If a tree falls in a forest...

Started by Miz en Scène October 20th, 2009 11:37 PM
  • 1820 views
  • 64 replies

Miz en Scène

Everybody's connected

Male
The Wired
Seen 2 Days Ago
Posted August 30th, 2016
1,645 posts
14.7 Years
This is not something to do with nature more than it is to do with science.

The question, as I'm sure some of you have heard at least once in your life is
"If a tree falls in a forest and nobody is around to hear it, does it make a sound?"

It looks like a simple question though it carries a deeper meaning. "Can something exist without being perceived?" or "Can we assume the unobserved world functions the same as the observed world?"This is akin to the Schrodinger's Cat thought experiment if it's easier for you to comprehend it that way.

Basically, sound is just the vibration of particles in the air that are caught by our eardrums and converted into nerve impulses which are detected by the brain and interpreted. Therefore, in the absence of the ear or any living body to experience the tree falling, did the tree even make a sound or fall in the first place? This theory is known as Immaterialism by the way.

Well, does it make a sound?
» Fiction «
Havisham
SWC 2011
» Fanfiction «
The Rainbow Chasers
SWC 2016 (1st Place)
——
The Promise I Made to You
SWC 2012 (2nd Place)
——
The Best
Pokecreepypasta Entry 2010
——
Using Firefox and see a scrollbar?
Tell me so I can fix it! (Hopefully)
» TBD «

Want a fanfic review?
Just ask me!

Got a review from me?
Pay it forward!
Drop a comment or a review on someone else's fic. I'm sure they'll appreciate it!
Female
In my reality.
Seen November 6th, 2009
Posted November 6th, 2009
192 posts
13.6 Years
Well how do peoples supposed to know that? When peoples are around while the tree falls peoples can hear it. So maybe yes and maybe no. When no peoples are around it might not make a sound, you never know. xD but seriously now, in my opinion i do think tree makes sounds while it falls in the forest whether peoples are around or not.

Miz en Scène

Everybody's connected

Male
The Wired
Seen 2 Days Ago
Posted August 30th, 2016
1,645 posts
14.7 Years
Well how do peoples supposed to know that? When peoples are around while the tree falls peoples can hear it. So maybe yes and maybe no. When no peoples are around it might not make a sound, you never know. xD but seriously now, in my opinion i do think tree makes sounds while it falls in the forest whether peoples are around or not.
I think you don't understand the question. :/

By scientific definition,
sound is just the vibration of particles in the air that are caught by our eardrums and converted into nerve impulses which are detected by the brain and interpreted
In the absence of a receiver, how can it be called sound when it's merely the vibration of matter?
» Fiction «
Havisham
SWC 2011
» Fanfiction «
The Rainbow Chasers
SWC 2016 (1st Place)
——
The Promise I Made to You
SWC 2012 (2nd Place)
——
The Best
Pokecreepypasta Entry 2010
——
Using Firefox and see a scrollbar?
Tell me so I can fix it! (Hopefully)
» TBD «

Want a fanfic review?
Just ask me!

Got a review from me?
Pay it forward!
Drop a comment or a review on someone else's fic. I'm sure they'll appreciate it!

Miz en Scène

Everybody's connected

Male
The Wired
Seen 2 Days Ago
Posted August 30th, 2016
1,645 posts
14.7 Years
Cogito ergo sum.

It makes a sound but nobody cares, especially if it doesn't affect them.
Not the point... Trees do not think, scientifically speaking. Religiously speaking on the other hand...

Cogito ergo sum means, I think therefore I am. Which roughly translates to, I'm doing the thinking about whether I exist therefore I'm here. What does that have to do with what you just said?

Must I repeat the point?
Can something exist without being perceived?
» Fiction «
Havisham
SWC 2011
» Fanfiction «
The Rainbow Chasers
SWC 2016 (1st Place)
——
The Promise I Made to You
SWC 2012 (2nd Place)
——
The Best
Pokecreepypasta Entry 2010
——
Using Firefox and see a scrollbar?
Tell me so I can fix it! (Hopefully)
» TBD «

Want a fanfic review?
Just ask me!

Got a review from me?
Pay it forward!
Drop a comment or a review on someone else's fic. I'm sure they'll appreciate it!

Guillermo

i own a rabbit heh

Age 28
Australia
Seen April 11th, 2015
Posted May 18th, 2014
6,794 posts
14.8 Years
Of course it would make a sound. Not that anyone would care, anyway.

And yes, something can exist without being perceived. It's all a matter of ones opinion on the thing existing. Like if something happens between a family and the father goes, "I don't have a son!" the son still exists, even if the father doesn't perceive him to.
credittoDukey
one life, one chance


| | le deux | | so-so-soulful

Ho-Oh

used Sacred Fire!

Age 31
Female
QLD, Australia
Seen June 5th, 2022
Posted April 23rd, 2022
35,988 posts
17.5 Years
If a camera was on record, and you came back later... you'd hear it when it's replayed. [/logic]

It wouldn't make a sound at that time, however.

Miz en Scène

Everybody's connected

Male
The Wired
Seen 2 Days Ago
Posted August 30th, 2016
1,645 posts
14.7 Years
If a camera was on record, and you came back later... you'd hear it when it's replayed. [/logic]

It wouldn't make a sound at that time, however.
That would mean that it was perceived by something or someone. The question is that if nothing perceives it does it exist?
Seriously, did all of you just tl:dr the first post?

And yes, something can exist without being perceived. It's all a matter of ones opinion on the thing existing. Like if something happens between a family and the father goes, "I don't have a son!" the son still exists, even if the father doesn't perceive him to.
The son however (cogito ergo sum) perceives that he exists therefore he exists...
» Fiction «
Havisham
SWC 2011
» Fanfiction «
The Rainbow Chasers
SWC 2016 (1st Place)
——
The Promise I Made to You
SWC 2012 (2nd Place)
——
The Best
Pokecreepypasta Entry 2010
——
Using Firefox and see a scrollbar?
Tell me so I can fix it! (Hopefully)
» TBD «

Want a fanfic review?
Just ask me!

Got a review from me?
Pay it forward!
Drop a comment or a review on someone else's fic. I'm sure they'll appreciate it!
Seen November 18th, 2015
Posted November 17th, 2015
8,170 posts
18.6 Years
Not the point... Trees do not think, scientifically speaking. Religiously speaking on the other hand...

Cogito ergo sum means, I think therefore I am. Which roughly translates to, I'm doing the thinking about whether I exist therefore I'm here. What does that have to do with what you just said?

Must I repeat the point?
Can something exist without being perceived?
Hey dumbass.. What it means is that just because you don't hear it doesn't mean it doesn't make a sound. :O

I think therefore I am.. can also be I think therefore you are.

Miz en Scène

Everybody's connected

Male
The Wired
Seen 2 Days Ago
Posted August 30th, 2016
1,645 posts
14.7 Years
Hey dumbass..
That hurt. ;_;

What it means is that just because you don't hear it doesn't mean it doesn't make a sound. :O
In the absence of a receiver, how can it be called sound when it's merely the vibration of matter?

I think therefore I am.. can also be I think therefore you are.
But then you perceive it to have existed when I asked if no one perceives it does it exist...
» Fiction «
Havisham
SWC 2011
» Fanfiction «
The Rainbow Chasers
SWC 2016 (1st Place)
——
The Promise I Made to You
SWC 2012 (2nd Place)
——
The Best
Pokecreepypasta Entry 2010
——
Using Firefox and see a scrollbar?
Tell me so I can fix it! (Hopefully)
» TBD «

Want a fanfic review?
Just ask me!

Got a review from me?
Pay it forward!
Drop a comment or a review on someone else's fic. I'm sure they'll appreciate it!

Ho-Oh

used Sacred Fire!

Age 31
Female
QLD, Australia
Seen June 5th, 2022
Posted April 23rd, 2022
35,988 posts
17.5 Years
It would've existed at some point, but to humans, if they weren't there at that time they wouldn't have heard it? But yeah, I didn't tl;dr your first post, ... you're just complaining about all of our posts for no real reason. XD

Miz en Scène

Everybody's connected

Male
The Wired
Seen 2 Days Ago
Posted August 30th, 2016
1,645 posts
14.7 Years
It would've existed at some point, but to humans, if they weren't there at that time they wouldn't have heard it? But yeah, I didn't tl;dr your first post, ... you're just complaining about all of our posts for no real reason. XD
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/If_a_tree_falls_in_a_forest

Read it...

And how am I complaining when I'm just countering what you said earlier?
» Fiction «
Havisham
SWC 2011
» Fanfiction «
The Rainbow Chasers
SWC 2016 (1st Place)
——
The Promise I Made to You
SWC 2012 (2nd Place)
——
The Best
Pokecreepypasta Entry 2010
——
Using Firefox and see a scrollbar?
Tell me so I can fix it! (Hopefully)
» TBD «

Want a fanfic review?
Just ask me!

Got a review from me?
Pay it forward!
Drop a comment or a review on someone else's fic. I'm sure they'll appreciate it!

Miz en Scène

Everybody's connected

Male
The Wired
Seen 2 Days Ago
Posted August 30th, 2016
1,645 posts
14.7 Years
Questioning an existence means you are perceiving it as to may have existed. Then someone says yes. Therefore it exists. :O
Then it means you agree with the earlier statement so why must you counter me?
» Fiction «
Havisham
SWC 2011
» Fanfiction «
The Rainbow Chasers
SWC 2016 (1st Place)
——
The Promise I Made to You
SWC 2012 (2nd Place)
——
The Best
Pokecreepypasta Entry 2010
——
Using Firefox and see a scrollbar?
Tell me so I can fix it! (Hopefully)
» TBD «

Want a fanfic review?
Just ask me!

Got a review from me?
Pay it forward!
Drop a comment or a review on someone else's fic. I'm sure they'll appreciate it!
Female
In my reality.
Seen November 6th, 2009
Posted November 6th, 2009
192 posts
13.6 Years
Certainly it will produce sound waves, but is that all you mean by "sound"? If it is, then it absolutely does make a sound. If you take the position that sound is something which is experienced - that it is the sensation produced in a sentient being by sound waves - then it does not not make a sound. Where you draw the line is pretty arbitrary, so I don't think the question is really that interesting, though it certainly sounds interesting the first time you here it.

Miz en Scène

Everybody's connected

Male
The Wired
Seen 2 Days Ago
Posted August 30th, 2016
1,645 posts
14.7 Years
Certainly it will produce sound waves, but is that all you mean by "sound"? If it is, then it absolutely does make a sound. If you take the position that sound is something which is experienced - that it is the sensation produced in a sentient being by sound waves - then it does not not make a sound. Where you draw the line is pretty arbitrary, so I don't think the question is really that interesting, though it certainly sounds interesting the first time you here it.
Which is exactly the question that I'm trying to pose. Thank you for understanding. The point of this thread was to find out what you(the general public) thought of this idea based on your understanding...
» Fiction «
Havisham
SWC 2011
» Fanfiction «
The Rainbow Chasers
SWC 2016 (1st Place)
——
The Promise I Made to You
SWC 2012 (2nd Place)
——
The Best
Pokecreepypasta Entry 2010
——
Using Firefox and see a scrollbar?
Tell me so I can fix it! (Hopefully)
» TBD «

Want a fanfic review?
Just ask me!

Got a review from me?
Pay it forward!
Drop a comment or a review on someone else's fic. I'm sure they'll appreciate it!

Miz en Scène

Everybody's connected

Male
The Wired
Seen 2 Days Ago
Posted August 30th, 2016
1,645 posts
14.7 Years
I don't believe it's sound if nothing hears it.

But I would think there are many animals around it to hear it.
If nothing perceives it.

But I think you get the general idea. XD
» Fiction «
Havisham
SWC 2011
» Fanfiction «
The Rainbow Chasers
SWC 2016 (1st Place)
——
The Promise I Made to You
SWC 2012 (2nd Place)
——
The Best
Pokecreepypasta Entry 2010
——
Using Firefox and see a scrollbar?
Tell me so I can fix it! (Hopefully)
» TBD «

Want a fanfic review?
Just ask me!

Got a review from me?
Pay it forward!
Drop a comment or a review on someone else's fic. I'm sure they'll appreciate it!

♣Gawain♣

Onward to Music!!!

Age 32
Male
Moscow, Russia
Seen December 2nd, 2013
Posted November 29th, 2013
4,997 posts
15.4 Years
Anything makes sound, but when we aren't there to hear it, could it be called "sound"? Animals without hearing organs may have "experience" it, but not through "sound" waves.

It's like observing black holes. We can't see black holes, but we know it existed because of it's disastrous effects on nearby celestial objects. We can undirectly observe it through that means.

VM Δ PMPairsDeviantArtPlaying...ClubsTheme

Gunn

horror resident

Female
California, United States
Seen March 5th, 2022
Posted July 7th, 2012
1,403 posts
17.9 Years
Well, does it make a sound?
Yes. Sound wave generation isn't reliant upon an audience. Hakeen already killed the Immaterialism idea; it's an outdated theory.
blessed mother. 😈

Miz en Scène

Everybody's connected

Male
The Wired
Seen 2 Days Ago
Posted August 30th, 2016
1,645 posts
14.7 Years
Anything makes sound, but when we aren't there to hear it, could it be called "sound"? Animals without hearing organs may have "experience" it, but not through "sound" waves.
The general question states that nothing is around to feel/perceive it.

It's like observing black holes. We can't see black holes, but we know it existed because of it's disastrous effects on nearby celestial objects. We can undirectly observe it through that means.
Basically that means we are perceiving black holes through its effects on other objects and therefore can perceive it in some way...

Yes. Sound wave generation isn't reliant upon an audience. Hakeen already killed the Immaterialism idea; it's an outdated theory.
Sound is only considered sound when it is detected by something. Sound waves are the vibration of particles.Of course it's an outdated theory I'm just wondering what the general public thought of it. I could evoke Schrodinger's Cat if you wanted...
» Fiction «
Havisham
SWC 2011
» Fanfiction «
The Rainbow Chasers
SWC 2016 (1st Place)
——
The Promise I Made to You
SWC 2012 (2nd Place)
——
The Best
Pokecreepypasta Entry 2010
——
Using Firefox and see a scrollbar?
Tell me so I can fix it! (Hopefully)
» TBD «

Want a fanfic review?
Just ask me!

Got a review from me?
Pay it forward!
Drop a comment or a review on someone else's fic. I'm sure they'll appreciate it!

♣Gawain♣

Onward to Music!!!

Age 32
Male
Moscow, Russia
Seen December 2nd, 2013
Posted November 29th, 2013
4,997 posts
15.4 Years
The general question states that nothing is around to feel/perceive it.

Basically that means we are perceiving black holes through its effects on other objects and therefore can perceive it in some way...
Oh well, cancel out the "animal part". XD Still, I still considered it controversial...

And that's the only way to study black holes, through its effects. Since they have only mass, magnetic charge and angular momentum, as stated part of the no-hair theory...

VM Δ PMPairsDeviantArtPlaying...ClubsTheme

Miz en Scène

Everybody's connected

Male
The Wired
Seen 2 Days Ago
Posted August 30th, 2016
1,645 posts
14.7 Years
Oh well, cancel out the "animal part". XD Still, I still considered it controversial...

And that's the only way to study black holes, through its effects. Since they have only mass, magnetic charge and angular momentum, as stated part of the no-hair theory...
Yep, this topic is controversial. :P

And, by studying a black hole through that way you are technically perceiving it in some way such as feeling wind even though you can't see it, or thinking about your spouse even though you can't see her.
» Fiction «
Havisham
SWC 2011
» Fanfiction «
The Rainbow Chasers
SWC 2016 (1st Place)
——
The Promise I Made to You
SWC 2012 (2nd Place)
——
The Best
Pokecreepypasta Entry 2010
——
Using Firefox and see a scrollbar?
Tell me so I can fix it! (Hopefully)
» TBD «

Want a fanfic review?
Just ask me!

Got a review from me?
Pay it forward!
Drop a comment or a review on someone else's fic. I'm sure they'll appreciate it!
Seen April 9th, 2021
Posted February 5th, 2017
6,779 posts
15.5 Years
You have to use analogies to make it work.
If a man dies in the middle of nowhere, does it mean that he didn't die?
Just because humans with their extremely limited knowledge didn't notice it does not mean that what isn't noticed by species like us doesn't exist.
Something can exist without it being perceived, it's just that we won't know about its existence, just like how we think things exist when they most likely don't. Unless of course, you can show me evidence of the existence of snufflecrombabats.