatly accurate.

Long Range weapons
Human Sniper Rifle (halo)

The halo sniper rifle is the most sought after longrange weapon in the game. With it's clips and rate of fire more reliable than the covenant counterpart, this weapon can tear into a team. With a 2 hit gaurentee kill and headshot capabilities, this is a leathal weapon in several hands. With new Ricochet abilities added on in Halo 3, one round can reach around and kill anyone in cover.

Longshot Rifle (gears)

The Gears of war sniper rifle has been powered down with the last title, but it is still as leathal as it gets. This Bolt Action Rifle will inflict massive damage and has a 2 shot kill garantee. Although it has a viceral headshot, it is a difficult weapon to control.

Special weapons
Matchups:
Rocket Launcher Vs. Boomshot
Torque bow vs Brute Shot

Rocket Launcher and Brute Shot(not Pictured)(Halo)

The Halo Rocket Launcher is on of the most devastating anti-everything weapon in the game. With the ability to just point and shoot at the people you dont like, its easy to score kills with this weapon. It has fairly easy sniping abilities and auto-lock on for vehicles. Max capacitiy for rounds are 2. Brute shot is a weapon that lobs frag grenades at opponents. Grenades are multiple, however, since they have a tendacy to bounce, accuracy is a bit sketchy with only 6 shots.

Torque Bow and Boomshot(Not Pictured)(Gears)

Boomshot is that one weapon in Gears of war 2 people have epic battles over. While it packs single fire capabilities, the shots that it fires are artillary pineapple shells with multiple explosions that can shred up a team. Firing long range presents issues due to the fact that the heavier rounds will arc in the air. Torque Bow is the most versatile weapon in the game. While posing single shot firing rate, the bolts have sniping capacities being able to shoot off multiple heads and continue its trajectory. It will stick on what ever it lands on and blow up on it. Weather its on the floor for a mini landmine, or on a person its devastating to anyone near it. Melee is particularly devastating since it packs dual blades.

Grenades

Plasma Grenade(Halo)

Plasmas are Halo's signature grenades. With the infamous fuzzy spider on one's body, death is surely immanant. Although lacking as much punch as the human frag, it makes up with the ability to stick on people, making it a dangerous anti-infantry weapon.

Frag Grenade(Gears)

Gears of War 2 Frag grenades have been dramaticly improved since their prior form. With frag tagging (sticking a frag on a person or a surface) this becomes a very devastating tactical weapon.

So thoose are the prechoosen weapons for the fight. My opinion?

1.)M90 Shotgun(halo) vs Gnasher shotgun(gears)
As heavy hitting as the gnasher is, I would have to give it to the Halo's M90 shotgun due to its consistancy.
Winner: M90

2.)BR55 Battle Rifle(halo) vs. Hammerburst(gears)
I've used the hammerburst extensivly and can pull it apart. Its a hard hitting weapon with a rapid rate of fire. But due to the ease of use, range and low recoil, I would have to give it to the battle rifle.
Winner: BR55

3.) Assault Rifle(halo) vs. Lancer(gears)
This is a no-brainer. As if the automatic kill with the chainsaw isn't proof enough, the fact that a stream of lancer fire slows enemys to a crawl is dominating enough.
Winner: Lancer

4.) Human Sniper Rifle(halo) vs. Longshot Rifle(gears)
I've tried both, although the longshot is a bit more accurate from the hip, bottom line is that the halo sniper has multiple shots, ricocheting and consistancy on their side.
Winner: Human Sniper Rifle

5.) Rockert Launcher(halo) vs. Boomshot(Gears)
I can use both very well. Although I like the fact that the rocket launcher gets 2 trys before it needs to reload, I also love the pineapple clusterbomb which tears up groups more effectivly. Although the rocket launcher is more accurate towards direct threats, the arcing boomshot is more of a threat to hiding snipers behind cover. I honestly cant call between the 2.
Undecided

6.) Brute Shot(Halo) vs. Torque Bow(Gears)
This one's an easy one for me. Its going to be Torque. Although the brute shot can pepper an area with grenades, the fact that the torque is an all-purpose weapon, this wins for me.
Winner: Torque Bow

7.) Plasma Grenade(halo) vs. Frag Grenade(gears)
Sticking someone with a plasma is an artform. But that being said, I see it as harmless. It gives its position up easily with its glowing, so not too many people will step on it, and it doesnt have too much of a roll around to it. Gears frag grenade is stealthy killer who only alerts you with three beeps before it goes off in your area. paired with a second, it sprays a huge area.
Winner: Frag Grenade

Basing it on weapons only, I would say Sgt. Marcus Fenix would win in a fight. But regardless, this would be a highly entertaining fight for me.

^_^

Spoiler:

My pokemon battle rules:
Spoiler:
My FC is 1933 7884 6981
Shoddy name: RedSoxDragon
Perferably a Uu battle
No ubers
HAVE FUN MOFO! Its a game. You wont make much cash or look like a badass, so Have fun with it.
For the love of god...VOICE CHAT OFF!
Please try to give me a fun and original battle.:may:

XBL Info: RedSoxDragon
Spoiler:
XBL GamerTag: RedSoxDragon
Main Game: Gears of War 2/ Modern Warfare 2
Gears of War 2: Annex Specialist
True Rank(Before the hackers): 496 K/D Ratio: 2.5 Win/ Loss: 1287w- 142L
Modern Warfare 2:"One Man Army" Perk Specialist
K/D Ratio:2.57 and rising!

Fenrir Reki

Guardian of Destruction

Age 28
Male
San Jose, CA
Seen August 31st, 2014
Posted August 31st, 2014
2,073 posts
14.4 Years
I think Marcus would win this fight. Even though master chief has survived plenty of the covenant/flood, Marcus has a much better advantage. Most of his guns are better than the Chiefs. Besides it would be awesome to see Marcus chainsaw Master Chief with the lancer. :D

(Working on a better signature + avy)

Male
Gronzyl Grad
Seen February 22nd, 2012
Posted October 24th, 2009
275 posts
15.3 Years
Marcus has a freaking chainsaw gun. 'Nuff said.
I'd like to see the Left 4 Dead survivors going up against Gordan Freeman and some of the other Half-Life 2 characters. Neither side is exactly combat-trained to begin with. :3
Gordon wins. :D
Hell, put in the entire TF2 cast and he'll still win.
Why? Because he's Gordon Freeman!

(Yes, I love typing like this.)
Sigpics aren't sexy~
:t052::t230: :t058:

HAHA I R CLEVAR 90% OF TEENS DERP DERP MILEH CYRUS DERP DERP
омG і сαπ ŭşĕ Т3Н сђаяас†3ѓ МАр lawl!!!!11!!one!!1!!