I think Smogon is wrong.

Started by Kozoi September 2nd, 2009 3:40 PM
  • 21825 views
  • 39 replies
Male
Behind you.
Seen June 15th, 2012
Posted July 3rd, 2011
368 posts
14.9 Years
Okay, before I get a bunch of raging Smogon nerds I would like to argue my side across. Smogon is used by everyone to rank Pokémon into tiers, nobody has tried to argue with Smogon because Smogon couldn't be wrong, could it? For those who do not know the tiers are divided up into Neverused, Underused, Overused and Uber depending on a variety of different factors.

According to smogon users, the first factor that divides tiers up and the most important is how many people use them. Not on Wi-Fi though, oh no. Just on Shoddy Battle, a battling simluation program where people test teams and battle for fun. This means that only the more intellectual battlers use it and people who use Pokémon such as Pikachu do not exist, thus making Pokémon like Pikachu NU dispite the fact it is used in almost every kids Platinum team. This is a problem in itself.

The next factor, according to smogon users is movepool and stats. Now this is completely wrong because there are plenty of NU Pokémon with stats equal or better than that of an OU Pokémon. Lets compare one, shall we?

Gardevoir Statistics:
HP: 68
Attack: 65
Defense: 65
Special Attack: 125
Special Defense: 115
Speed: 80

These stats seem pretty average for a UU Pokémon right? Exactly, but that's not all. Gardevoir has an excellent movepool which includes great attacks such as Psychic, Energyball, Focusblast, Thunderbolt, Hidden Power, Grassknot, Shadowball, Will-O-Wisp, Wish, Hypnosis and many other useful moves. That's not all! Gardevoir has the unique ability Trace which copies the opponents ability. This means Gardevoir can switch in on Jolteon and Vaporeon, two top tier OU Pokémon and basically laugh in their faces. Guess what? This Pokémon is NU.

Alakazam Statistics:
Hp: 55
Attack: 50
Defense: 45
Special Attack: 135
Special Defense: 85
Speed: 120

This Pokémon is always coupled with Syncronize or Inner Focus. Both of which are pretty much terrible abilities compared to Gardevoirs rare Trace ability. Alakazam has a much more limited movepool too, the only special sweeping moves it can learn of any value are Psychic, Hidden Power, Focus Blast, Signal Beam and Shadow Ball. These moves are pretty typical and can be predicted. Sure Alakazam has slightly better special attack and hugely better speed but Gardevoir makes up with it by being much more bulky and having that rare ability. This Pokémon is OU which is common knowledge but comparing it to Gardevoir close up makes it seem pretty pathetic in comparison.

There are plenty of other Neverused Pokémon which aren't bad by any means, one of these is Ramparados which has one of the biggest attack stats in the game. (165) This is bigger than any Rhyperior, Jirachi or Aerodactyl. With choice scarf I could see that Pokémon tearing teams apart in OU. (Plus it has an excellent movepool) Another example is Aggron with a monsterous 180 defense and a respectable 110 attack stat. It also has a great movepool and a pretty acceptable ability yet it is NU.

Looking at all of these NU Pokémon which are really worthy of OU makes me sick, if you use a Pokémon like Gardevoir in the OU tier on shoddy then you're liable to be laughed at for using an NU Pokémon. Nobody gives these Pokémon a chance, they just stick to the same overused Pokémon in every single Wi-Fi battle.

Tl;dr - Smogon is wrong, they're tiering Pokémon up based on the same Pokémon that are used over and over again. All people do now is grab the first set they see on Smogon and throw together a pretty darn predictable team. This can be seen on Serebii Wi-Fi chat, check it out there.

Discuss and share your nerdy thoughts.
It is impossible to bob your head back and forth with your mouth open.

Greene1516

Scratching the surface...

Male
Purgatory
Seen May 1st, 2013
Posted April 21st, 2011
373 posts
14 Years
Well on your example right there the speed is what makes the huge difference. Alakazam can outspeed and OHKO most of the best Pokemon out there, whereas Gardevoir struggles to keep up the pace and gets plastered to the wall before it gets to attack. The fact that it can counter Vaporeon and Jolteon means diddly-squat; they are but 2 POkemon of many hundreds.

And then of course there is the main factor which you mentioned yourself, the tiers represent what is used the most on SHoddy, not what is the best necessarily, so maybe you should read your own post before ranting on again.

And for the record, I hate smogon, so don't think only smogon loving nerds are going to contest you. The tiers are a joke, but your understanding of why is much less impressive.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Heart and Soul League Official Rock Gym Leader
FC: 2707-9490-0844
W:117 Dr:1 Ls:30

Subscribe to my youtube battle channel: http://www.youtube.com/user/Greene1516
Also check my trade thread: http://www.pokecommunity.com/showthread.php?t=182882

Battle Frontier

The Scientist

PKMN Scientist/Mathemagician

Male
In a Laboratory
Seen July 27th, 2012
Posted December 19th, 2009
721 posts
19.3 Years
Greene1516 got it.

The tiers are determined by what the players choose, and not vice versa. A Pokemon/moveset only becomes popular in competetive battling if it's effective. If everyone starts running a U-Turn/Bullet Punch Scizor, then Scizor will be high-tiered. When someone finds a way to counter it, it'll drop (like what happened to Rampardos, lead Bronzong/Yanmega, Arcanine, etc.)

In the end, it's the players who decide the tiers, and Smogon just reports on those statistics. It does discourage new players from experimenting on their own at first, but eventually they will have no choice but do think for themselves.

Regardless, my Xatu rips through Tyranitar with surprising ease.
Love science? Join The Laboratory!
----------------------------------------------------------
General Scientists: The Scientist | Idiomorph | Dr Gregory House | Redstar
Self-professed "Mad" Scientist: Viceroy Gawain
Resident Quantum Physicist: Mizan de la Plume Kuro
[Un]Lovable Intern: Luck
Lovable Interns: Yams | mOOG | Haz | Eliminator Jr.
That shady guy lurking around the chemical dumpsters: Latiace
Some random guy: 0m3GA ARS3NAL
Sexy Lab Assistant: 001


Male
Behind you.
Seen June 15th, 2012
Posted July 3rd, 2011
368 posts
14.9 Years
Well on your example right there the speed is what makes the huge difference. Alakazam can outspeed and OHKO most of the best Pokemon out there, whereas Gardevoir struggles to keep up the pace and gets plastered to the wall before it gets to attack. The fact that it can counter Vaporeon and Jolteon means diddly-squat; they are but 2 POkemon of many hundreds.

And then of course there is the main factor which you mentioned yourself, the tiers represent what is used the most on SHoddy, not what is the best necessarily, so maybe you should read your own post before ranting on again.

And for the record, I hate smogon, so don't think only smogon loving nerds are going to contest you. The tiers are a joke, but your understanding of why is much less impressive.
I lol'd, good job. Gardevoir can make an excellent support Pokémon in OU and has much more going for it than Alakazam. Good for Alakazam having good speed but that doesn't save it from a Choice Scarfed Shadow Ball. Gardevoir can counter pretty much any Pokémon with flash fire, water absorb or volt absorb. Considering this, it's a prime example of a counter in the OU tier.

I mentioned the factor myself that Smogon is wrong BECAUSE they're tiering Pokémon based on how many people use them in Shoddy Battle, not Wi-Fi. This effects many Wi-Fi battlers, even those who do not use Shoddy Battle. You tried to make out that I didn't know this, or tried to restate what I already knew in an attempt to argue your point across. Pointless.


I agree entirely. I've taken down Giritina and Deoxys before with only my Farfetch'd.
I love to embarass uber teams with NU Pokémon.

Greene1516 got it.

The tiers are determined by what the players choose, and not vice versa. A Pokemon/moveset only becomes popular in competetive battling if it's effective. If everyone starts running a U-Turn/Bullet Punch Scizor, then Scizor will be high-tiered. When someone finds a way to counter it, it'll drop (like what happened to Rampardos, lead Bronzong/Yanmega, Arcanine, etc.)

In the end, it's the players who decide the tiers, and Smogon just reports on those statistics. It does discourage new players from experimenting on their own at first, but eventually they will have no choice but do think for themselves.

Regardless, my Xatu rips through Tyranitar with surprising ease.
Paragraph 1 - Wait, didn't I already say that in the first place?
Paragraph 2 - Okay, sure.

Yeah, Xatu is pretty kick ass in OU too but it's not a Tyranitar counter because of Stone Edge.

Can you stop restating what I said guys? Smogon tiers are WRONG because of how they tier Pokémon up. They need to consider stats a little more and possibly, just possibly actually consider how many people use them in Wi-Fi.

On the topic of Gardevoir, it's more bulky and sturdy than Alakazam and is still not a bad Pokémon for UU/OU by any means. It can counter Heatran, Swampert, Vaporeon, Jolteon, Lanturn, Lapras, Arcanine and can usually deal with most Gyarados, Salamence, Flygon, etc providing that they haven't DDced enough to outspeed choice scarf 80 speed users. Gardevoir has Will-O-Wisp, Wish, Hypnosis and Toxic. All of these are support moves that work well in the OU tier.

Also Scarf Rampardos with 165 attack is win. I've been using it in OU for a while and it hasn't let me down once.
It is impossible to bob your head back and forth with your mouth open.

Charmageddon

Charizard has evolved into ^

Seen April 25th, 2016
Posted June 3rd, 2012
859 posts
14.4 Years
Aggron is useless because it gets utterly destroyed by Earthquake and any fighting move. And Gardevoir having Toxic means diddly-squat, every pokemon that can learn TMs can learn that.

But yeah, I agree with parts of your post.
"Strong Pokemon. Weak Pokemon. That is only the selfish perception of people. Truly skilled trainers should try to win with their favourites."
- Karen, Pokemon Gold, Silver and Crystal

Niprop

The Fighting Porygon Team

Male
Somewhere Between the Internet and Reality
Seen January 25th, 2012
Posted January 23rd, 2012
846 posts
14.7 Years
The same reason that Porygon2 (A major Heatran, Gyrados, AND Salamence counter rolled into one!) is, and why Gyrados pre-D/P/P was. Most pokémon have decent stats, but they are used next to none in competitive play. Smeargle was only recently bumped to OU because of it's Baton-Passing abilities.
´ 3`) official gulpin emote. ^.^Help gulpin take over the Internet and use him for your signature!
"Yay! Yay! ♪ Perfect Apple! ♪ Perfect Apple! ♪"
- Wigglytuff
"Geodudes are really tough."- Random kid from Pokémon Commercial
"Dragonite for the win!"- Lance
"Are you kidding me? Not my Chikorita!"- Random kid from other Pokémon Commercial

thegeneticway

"He has kickin' powers"-Trixie

Age 26
Male
California B)
Seen January 22nd, 2017
Posted December 2nd, 2012
415 posts
13.8 Years
Yes, I don't like how they put the tiers also, but you can't really change everyone's thought ~
Hey.
I'm Roger! Call me Genetic if you prefer, but I really don't mind ^-^

Replaying Emerald!

Goals:

National Dex Completed
All 7 Gold Symbols
Master of Contests

... looks like i have a long way to go
Age 31
Male
?????
Seen January 26th, 2013
Posted April 14th, 2012
1,130 posts
14.8 Years
Okay, before I get a bunch of raging Smogon nerds I would like to argue my side across. Smogon is used by everyone to rank Pokémon into tiers, nobody has tried to argue with Smogon because Smogon couldn't be wrong, could it? For those who do not know the tiers are divided up into Neverused, Underused, Overused and Uber depending on a variety of different factors.

According to smogon users, the first factor that divides tiers up and the most important is how many people use them. Not on Wi-Fi though, oh no. Just on Shoddy Battle, a battling simluation program where people test teams and battle for fun. This means that only the more intellectual battlers use it and people who use Pokémon such as Pikachu do not exist, thus making Pokémon like Pikachu NU dispite the fact it is used in almost every kids Platinum team. This is a problem in itself.

The next factor, according to smogon users is movepool and stats. Now this is completely wrong because there are plenty of NU Pokémon with stats equal or better than that of an OU Pokémon. Lets compare one, shall we?

Gardevoir Statistics:
HP: 68
Attack: 65
Defense: 65
Special Attack: 125
Special Defense: 115
Speed: 80

These stats seem pretty average for a UU Pokémon right? Exactly, but that's not all. Gardevoir has an excellent movepool which includes great attacks such as Psychic, Energyball, Focusblast, Thunderbolt, Hidden Power, Grassknot, Shadowball, Will-O-Wisp, Wish, Hypnosis and many other useful moves. That's not all! Gardevoir has the unique ability Trace which copies the opponents ability. This means Gardevoir can switch in on Jolteon and Vaporeon, two top tier OU Pokémon and basically laugh in their faces. Guess what? This Pokémon is NU.

Alakazam Statistics:
Hp: 55
Attack: 50
Defense: 45
Special Attack: 135
Special Defense: 85
Speed: 120

This Pokémon is always coupled with Syncronize or Inner Focus. Both of which are pretty much terrible abilities compared to Gardevoirs rare Trace ability. Alakazam has a much more limited movepool too, the only special sweeping moves it can learn of any value are Psychic, Hidden Power, Focus Blast, Signal Beam and Shadow Ball. These moves are pretty typical and can be predicted. Sure Alakazam has slightly better special attack and hugely better speed but Gardevoir makes up with it by being much more bulky and having that rare ability. This Pokémon is OU which is common knowledge but comparing it to Gardevoir close up makes it seem pretty pathetic in comparison.

There are plenty of other Neverused Pokémon which aren't bad by any means, one of these is Ramparados which has one of the biggest attack stats in the game. (165) This is bigger than any Rhyperior, Jirachi or Aerodactyl. With choice scarf I could see that Pokémon tearing teams apart in OU. (Plus it has an excellent movepool) Another example is Aggron with a monsterous 180 defense and a respectable 110 attack stat. It also has a great movepool and a pretty acceptable ability yet it is NU.

Looking at all of these NU Pokémon which are really worthy of OU makes me sick, if you use a Pokémon like Gardevoir in the OU tier on shoddy then you're liable to be laughed at for using an NU Pokémon. Nobody gives these Pokémon a chance, they just stick to the same overused Pokémon in every single Wi-Fi battle.

Tl;dr - Smogon is wrong, they're tiering Pokémon up based on the same Pokémon that are used over and over again. All people do now is grab the first set they see on Smogon and throw together a pretty darn predictable team. This can be seen on Serebii Wi-Fi chat, check it out there.

Discuss and share your nerdy thoughts.
Dude, I agree with you on almost all of your points. Gardevoir has a better stat spread than Alakazam, but you are forgetting Alakazam's speed stat. Now if a Gardevoir had a Choice Scarf, that speed stat of Alakazam's would be useless. That is true.

Now let's talk about Rampardos. That thing's attack stat is absolutely phenomenal. However, take a look at its stat spread. Attack is the only thing that stands out, and its ability is kinda useless with its physical movepool. If that thing went up against my Rhyperior, it would be destroyed by one, ONE, Earthquake, even if it got the first hit.

Basically what I'm trying to say is this. While you do make plenty of points, you are not backing it up with the right things.

An example of this would be my Muk absolutely destroying an Uber team the other day.
Pokecommunity Family:
Nideous (Spamming Bro)
aspie3000 (Brother)
ShinyDiamond (Karate Bro)
PkMnTrainerYellow (Improbable Daughter)
Mr. Mammoth (Mammoth Gentleman Son)

Hey everybody! Once a week, I will change my avatar to a video game character(s). If you have any suggestions, PM me. My current avi is of Hito-Shura from Shin Megami Tensei III: Nocturne! It was suggested by TornZero. Someone better suggest the Space Core from Portal 2.
Age 30
Scotland
Seen May 12th, 2020
Posted February 6th, 2014
383 posts
14.2 Years
Meh, I don't listen to tiers. Probably because I don't IV/EV train my Pokemon and battle competitively. But if I did, I would use any Pokemon I want, even if it was considered useless.

If Magikarp can beat an uber team, then the tier list is kinda wrong to me anyway.
Come check out my Yugioh Videos!
3DS FC: 1521 - 2681 - 0996

Sackferth

Fonetics Phanatic

Age 31
Guyana, South America
Seen November 16th, 2021
Posted November 16th, 2021
154 posts
14.2 Years
Meh, I don't listen to tiers. Probably because I don't IV/EV train my Pokemon and battle competitively. But if I did, I would use any Pokemon I want, even if it was considered useless.

If Magikarp can beat an uber team, then the tier list is kinda wrong to me anyway.
Have fun getting a Magikarp to beat an Uber team with Giratina on it. :P
SkythurBathandBeyond151

Mew~
The New Species Pokémon
Height ~ 0.4m
Weight ~ 4.0Kg


♥Pair♥
♠Brother♠
♫Friend Code♫


♪Theme♪
♣Credits♣

Aurafire

provider of cake

Age 32
Male
New York
Seen April 25th, 2017
Posted November 8th, 2011
5,735 posts
15 Years
No one is saying you can't use UU/NU pokemon in OU or even Uber battles. Take the tiering levels with a grain of salt if you wish. But you forget the Smogon and its members don't determine tiering based only on usage. They identify suspects that may need to move up or down in tiering and go through hours and hours of testing to determine where said suspects should be. If you're saying that someone else could do a better job in determining tiering based on actual empirical data, then you're quite wrong.

You're also dead wrong in saying that stats have anything to do with tiering. Just because a lower-tier pokemon may have higher stats than an OU pokemon doesn't mean that it should be OU as well. Slaking has some of the best base stats in the game...So you're saying it should be OU simply by that fact? Truant totally ruins it and makes it totally prediction-reliant. Take Gardevoir: When played correctly, it can be useful in OU as a support pokemon. But being useful in OU doesn't mean it should in fact be there. The point is, most players will overlook Gardevoir in favor of more reliable options. Once again, that doesn't mean you can't use it. But know that there is a reason why the most successful OU teams use, surprise surprise, the most overused pokemon.

You also can't compare Gardevoir and Alakazam, as both play incredibly different roles. Obviously, Gardevoir is more of a support pokemon, while Alakazam is oriented more towards sweeping. Pretending like one could do the job of the other is ridiculous. How can you possibly justify that Gardevoir is "better" than Alakazam by only basing your opinion on a comparison of the two?

Rampardos and Aggron are jokes in OU, despite their stats. Once again, stats have nothing to do with tiering, or even the pokemons usefulness. Ramparos is among the slowest and most fragile pokemon in the game, and a huge attack stat which it cannot take advantage of doesn't make it worthy of a higher tier.

Once again, no one is saying you can't use UU/NU pokemon in OU. But the hard data will always tell you that you're almost always statistically more likely to lose if you do. But hey, if you think that they work, then go for it.

wolf

he/him
Seen 1 Hour Ago
Posted October 23rd, 2022
8,259 posts
14.7 Years
How can you prove Shoddy contains noobs? If your rating is low in Shoddy, of course it will pair you up with noobs until you rise up the ladder (same if you don't go on Shoddy much). If you base it on the chatroom, which only like 8 people use. That is a very small amount compared to who are online at the time (which is around 100 people). I've been on a lot of Wi-Fi/Shoddy communities, and Shoddy has roughly the same amount of good battlers Wi-Fi does. I also know a lot of Wi-Fi battlers that frequently use Shoddy (here, and other forums).

If you don't like tiers, tough. You don't need to follow their tiers, there are plenty of people out there that I don't follow them either. If you want Gardevoir in OU, just convince everyone to use it. That's how Umbreon made it to OU. Smogon is not saying Rampardos sucks because it is NU, if you like it, use it, no one is stopping you. Just because Rampardos is not the current "trend", doesn't mean it sucks.

You also have the tiering wrong on how it works. I would explain, but I don't feel like typing a wall of text.

Edit: Aura beat me. ;o;
.

Niprop

The Fighting Porygon Team

Male
Somewhere Between the Internet and Reality
Seen January 25th, 2012
Posted January 23rd, 2012
846 posts
14.7 Years
Also, they were considering making a special tier for Primeape and Quagshire and similar Pokes that do poorly in OU, but are great in the Uber tier. Forgot where I heard it though, so it might not be official...

The dynamics also change dramatically in Double Battling. Wobuffet drops in efficiency due to the fact that you are no longer forced to hit it and get instant-koed by a counter, and can even gang up on it, and Slacking can be Gasto-Acided by support to show those snoddy OUs that rejected it who's boss. Minun and Plusle are also a bit more useful here, though I still wouldn't suggest using them.

Many things go in determining the dynamics of a Po
kémon, so what's listed isn't necessarily true in all types of play.

Also, Gardevoir is seeing an upage of use, particularly in Double Battles with Gallade. This is for Real (no offense to Shoddy) battling though, so Smogon might not record this...
´ 3`) official gulpin emote. ^.^Help gulpin take over the Internet and use him for your signature!
"Yay! Yay! ♪ Perfect Apple! ♪ Perfect Apple! ♪"
- Wigglytuff
"Geodudes are really tough."- Random kid from Pokémon Commercial
"Dragonite for the win!"- Lance
"Are you kidding me? Not my Chikorita!"- Random kid from other Pokémon Commercial

Apostrophe

Everybody do the search dance!

Male
Seen November 10th, 2010
Posted November 8th, 2010
256 posts
13.8 Years
Arguing for (or against) the tiers is useless. People will always find new ways to use underused Pokemon in some crazy, well-thought-out strategy. In the end, the people who write the tiers are just saying "Hey, here's what's being used a lot, and here's what's not being used very much". They're not trying to tell you what to use, just what is being used.
Pokemon news from the future:
2017: Team Galactic makes alternative energy breakthrough by making car that runs on ground-up Bidoofs.
No ethics complaints whatsoever, supply in Sinnoh expected to run out "sometime after the sun stops burning".

PM me for more news.
Age 30
Male
Mt. Silver, Laughing at Red
Seen December 9th, 2009
Posted September 7th, 2009
178 posts
14.3 Years
I've never used Smogon before, and I still beat my friend who copies EVERYTHING they do. I'm glad you brought this point up, it gives me a reason to keep ignoring it.
An evil plan that includes sending a L17 Ratatta against a trainer who has already beaten 7 gyms, the usual. Those evil bastards. ;)

:t250: Future Heart Gold owner
Age 33
Male
Australia
Seen January 18th, 2010
Posted December 15th, 2009
46 posts
13.7 Years
Smogon is not 'wrong'. They don't claim that their tiering system is necessarily relevant to WiFi or a true indication of the Pokémon's battling prowess. Tiering is done based on ShoddyBattle because statistics can be easily acquired from the servers; only Nintendo can tell you how many of x Pokémon are used in WiFi battles.

I agree with your general points that people shouldn't rely on ShoddyBattle data being representative of WiFi and that many NU/UU Pokémon are underrated, but those are problems with the community's assumptions, not with Smogon's system.

Also, despite my fondness for Gardevoir, it can't really counter Vaporeon/Jolteon all that easily due to the tendency for them to carry Shadow Ball/Signal Beam =/
Seen December 21st, 2009
Posted September 14th, 2009
2 posts
14.6 Years
Porygon2 is a better user of Trace than Gardevoir for the most part (if you're actively using Trace to counter stuff), because it can use it to counter DDSalamence and pretty much every Gyarados out there, whereas Gardevoir (even after tracing an Intimidate) can't stay in comfortably against either. It can also switch in on most Flygon (Trace Levitate to dodge Earthquake and unboosted Outrage does like 40% to physically defensive P2), which Gardevoir can't because it's liable to take a hefty chunk of damage from U-turn. And yeah, Porygon2 takes no damage from Shadow Ball/Signal Beam, so it switches in Jolteon and Jolteon is screwed. Gardevoir does have the advantage in its support moves though, but I tend to run pokemon that are good at what it does, and if I want a support pokemon I'd rather use Uxie/Cresselia/Jirachi/Celebi because they're better at supporting. Gardevoir is more of a "niche" pokemon that can do some support and use Trace to shakily check Heatran/Vaporeon/Specsjolt/Flygon, but niche pokemon tend to be high-maintenance (they can only show their full potential in a narrow selection of teams), and I very much perfer having a pokemon to fit a team, rather than having a team fit a pokemon.

Anyways, note how the tiers are called "Overused" and "Underused" and not "High tier" or "Low tier"? Tiers tell you of things that are commonly used, not things that are powerful or not. Though there is a certain relationship between power and usage, it is not an extremely strong one. Scizor is #1 pokemon used at the moment, beating Salamence (the #2 pokemon) by a wide margin of 30%+, but I dare say for most people, getting a switch-in against Salamence is a much more daunting task than getting a switch-in against Scizor. Salamence can run so many equally dangerous and unpredictable sets that whatever your salamence switch-in is, you can maybe expect it to survive the encounter half the time. However, while Salamence remains a good selection on many offensive teams, Scizor can happily fit itself in just about every non-outright-stall team there is, having the most powerful priority in the game that does not require your opponent to attack.

That is just an example in the difference between usage and power - pokemon that can prove itself useful in more situations often gets picked over other pokemon. I can give another example - Look at rampardos. 165 atk is juicy, but every single other stat is crap and basically it is comparable to, to quote the an article in the latest The Smog, "a fat, ugly man with a huge penis." It may have the raw power, but it is extremely difficult to get it to do anything, and for many players it is a chore to try to build a team just so Rampardos can sweep comfortably, especially since so many things can go wrong and those kind of "specialized teams" tend to fall apart as soon as something in the team breaks.

Finally, if you REALLY want something in OU THAT badly, then simply get on Smogon's shoddy server and use it over and over and over again. If you can use them successfully all the better, as people will eventually get tired of losing to truly useful sets and use them themselves which serves further to increase its usage count. Look at electivire - it is commonly laughed at by a whole bunch of people, yet it steadily keeps its place in the 30something rank every month (much to the chagrin of previously mentioned whole bunch of people), because people WILL use them. Same goes to Ninjask, really, and to use a less offensive example, Roserade will likely become OU in the next tiering change because it is now used so frequently as a powerful lead.

Archer

NSW, Australia
Seen January 26th, 2020
Posted January 5th, 2020
3,956 posts
16.7 Years
According to smogon users, the first factor that divides tiers up and the most important is how many people use them. Not on Wi-Fi though, oh no. Just on Shoddy Battle, a battling simluation program where people test teams and battle for fun. This means that only the more intellectual battlers use it and people who use Pokémon such as Pikachu do not exist, thus making Pokémon like Pikachu NU dispite the fact it is used in almost every kids Platinum team. This is a problem in itself.
I'm sorry. In many cases, Shoddy Battlers are better, as the metagame shifts more, as teams are more easily changed. You get a lot more noobs using Wifi, which is where you get your Pikachu teams. Wifi also warps the tiers, as legendary or more difficult to obtain pokemon are used less, so their real usage is not gauged properly.

By the way, Shoddy is used because they can record usage stats. Not because they want to spite you. The system is fine as it is. Enough said. Go on, post this is S&M where the real players are. You'll get a remarkably different set of replies to what you've been getting.

Anti

return of the king

Non-binary
Kobe's Reality
Seen March 6th, 2022
Posted January 17th, 2022
10,818 posts
15.8 Years
The other S&M regulars have already said what needs to be said, but a few things...

According to smogon users, the first factor that divides tiers up and the most important is how many people use them. Not on Wi-Fi though, oh no. Just on Shoddy Battle, a battling simluation program where people test teams and battle for fun. This means that only the more intellectual battlers use it and people who use Pokémon such as Pikachu do not exist, thus making Pokémon like Pikachu NU dispite the fact it is used in almost every kids Platinum team. This is a problem in itself.
Yeah, but kids with Pikachu on their Platinum team aren't playing competitively. You're using an ingame statistic to argue against common practices in competitive battling. That doesn't make any sense.

The next factor, according to smogon users is movepool and stats. Now this is completely wrong because there are plenty of NU Pokémon with stats equal or better than that of an OU Pokémon. Lets compare one, shall we?
This is almost entirely false. NU Pokemon generally have horrible stats compared to OU Pokemon. Movepool only matters if the Pokemon has the stats to abuse it. Even the super powerful NU Pokemon like Slaking, Medicham, and Rampardos all have very huge faults. Slaking is a joke in the hgiher tiers because of Traunt (it's set-up bait), and the other two are horribly frail and have pretty lacking Speed.

Tl;dr - Smogon is wrong, they're tiering Pokémon up based on the same Pokémon that are used over and over again. All people do now is grab the first set they see on Smogon and throw together a pretty darn predictable team. This can be seen on Serebii Wi-Fi chat, check it out there.
Um, tiering is just grouping Pokemon based on usage. How can organizing something be "wrong"? That doesn't make any sense. There isn't anything that says that you can't use lower tier Pokemon in OU matches, and the fact that people don't should tell you something about how good (AKA bad) those Pokemon are. If you want to get upset with players for only using OU Pokemon or not being original, be my guest, but you can't blame the tiering system for that. A lot of Pokemon that aren't used much now were tried out and didn't work. The metagame has been pretty thoroughly explored at this point, so it's not like things are being overlooked. If you want to complain about Smogon's tiers having a negative impact on WiFi battling, I'm not the person to argue against you since I've never been on WiFi in my life. at the same time, you can't just ignore the impossibility of collecting stats from every WiFi battle that happens, so this is the best Smogon or any Pokemon community can do.

Generally your argument seems to harp on the bad points of OU Pokemon and only the good points of NU. (Where is the mention of Rampardos having only one good stat and awful typing? Aggron's horrible weaknesses?) You can't be selective with facts and then say act like the facts support your position. The tiering system is by no means perfect, but the notion that NU Pokemon are just as good as OU Pokemon is absurd.
Why are the beautiful sick and divided like myself?