• 8658 views
  • 8 replies
Age 29
Male
England
Seen September 7th, 2021
Posted May 5th, 2013
485 posts
13.9 Years
Not sure if this is an ideal place for this, but I've posted it in other places with little feedback.

Warning: big image.
Spoiler:


Now, I'm looking for suggestions about where to place additional locations from the anime, manga and other games. Equally, any feedback about my placement of regions is welcome.

Amore

Seen 8 Hours Ago
Posted 4 Days Ago
5,237 posts
13.7 Years
Dude....you did your IMG tags wrong......all it shows is a faulty link (faulty as it incorporates the latter [ /IMG] tag as part of the url)

Spoiler:






I've put your image in my own spoilers...:D

It's a good image, and goes with the general consensus on pokémon....but personally I reckon Isshu/Unova looks out of place and you should've just ignored it, as it's common knowledge that it's based around New York...which is probably nearer when you head East than West.

EDIT: Also, if that one you've put a little West of Johto which has map points but no routes is meant to be Orre....I'm pretty sure the general consensus is that Orre is Arizona...and a lot more desert-ish than that, so you might want to either alter that or just get rid of it....nice placement though!

Kirbychu

Still looking for Mirage Island
Seen August 20th, 2021
Posted July 28th, 2020
2,347 posts
13.9 Years
Dude....you did your IMG tags wrong......all it shows is a faulty link (faulty as it incorporates the latter [ /IMG] tag as part of the url)

Spoiler:






I've put your image in my own spoilers...:D


You failed too, let me show you guys how it's done! xD

Spoiler:


First of all I want to say that the map looks fantastic, great job.

Wow, you actually portrayed the Battle Zone in Sinnoh correctly. Most people just make it a tiny island without any further research, which really bugs me. O.e


As mentioned before, Isshu is confirmed to be based off New York, so it should be in its own box or something. The whole Orre and Arizona thing is questionable too, but the Orre region seems to be a nice fit where you have it.
Age 29
Male
England
Seen September 7th, 2021
Posted May 5th, 2013
485 posts
13.9 Years
I've fixed the IMG tags now. xD Dammit. I was in a rush.
It's a good image, and goes with the general consensus on pokémon....but personally I reckon Isshu/Unova looks out of place and you should've just ignored it, as it's common knowledge that it's based around New York...which is probably nearer when you head East than West.
As mentioned before, Isshu is confirmed to be based off New York, so it should be in its own box or something.
I looked for somewhere to the right of Japan where there was enough room, but as I couldn't, I decided to put it up in that corner. I don't think it looks *too* awful, but I might add a box if it does.

Also, if that one you've put a little West of Johto which has map points but no routes is meant to be Orre....I'm pretty sure the general consensus is that Orre is Arizona...and a lot more desert-ish than that, so you might want to either alter that or just get rid of it....nice placement though!
The whole Orre and Arizona thing is questionable too, but the Orre region seems to be a nice fit where you have it.
I went with the notion that all of Orre's Pokémon are from Hoenn and Johto, so it makes sense for it to be between the two. It is based off the area around Phoenix, yes, but it seemed too good a fit to put it somewhere else. I'll work on terrains at some point, so the desert'll come there.

First of all I want to say that the map looks fantastic, great job.

Wow, you actually portrayed the Battle Zone in Sinnoh correctly. Most people just make it a tiny island without any further research, which really bugs me. O.e
Thanks! ^_^ I thought I might as well put Sakhalin where it actually is instead of leaving it hanging. :3
hey wats/where orre for?
Come again? O.o
Male
Hiougi City
Seen April 12th, 2020
Posted September 11th, 2014
2,543 posts
14 Years
Wow, you actually made Unova fit. Even though it's based on New York, it's still "far away" from the other regions which are all on close pieces of land. Fantastastic job mate!

Also, it looks like Unova will be the new Kanto, with ti's own Johto. It seems connected to someplace else. It'll fit the whole Pokemon re-branding thing.

I prefer the first map xD
3DS Friend Code: 1204-0601-9485
Pokémon X
Post on my wall if you add me so I can add you!

Oryx

CoquettishCat

Age 30
Female
Seen January 30th, 2015
Posted December 27th, 2014
13,184 posts
12.2 Years
Hey,

It's against the rules to revive an old thread, even if it's your own. Feel free to make a new thread with the image though! Make sure you follow the 4 word rule though as well.


Theme * Pair * VM * PM

Not all men...

Are all men stupid?

That's right.