One Piece in America

Started by Tonitonichopchop September 23rd, 2009 4:14 AM
  • 3433 views
  • 38 replies
Age 30
Male
Israel
Seen December 2nd, 2009
Posted November 11th, 2009
62 posts
14.8 Years
As I think back, I realize how unpopular One Piece is in the US compared to Naruto and Bleach. I've always wondered why One Piece failed in America. Was it the 4kids version? Was it a lack of appeal to Americans? I think One Piece is one of the greatest series out there, but is far from as popular as Bleach or Naruto even though all of these are good series. So the question is where did One Piece go wrong?
I've always thought it wasn't the 4kids version, but more about how the series started out. Naruto starts out midly interesting since Naruto is aiming to be Hokage (A clearly definable title as the one who guards the village) and he's in Ninja training, Ichigo becomes a soul reaper right away in Bleach with loads of interesting combat scenes right away, but One Piece starts out with a kid aiming to be the pirate king (And no one knew what the hell that was when the series started) and I think it caused people to think the show/manga was boring. Mind you that's just my opinion of course, but what does everyone else think?

Harmonie

Winds ღ

Age 34
She/her
The Bible Belt. >_<
Seen 7 Hours Ago
Posted 1 Day Ago
1,002 posts
16.2 Years
It's because One Piece requires an open mind to enjoy. it takes a while to get started and has a different artstyle (although I still don't see what's so bad about the artstyle!).

Since a lot of the casual anime fans are the instant gratification type they overlooked One Piece and went for Naruto and Bleach.

And of course 4Kids did not help. But even if FUNimation had dubbed it from the start there still would have been loads of people who were too close-minded to give it a chance.

~Signature Artwork from (DA) queen-of-dark-elves
Age 30
Male
Israel
Seen December 2nd, 2009
Posted November 11th, 2009
62 posts
14.8 Years
The thing I disliked the most about this series was just the art style. I hated the character designs and I guess I'm just not interested in the story either. :(
I think that people like yourself who hate the art style are into other, more familiar anime. I don't think the art style is bad, just different. I usually don't tend to care about the art style unless it gets in the way of the story (Such as poorly drawn situations where you can't tell heads or tails about whats what). By the way, did you watch the 4kids version or the funi dub or what? That might be a reason you didn't like it. Go to kaizoku fansubs and watch the arlong arc (It's about episode 31 to 45). This is where I think the series really took off. If you don't like One Piece after watching these eps I don't know what to tell you.

twocows

The not-so-black cat of ill omen

Age 32
Male
Michigan
Seen February 19th, 2023
Posted April 30th, 2021
4,307 posts
14.2 Years
It doesn't air on American television, does it (asking honestly here; I'm not sure). The other two are both on Adult Swim, and that audience is pretty big. The more viewers you have, the more they spread the word about a series, and the more viewers you get to spread the word to more viewers who spread... etc.
VNs are superior to anime, don't @ me
Age 30
Male
Israel
Seen December 2nd, 2009
Posted November 11th, 2009
62 posts
14.8 Years
It doesn't air on American television, does it (asking honestly here; I'm not sure). The other two are both on Adult Swim, and that audience is pretty big. The more viewers you have, the more they spread the word about a series, and the more viewers you get to spread the word to more viewers who spread... etc.
Yes, you're correct that One Piece does not air on American television. I agree with you that being on Adult swim definetly boosts the popularity of certain anime, but is Naruto even on Adult Swim? Anyway, I think Bleach is the best show for the US for a number of reasons:

It is violent
It starts of very interesting
It isn't Sailor Moon (Sorry fans!)

I could list more but it's uneccassary. If the uncut One Piece dub aired on Adult Swim I think the shows popularity would skyrocket, mainly because the older audience probably isn't aware of the 4kids dub to think it's a childish show O__o

twocows

The not-so-black cat of ill omen

Age 32
Male
Michigan
Seen February 19th, 2023
Posted April 30th, 2021
4,307 posts
14.2 Years
is Naruto even on Adult Swim?
I know it airs (or aired) on American television. I don't know for sure if it airs on Adult Swim, though (I really don't watch anything on there except ATHF and Robot Chicken). I think it airs on there, though. Either that or it airs on Cartoon Network daytime television, which I doubt.
VNs are superior to anime, don't @ me
Age 30
Male
New York City
Seen May 21st, 2016
Posted May 16th, 2016
3,597 posts
15.9 Years
Naruto and One Piece both air BEFORE Adult Swim, in the section that keeps changing names (used to be called Toonami, now who really cares, since I don't watch Cartoon Network much anymore).
lurid/lucid

"I want to tear myself from this place, from this reality, rise up like a cloud and float away, melt into this humid summer night and dissolve somewhere far, over the hills. But I am here, my legs blocks of concrete, my lungs empty of air, my throat burning. There will be no floating away."

Khaled Hosseini

→ Refresh for a different picture
→ White FC: Haruka 0347 0171 1756


whoever disabled my signature:
my signature is not even close to 300px tall.
i dont understand why it was disabled.
Male
Over thar
Seen April 17th, 2020
Posted January 25th, 2018
1,479 posts
14.5 Years
The 4kids dub and the slow pace of the manga(they JUST finished the Alabasta arc in the U.S. manga) is what did it in.

Although there is still hope- Funimation has been uploading episodes to their site and simulcasting the Japanese episodes(at least for now- there have been some video piracy issues arise from it, and they only just recently got approval to start doing it again). And in January, Viz is going to begin releasing five volumes of the manga each month until July due to fan demand, and I think they'll be keeping it in Shonen Jump magazine during that time, skipping ahead of all the volumes they intend to release(why, I dunno....but it's there).

Give it some time- eventually, One Piece will get the attention it deserves.

The Mega Champion

Strategist

Age 33
Male
Ohio
Seen 12 Hours Ago
Posted 1 Day Ago
1,343 posts
15.7 Years
Go away One Piece haters.

>:-(

I LOVE One Piece.

One Piece DESERVES to be aired on TV.

Just like freaking Naruto deserves to be aired on TV.

**** you Cartoon Network

**** YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

>:-(
Controversial person with controversial opinions apparently

Harmonie

Winds ღ

Age 34
She/her
The Bible Belt. >_<
Seen 7 Hours Ago
Posted 1 Day Ago
1,002 posts
16.2 Years
Naruto and One Piece both air BEFORE Adult Swim, in the section that keeps changing names (used to be called Toonami, now who really cares, since I don't watch Cartoon Network much anymore).
No they do not.

One Piece isn't on there anymore and neither is Naruto. However Naruto Shippuden is coming to Disney XD really soon. (I don't know how anybody could miss that news, since all of the crazy fans were complaining so much.)

~Signature Artwork from (DA) queen-of-dark-elves
Age 30
Male
New York City
Seen May 21st, 2016
Posted May 16th, 2016
3,597 posts
15.9 Years
Meant "aired."
Naruto finished this January.
lurid/lucid

"I want to tear myself from this place, from this reality, rise up like a cloud and float away, melt into this humid summer night and dissolve somewhere far, over the hills. But I am here, my legs blocks of concrete, my lungs empty of air, my throat burning. There will be no floating away."

Khaled Hosseini

→ Refresh for a different picture
→ White FC: Haruka 0347 0171 1756


whoever disabled my signature:
my signature is not even close to 300px tall.
i dont understand why it was disabled.

Harmonie

Winds ღ

Age 34
She/her
The Bible Belt. >_<
Seen 7 Hours Ago
Posted 1 Day Ago
1,002 posts
16.2 Years
I think that people like yourself who hate the art style are into other, more familiar anime. I don't think the art style is bad, just different. I usually don't tend to care about the art style unless it gets in the way of the story (Such as poorly drawn situations where you can't tell heads or tails about whats what). By the way, did you watch the 4kids version or the funi dub or what? That might be a reason you didn't like it. Go to kaizoku fansubs and watch the arlong arc (It's about episode 31 to 45). This is where I think the series really took off. If you don't like One Piece after watching these eps I don't know what to tell you.
I don't know... I still think that Water 7 and afterwards are where it gets REALLY good. Although, of course the three big arcs before that (Arlong, Skypeia, and Alabasta all had their moments.)

But seriously, Water 7 it just seems to take a big step up. But I maybe biased because my favorite scene is in the Enies Lobby arc.

Although personally I wouldn't tell anybody to skip over anything except for fillers if they're watching the anime. One Piece is an series that largely builds up upon itself. If you watch it all you will be used to the artstyle and you'll really like the characters because you've got adjusted to them. (Luffy very much so. I didn't like him so much when I first watched One Piece, but now he is one of my very favorite characters.)

Once you really care for the characters you realize how great the series really is.

~Signature Artwork from (DA) queen-of-dark-elves

Taichi

The Keyblader of The Future

Seen September 14th, 2012
Posted September 14th, 2012
428 posts
16.7 Years
Hate me all you like, but I actually like the 4kids version. YA YO YA YO YA YO!!! That theme song is one of the things 4kids did right and got me on the show. (And in the end that's 4kids job, to introduce to anime.) I like the fansubs also. Personally prefer the ya yo ya yo ya yo version though. I really have no idea why it failed so much in america. IMO, the Funi version redid voice actors that did it in. (I can honestly say that I like 4kids Luffy AND Sanji, lollipop and all.)

Harmonie

Winds ღ

Age 34
She/her
The Bible Belt. >_<
Seen 7 Hours Ago
Posted 1 Day Ago
1,002 posts
16.2 Years
You... liked... 4Kids... Sanji...?

There are no words.

Poor Sanji was probably the one that got the worst treatment in the 4Kids dub.

~Signature Artwork from (DA) queen-of-dark-elves
Female
Insert Location Here
Seen October 18th, 2009
Posted October 10th, 2009
3,918 posts
18.3 Years
I think what really didn't help One Piece gain ground in the US was the 4KIds dubbing. I personality love the 4Kids dub but I can see where some people may not like it. The dub was kind of butchered ('kind of' being used loosely here) and some people had issues with the voices. The pacing could be a problem but the thing is that One Piece really does find a pacing by the time Buggy gets going. The Buggy arc help set things up but the awesome stuff that defines how the show will be is in Arlong. If you weren't in love with ONe Piece by Arlong then your chance of clicking with One Piece is low. The thing that a lot of people had gained a prejudice against 4Kids dubs that they already wrote off ONe Piece as a failure and thus a good chunk of the fanbase was lost.

It also didn't help that Cartoon Network treatment of the show. One Piece clearly didn't get the same treatment that Naruto got when it premiere and was being shown. Naruto got the custom commercials while ONe Piece got jammed in Toonami commercial moments. One Piece also got jerked around and pulled off normal airing a good amount of times if anybody remember correctly. Sometimes One Piece would be off the air for months at a time and then put back on with new episodes. While Naruto got new episodes each time. Similar treatment was done when it was on FoxBox except once they took it off the air. It stayed off the air until Cartoon Network put it back on.

One thing I want to bring up is that Cartoon Network of Australia was able to finish the Skypiea. So it had to been popular down there.

I just think that One Piece never had that right treatment to get that chance that it needed to be big. Things like art style and stuff can be get over since there are popular shows like Shin Chan who have a huge following but 'lacking' animation style. Right now it seems like Funi and Toei are doing their best to make One Piece get that right treatment. DVDs that have subbed and dubbed options. Getting the manga up to par. All they need now is to get One Piece back on TV here in the US and they be set. Which is possible seeing that Naruto is going to be on Disney XD. If Naruto does good there then Toei may think about pushing to get One Piece on Disney XD too with FUni dubs.

EDIT: I liked 4Kids Sanji. He is the only Sanji I would cosplay as. haha

Pearl FC: 0516-3886-8747
Platinum FC: 0817-9631-0675


The funny thing about temporary is that you never know if it is actually temporary or permanent.
Age 30
Male
Israel
Seen December 2nd, 2009
Posted November 11th, 2009
62 posts
14.8 Years
I think what really didn't help One Piece gain ground in the US was the 4KIds dubbing. I personality love the 4Kids dub but I can see where some people may not like it. The dub was kind of butchered ('kind of' being used loosely here) and some people had issues with the voices. The pacing could be a problem but the thing is that One Piece really does find a pacing by the time Buggy gets going. The Buggy arc help set things up but the awesome stuff that defines how the show will be is in Arlong. If you weren't in love with ONe Piece by Arlong then your chance of clicking with One Piece is low. The thing that a lot of people had gained a prejudice against 4Kids dubs that they already wrote off ONe Piece as a failure and thus a good chunk of the fanbase was lost.

It also didn't help that Cartoon Network treatment of the show. One Piece clearly didn't get the same treatment that Naruto got when it premiere and was being shown. Naruto got the custom commercials while ONe Piece got jammed in Toonami commercial moments. One Piece also got jerked around and pulled off normal airing a good amount of times if anybody remember correctly. Sometimes One Piece would be off the air for months at a time and then put back on with new episodes. While Naruto got new episodes each time. Similar treatment was done when it was on FoxBox except once they took it off the air. It stayed off the air until Cartoon Network put it back on.

One thing I want to bring up is that Cartoon Network of Australia was able to finish the Skypiea. So it had to been popular down there.

I just think that One Piece never had that right treatment to get that chance that it needed to be big. Things like art style and stuff can be get over since there are popular shows like Shin Chan who have a huge following but 'lacking' animation style. Right now it seems like Funi and Toei are doing their best to make One Piece get that right treatment. DVDs that have subbed and dubbed options. Getting the manga up to par. All they need now is to get One Piece back on TV here in the US and they be set. Which is possible seeing that Naruto is going to be on Disney XD. If Naruto does good there then Toei may think about pushing to get One Piece on Disney XD too with FUni dubs.

EDIT: I liked 4Kids Sanji. He is the only Sanji I would cosplay as. haha
Hate me all you like, but I actually like the 4kids version. YA YO YA YO YA YO!!! That theme song is one of the things 4kids did right and got me on the show. (And in the end that's 4kids job, to introduce to anime.) I like the fansubs also. Personally prefer the ya yo ya yo ya yo version though. I really have no idea why it failed so much in america. IMO, the Funi version redid voice actors that did it in. (I can honestly say that I like 4kids Luffy AND Sanji, lollipop and all.)
I find the love torwards 4kids in this thread as slightly disturbing, but nevertheless I agree with you charizard_maa, if Naruto does well on disney xd they could (But very unlikely) push to have One Piece air also. If that happens I think that that alone would cause the fanbase to grow by a considerable margin.

p.s.

Taichi, there is no way in Hell that funi is responsible for One Pieces poor popularity. The ratings for One Piece actually grew when the edited Skypeia arc aired on Cartoon network (Edited by funi of course).

Taichi

The Keyblader of The Future

Seen September 14th, 2012
Posted September 14th, 2012
428 posts
16.7 Years
Okay, that may be biased on my part. I just like the 4kids One Piece rather than Funi One Piece. DO NOT mistaken that as a "I like 4kids better than Funi" post because that's not the case, I just liked a particular version of the anime rather than the other. I love Funimation. (DBZ, YuYu, FMA, awesome.) I just like One Piece 4kids. Like it or not, 4kids did their job and introduced me to One Piece. Afterwards, I picked up the manga and it was awesome. I wouldn't be a fan of One Piece if it wasn't for 4kids. Just saying.

YA YO YA YO YA YO!!!
Age 30
Male
Israel
Seen December 2nd, 2009
Posted November 11th, 2009
62 posts
14.8 Years
Okay, that may be biased on my part. I just like the 4kids One Piece rather than Funi One Piece. DO NOT mistaken that as a "I like 4kids better than Funi" post because that's not the case, I just liked a particular version of the anime rather than the other. I love Funimation. (DBZ, YuYu, FMA, awesome.) I just like One Piece 4kids. Like it or not, 4kids did their job and introduced me to One Piece. Afterwards, I picked up the manga and it was awesome. I wouldn't be a fan of One Piece if it wasn't for 4kids. Just saying.

YA YO YA YO YA YO!!!
I actually started One Piece with the 4kids version also. It was great when I was younger, and don't get me wrong, the rap was probably the best part about the show, but the quality when comparing it to the japanese or the funi version is lacking in my opinion. Also, and I'm honestly curious when I ask this, but what did you like about the 4kids version better?

Taichi

The Keyblader of The Future

Seen September 14th, 2012
Posted September 14th, 2012
428 posts
16.7 Years
Honestly. The voice actors I liked. Specifically Luffy and Sanji. I know Sanji got murdered with the accent and all but I liked the accent, with the lollipop as a censor. It added something very unusual to an unusual character. The Funi voice actors on OP just don't appeal to me. I'm sorry....lol.
Age 30
Male
Israel
Seen December 2nd, 2009
Posted November 11th, 2009
62 posts
14.8 Years
Honestly. The voice actors I liked. Specifically Luffy and Sanji. I know Sanji got murdered with the accent and all but I liked the accent, with the lollipop as a censor. It added something very unusual to an unusual character. The Funi voice actors on OP just don't appeal to me. I'm sorry....lol.
I see. I actually hear from a lot of people that they like the 4kids Luffy more than the funi Luffy. As for Sanji, the accent definetly adds to his original character. I don't know about you, but the nasaly voice just got super annoying after a while. The lolipop I also thought was really strange for one reason; wouldn't that ruin the flavor of the food? Another question I have is what you watched after the 4kids and Manga, or did you stop watching after that?

The Mega Champion

Strategist

Age 33
Male
Ohio
Seen 12 Hours Ago
Posted 1 Day Ago
1,343 posts
15.7 Years
OMFG....

You've GOT to be kidding me...

4KIDS ******* RAPED ONE PIECE IN THE ASS HARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

How could you people like that?!

I've lost ALL respect I had left for this board.

I hope you realize that, and I hope you're happy about that.

I KNOW I'M NOT.

>:-(

FUNIMATION IS DOING AN AWESOME JOB WITH ONE PIECE. AT LEAST THEIR NOT RAPING IT. IN FACT, THEY'RE DOING TEN TIMES BETTER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LEAVING THE EPISODES UNCUT AND UNEDITED WHICH IS HOW ALL ANIME SHOULD BE LEFT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Who gives a **** about the voices?! I know I don't!!!!!!!!!!

The voices are FINE.

WTF is wrong with you people?!

Geez!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

>:-(
Controversial person with controversial opinions apparently

Male
the town on no map
Seen September 16th, 2022
Posted July 12th, 2022
3,340 posts
14.2 Years
OMFG....

You've GOT to be kidding me...

4KIDS ******* RAPED ONE PIECE IN THE ASS HARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

>:-(
Calm down. :laugh:

Yes, I find it hard to believe that some people actually like the 4kids dub of One Piece. To each their own I guess.

Harmonie

Winds ღ

Age 34
She/her
The Bible Belt. >_<
Seen 7 Hours Ago
Posted 1 Day Ago
1,002 posts
16.2 Years
Wow...

I PERSONALLY would prefer Luffy's 4Kids voice if the voice actress would have used emotion and not yelled all of the time. I think that otherwise the voice was good. I know that Colleen (FUNimation Luffy) is working her hardest, but I personally... well, I don't know. Tanaka is just the best voice for Luffy! (I believe that Luffy was one of the character's that Oda actually built around a voice actor/actress. I know that sounds ridiculous but I've read it in interviews.)

But the rest of the 4Kids voices are ranging from alright to just downright horrible, while the rest of the FUNimation voices are either perfect fits or very acceptable. (Well except for Franky, but we haven't really heard him yet... not enough anyways.)

I can not understand how anybody could even stand Sanji's 4Kids voice. It was horrible. I feel bad for the voice actor that was told to do that voice, as well. Please... Eric Vale is a much better Sanji.

4Kids only introduced the anime to America, by the way. The manga was here long before. I first saw One Piece in a Shonen Jump issue in 2003. Of course back then I didn't know what it was, but it was unedited. Zoro was Zoro, not Zolo. There was blood... And real guns. :o

I went with the anime in the end and saw more of One Piece through CN's 4Kids dub than Shonen Jump (not by much at all, though. XD), but I still will not deny that the dub was bad and hindered One Piece's popularity. I will not give them credit for anything either. I still would have watched the subbed One Piece either way. I believe I was influenced to check it out because it was so popular, not from what I saw on CN.

~Signature Artwork from (DA) queen-of-dark-elves