3rd Gen ~*!*~RSE VS FRLG~*!*~

Started by ~*!*~Tatsujin Gosuto~*!*~ September 14th, 2009 5:01 PM
  • 5215 views
  • 16 replies
  • Public Poll

~*!*~PICK ONE~*!*~

thegeneticway

"He has kickin' powers"-Trixie

Age 26
Male
California B)
Seen January 22nd, 2017
Posted December 2nd, 2012
415 posts
13.8 Years
I like RSE.

The Battle Frontier was awesomesauce.
Hey.
I'm Roger! Call me Genetic if you prefer, but I really don't mind ^-^

Replaying Emerald!

Goals:

National Dex Completed
All 7 Gold Symbols
Master of Contests

... looks like i have a long way to go

Sydian

fake your death.

Age 30
they/them
Georgia
Seen May 22nd, 2022
Posted November 29th, 2021
33,354 posts
15.2 Years
FRLG weren't great remakes, in my opinion. They're also my least favorite in the series. RSE gets my vote here.
BURY ME SIX FEET DEEP COVER ME IN CONCRETE
twitter | twitch | youtube
Female
The Golden State
Seen February 22nd, 2013
Posted January 24th, 2010
393 posts
17.5 Years
FrLg for sure. I did not like Hoenn at all. Too many water routes, boring new Pokemon, not enough of the good old Pokemon (and a lot of the ones they included weren't that great), and just all-around not fun. FrLg I felt struck a good balance between keeping true to the originals and adding enough new content to make the game more interesting. The Sevii Islands were a great after-story adventure, and I enjoyed the remixed music.
this is a signature.

scyfer

Veteran Trainer

Age 29
Male
Nimbasa City
Seen December 27th, 2019
Posted December 27th, 2019
141 posts
13.8 Years
FrLg for sure. I did not like Hoenn at all. Too many water routes, boring new Pokemon, not enough of the good old Pokemon (and a lot of the ones they included weren't that great), and just all-around not fun. FrLg I felt struck a good balance between keeping true to the originals and adding enough new content to make the game more interesting. The Sevii Islands were a great after-story adventure, and I enjoyed the remixed music.
this says it all, hoenn was crappy

credit: Reminiscing
Age 27
Male
PAL, GMT+2
Seen November 5th, 2015
Posted November 15th, 2012
203 posts
13.7 Years
I'll have to say Emerald, even though I never owned it. I would have liked the Battle Frontier... (I don't have Platinum, looking forward to HG for BF.) The only Hoenn game I have is a pirated Ruby. <_< I have FR as the real thing, but it sucks they took so many features out of it that were in R/S/E. Time being the biggest one.
STONESOUR HOUSE OF GOLD&BONES
I love both LeafGreen and Emerald. The rest are not that fun.

And as reported, inside the codes of RSE, there are a lot of Johto Music, especially Ruby, Like Route 23, Rocket Battle Music, Crystal Legendary Dogs Battle Music...

Also, Ruby and Sapphire, well, has a storyline. R\B\FR\LG is just the normal be-champ-and-defeat-rocket. Emerald is more like be-champ-encounter-two-epic-teams-and-try-to-stop-Groudon-Kyogre-Awaken-Rayquaza-Battle Frontier-Epic-Underwater. Who wins?

Except for the fact my first game was a LeafGreen, I would've chosen RSE. However, I've chosen both.
Age 26
Male
Norwa-BLEH
Seen September 21st, 2011
Posted June 10th, 2010
486 posts
13.8 Years
I voted both. I like FRLG as I like Kanto better than Hoenn (and I also think most of Hoenn's pokemon were just stupid) but then again, Emerald has an epic storyline that FRLG just can't seem to match for me.

I feel the starters were best in RSE though. IMO, Venusaur and Blastoise weren't all that great. Charizard, Sceptile, Swampert and Blaziken kicks ass.

When I get to borrow my friend's FR, i'll choose Charmander just for the sake of gettting Suicune. (I have a Modest Charizard in Emerald already - Hallelujah!)

So to be honest, I feel that both FRLG and Emerald are some really great games.
Platinum
Name: Damn!
Code: 2622 3796 5477
SoulSilver
Name:
Lyra
Code:
1419 9416 3991 (Use THIS FC unless told otherwise)

SoulSilver: Currently doing: Wifi Battling.

Wins: 34
Losses: 10
Male
Seen December 23rd, 2009
Posted November 29th, 2009
51 posts
13.7 Years
FR/LG
A. they are easier to hack
B. it's a classic

but i hate the way they changed charizard from good (R/B/Y)
to REALLY BAD.
i'm everyone, everywhere, just look behind you, i may just be there..

SIG UNDER CONSTRUCTION.
reason: trying to make a banner for my secret ROM.
PM me if you think i should post it here