Stereotyped Pokemon

Started by MistahDude July 13th, 2010 6:45 AM
  • 8351 views
  • 57 replies

MistahDude

Primate Pokemon Master

Age 29
Male
Star, Idaho
Seen September 13th, 2010
Posted September 6th, 2010
952 posts
13.5 Years
We have had Stereotyped Pokemon in the past, and it seems like we are getting another one.

If you don't know already I am American and as soon as I saw Wooguru I was happy and kinda weirded out at the same time. Its an honor for Japan to make a American pokemon but at the same time its kinda awkward.

Wooguru is a Red, White, and Blue bald eagle with a Native American Headdress on his head. If that doesn't scream "AMERICA!!!" I don't know what does.


1 - Symbol of America is the Bald Eagle
2 - Native Americans used to own most of the land of America before it was taken from them
3 - Red, White, and Blue are the national colors of America.
4 - Wooguru is a combination of the Japanese words for War and Eagle, and America is known for being one of the strongest countries militarily.

I do not really see a problem with this stereotype like I have with previous stereotypes Nintendo has thrown at us.

Lt. Surge was the LIGHTNING AMERICAN. He was a war veteran and seemed to be War Crazed.

Ludicolo seems to be a Hispanic Stereotype. He has a Sombrero for a head and dances constantly.

Do you guys hope we have more stereotypes? I am okay with them as long as they aren't offensive. The LT. SURGE thing was sort of offensive, as was Ludicolo, but I don't see anything wrong with Wooguru. I could say that his Encourage ability might poke fun at how America has a lot of raw power but doesn't cause anything extra than destruction to happen. (Encourage gives all moves extra power but removes their chances of flinching, burning etc.,)

What do you guys think?

DISCUSS!

Check out my Youtube Channel!: http://www.youtube.com/user/Boarbeque
Check out my Twitter!: http://www.twitter.com/Boarbeque
Age 32
Male
West Portugal
Seen May 4th, 2013
Posted May 3rd, 2013
299 posts
14.1 Years
Wooguru will scream America, don't worry about that.
I don't see anything wrong with this and the other stereotypes you refered. The only negative stereotype Pokémon have is Mr Mime and most of the people don't even notice it, so it didn't become a problem after all. Of course I'll not explain it here because it's totaly innapropriate. Well, I don't really mind to see a red and green Pokémon with a big moustache after all.
All of my posts have passed through

MistahDude

Primate Pokemon Master

Age 29
Male
Star, Idaho
Seen September 13th, 2010
Posted September 6th, 2010
952 posts
13.5 Years
What about the original Jynx? She was a stereotypical black woman at first. Big red lips weave long red dress etc.
No she wasn't. It is sort of racist to think that people dress differently because of their race.

What Jynx is based on is a controversial topic within the fandom, although common interpretations are a Nordic woman (possibly Hel, goddess of the underworld), or ガン黒 ganguro, face-black. Also, the fact that Jynx are depicted as Santa's helpers in the anime can be a proof that Jynx is based on Zwarte Piet. Jynx also has the traits of a female opera singer, especially the iconic cartoon depiction of the fat lady. It should also be noted that the third generation sprites depict it singing, especially the Emerald sprite that animates it signing a high note.
Jynx may also have origins in the Japanese spirits known as Yuki Onna (who has no feet like Jynx) or Yama Uba, the latter of which is described as always wearing a tattered red kimono and having whitish-blonde hair (all traits shared by Jynx).

Check out my Youtube Channel!: http://www.youtube.com/user/Boarbeque
Check out my Twitter!: http://www.twitter.com/Boarbeque

StratusJm

yes, im better then you

Male
Seen July 22nd, 2011
Posted April 11th, 2011
412 posts
12.9 Years
Wooguru will scream America, don't worry about that.
I don't see anything wrong with this and the other stereotypes you refered. The only negative stereotype Pokémon have is Mr Mime and most of the people don't even notice it, so it didn't become a problem after all. Of course I'll not explain it here because it's totaly innapropriate. Well, I don't really mind to see a red and green Pokémon with a big moustache after all.
what stereotype is mr. mime based on?

MistahDude

Primate Pokemon Master

Age 29
Male
Star, Idaho
Seen September 13th, 2010
Posted September 6th, 2010
952 posts
13.5 Years
Wooguru will scream America, don't worry about that.
I don't see anything wrong with this and the other stereotypes you refered. The only negative stereotype Pokémon have is Mr Mime and most of the people don't even notice it, so it didn't become a problem after all. Of course I'll not explain it here because it's totaly innapropriate. Well, I don't really mind to see a red and green Pokémon with a big moustache after all.
what stereotype is mr. mime based on?
He is referring to the conspiracy that Mr Mime is based on all white people. That is entirely false.

Mr Mime is is clearly based on a mime. The clown hair, the way it performs its attacks like a mime, the pointy shoes, the rosy cheeks, the fact that it was in a circus in the anime before becoming Hanako's errand boy, etc...all give away its origin.

So the whole "Mr. Mime is based on white people" argument would only work if Caucasians were stereotyped as being mimes. Last time I checked, they weren't.

Check out my Youtube Channel!: http://www.youtube.com/user/Boarbeque
Check out my Twitter!: http://www.twitter.com/Boarbeque
Age 32
Male
West Portugal
Seen May 4th, 2013
Posted May 3rd, 2013
299 posts
14.1 Years
Well, if you the original Jynx as a black women and Mr Mime, who also only have a pre evo and no evolution, as pair with Jynx, you'll have the black/white person stereotype. But it isn't this that I'm referring to my other post, that I'll not explain here, I'll send pm's if you want.
All of my posts have passed through

Dmatt

Medium-Rare Trainer

Male
Seen November 24th, 2014
Posted January 1st, 2014
112 posts
14.6 Years
I think stereotype is a word a little bit too strong for what we have here. Sure you can say that the eagle is based on American motives, but that's as far as you can go. Any further is honestly an exaggeration.
So if it happens to learn Bounce, is it going to be about America's recession?
If it learns Drill Peck, is it going to be "hiddenly related" to illegal oil drilling?
If it learns Covet/Knock off/Thief... don't wanna go there :p

It's a fun debate but let's just hope it doesn't get blown out of proportion by some groups, because then we'll have another Jynx here, and the color scheme will be unnecessarily changed.
Name: Dmatt/Dan
Pearl : 2538 0185 7851
SoulSilver : 2495 0636 9069
White : 0905 9140 0338

My thread: Trades, EV services, Breeding. Clicky.
Age 20
Male
Seen May 2nd, 2011
Posted May 2nd, 2011
128 posts
13 Years
Annnddddd Pokemon's are animal stereotyped.
Wooguru was going to be awesome, don't destroy it's image with all that.
Yeah I don't see how the bird is even stereotyped. So it screams AMERICA but that doesn't make it a stereotype. Its probably just a Pokemon made to symbolize a certain country. But I don't think this bird is stereotyped I mean what is it saying? All Americans go around with a Native American Headress on?


Azure-Supernova

Trainer of mediocre Champions!

Age 30
Male
UK, England
Seen March 8th, 2011
Posted August 4th, 2010
263 posts
14.5 Years
I think you're looking into it a little too much... can't you just see it for what it is without creating connotations? It's not like American (though not exclusively) artists have never poked fun at Japan or the asian community before.

Sure some people found Jynx offensive, PC idiots. Ludicolo is the same, what is there to find offensive? Taking something recognized world-wide for being associated with the Mexican nation: Sombreros and then picking out something else completely at random, associated with hispanic cultures: Dancing. Thrown in a poncho and presto, Ludicolo.

If they released a Pokémon that walked around in a pork pie hat with a walking stick and a bone china tea cup on his little finger, I wouldn't be offended. If it's call sounded like "crumpets!" I wouldn't really mind (except that this is a terrible idea for a Pokémon). Yes some people are going to be offended, but what by? It's satire, we see far worse on South Park and Family Guy, other shows of that ilk, now it's used in an innocent context and there's objections?

Far as I can tell, I don't look at Wooguru and see a war hungry bald eagle, ready to snatch some land. I see a Pokémon that looks pretty sweet. And a lot of nations used Red, White and Blue in their flags (and have been doing so for hundreds of years). It's just as much America's national colours as they are Frances' or Russias'.



I don't calculate stat values, I don't breed my way to perfection, and I don't care about natures. I catch my Pokemon the way they are, and treat them like individuals instead of brainless drones.

Heart Gold 2021 - 3748 - 2668
Male
Betwixt Hither and Thither
Seen November 26th, 2021
Posted November 30th, 2011
426 posts
13.1 Years
You know... there is a difference between using a stereotype and being racist. Ludicolo was based off of pinatas and mariachi singers. Wooguru is an eagle in the Native American style (which, by the way, is wildly popular among certain subcultures in Japan right now). I understand the Jynx thing, but to the Japanese people who created her, it was probably more of an homage to black-face comedy than it was a racist thing. Especially since she is paired with Mr.Mime, who represents "white-face" comedy.

I see nothing wrong with Wooguru, and hope that people don't blow it out of proportion.
Currently Playing Pokémon White, and loving it

My showcase thread, featuring Fakemon (like a Pachirisu evolution and Legendary Unown), new types (Light
and Glass), and new items.

MistahDude

Primate Pokemon Master

Age 29
Male
Star, Idaho
Seen September 13th, 2010
Posted September 6th, 2010
952 posts
13.5 Years
You know... there is a difference between using a stereotype and being racist. Ludicolo was based off of pinatas and mariachi singers. Wooguru is an eagle in the Native American style (which, by the way, is wildly popular among certain subcultures in Japan right now). I understand the Jynx thing, but to the Japanese people who created her, it was probably more of an homage to black-face comedy than it was a racist thing. Especially since she is paired with Mr.Mime, who represents "white-face" comedy.

I see nothing wrong with Wooguru, and hope that people don't blow it out of proportion.
Im not saying anything is wrong with Wooguru. I actually like him.

Check out my Youtube Channel!: http://www.youtube.com/user/Boarbeque
Check out my Twitter!: http://www.twitter.com/Boarbeque

Bloothump

the Sea Fungi Pokemon.

Male
Colorado
Seen March 4th, 2012
Posted March 2nd, 2012
254 posts
13.1 Years
Stereotype = assumptions of traits made about a group of people that share a common origin.
Wooguru, is not a stereotype. Yes, he's very American, and I for one think it's great that the "American Pokemon" is this cool. I mean, he's probably my favorite flying type. Perhaps he's the final evolution of Mamepato, which would make me change my whole beleifs about flying types. (I've always seen them as an obligation rather than a good edition to the team)

the real fifth gen. starters

Mortalis

dreadnaught

Age 26
Male
Canada
Seen October 19th, 2020
Posted May 12th, 2017
345 posts
13 Years
Game Freak and Nintendo feed off of Stereotypes for inspiration for their characters / creatures. It's what gives a realism to the gaming world, allowing you to be sucked in and be familiarized with the world around you, making it more comfortable, and wanting to play more.

I like Wooguru; I'm Canadian, but the symbol of him from America makes me feel more comfortable with the game, seeing as I like America, and Isshu is closely represented by America.

All in all, it's a good Pokemon to have now.

MistahDude

Primate Pokemon Master

Age 29
Male
Star, Idaho
Seen September 13th, 2010
Posted September 6th, 2010
952 posts
13.5 Years
Game Freak and Nintendo feed off of Stereotypes for inspiration for their characters / creatures. It's what gives a realism to the gaming world, allowing you to be sucked in and be familiarized with the world around you, making it more comfortable, and wanting to play more.

I like Wooguru; I'm Canadian, but the symbol of him from America makes me feel more comfortable with the game, seeing as I like America, and Isshu is closely represented by America.

All in all, it's a good Pokemon to have now.
Wouldn't it be cool if Isshu was America and it was connected to a region above it that was based off of Canada?

Check out my Youtube Channel!: http://www.youtube.com/user/Boarbeque
Check out my Twitter!: http://www.twitter.com/Boarbeque

Biggee30

The Oldschool Hip-Hop Fan

Age 30
Male
San Jose, California
Seen September 30th, 2010
Posted September 11th, 2010
30 posts
14 Years
How can you be offended by Ludicolo? I mean, I'm a latino, and I found Ludicolo to be very cool. Unles they named him something else, like... actually I won't go into it. I'd only be offended if they represented latinos in a more racist way, like if they had it eating a certain type of seed that I won't mention.
Check out my drawings + comment on them at: http://s977.photobucket.com/albums/ae254/Biggee30/
Age 28
Male
Oregon
Seen September 24th, 2018
Posted July 3rd, 2018
17,520 posts
13.1 Years
How can you be offended by Ludicolo? I mean, I'm a latino, and I found Ludicolo to be very cool. Unles they named him something else, like... actually I won't go into it. I'd only be offended if they represented latinos in a more racist way, like if they had it eating a certain type of seed that I won't mention.
I'm latino too and I also don't see it offensive either :)
I'm currently working on some novels. If you're interested you can read them here:
https://www.wattpad.com/user/ImperialSun
Age 30
Male
New York City
Seen May 21st, 2016
Posted May 16th, 2016
3,597 posts
15.9 Years
Yea, really. I don't think it's fair to call a Pokemon stereotypical if it's supposed to be iconic. If I were a hippo, I'd say that Hippopotas is offensive because it learns Yawn and I certainly DO NOT eject bubbles from my mouth when I yawn.
lurid/lucid

"I want to tear myself from this place, from this reality, rise up like a cloud and float away, melt into this humid summer night and dissolve somewhere far, over the hills. But I am here, my legs blocks of concrete, my lungs empty of air, my throat burning. There will be no floating away."

Khaled Hosseini

→ Refresh for a different picture
→ White FC: Haruka 0347 0171 1756


whoever disabled my signature:
my signature is not even close to 300px tall.
i dont understand why it was disabled.
Age 31
Male
Australia
Seen November 29th, 2016
Posted August 14th, 2011
919 posts
13.6 Years
Not all americans are fat. Snorlax would fit more in at Japan as a sumo wrestler IMO.
No one said stereotypes were accurate. But that is an American stereotype. Not that Snorlax was an example; that was a joke. :P

Yea, really. I don't think it's fair to call a Pokemon stereotypical if it's supposed to be iconic. If I were a hippo, I'd say that Hippopotas is offensive because it learns Yawn and I certainly DO NOT eject bubbles from my mouth when I yawn.
Is ejecting bubbles from their mouths a stereotype about hippopotamuses?

Anyway, I think Pokemon based on stereotypes as long as they're not negative ones.