Dragonite Ernston
I rival Lance's.
- 149
- Posts
- 13
- Years
- Seen Jun 15, 2016
I've posted this on both Bulbagarden and Serebii now, and thought that the more "hardened" and "experienced" reviewers and writers here could give their thoughts.
Now, we agreed that the "Bulbapedia Method" was not going to be an acceptable name for the first method, but nobody else could come up with one that works.
Also, there actually isn't a poll, but that's because this is a secondary thread.
Zekurom said:Lately, I've been seeing a noticeable split between people who put the names of Pokémon in caps the "Bulbapedia" way (basically, the official way) and those who put it in lowercase with the justification that nouns like "animal", "mouse", and "dragon" aren't capitalized either. It's not just a select few anymore that leave the species names in lowercase.
This applies to items and moves, too. You say "potion", I say "Potion". Everyone seems to do it a different way.
These are the main conventions that I see (and the options on the poll):
- The Bulbapedia method (the official method, also known as the German method)
- Capitalize all names of Pokémon species, and items as they appear in the games.
- Capitalize all names of moves, wherever they appear as moves.
- Example sentence: The Pokémon Trainer used a Potion on his Squirtle, returning him to his Pokéball and hopping on his Bicycle to rush to the Viridian City Pokémon Centre.
- Example sentence 2: "Squirtle, Tackle that Pidgey!" said the Trainer, commanding the Squirtle to use Tackle.
- Example sentence 3: The Electrode shot a Thunderbolt at the Mudkip, who proceeded to eat the Oran Berry it was holding. The Mudkip then ran away, searching for other Berries.
- The Context-dependent Bulbapedia method
- Capitalize all names of Pokémon species, and items as they appear in the games.
- An exception is made for objects that are exactly the same as they are in real life. (e.g. bicycle, running shoes, trainer)
- Do not capitalize names of moves that are also verbs, when they are used as verbs. (e.g. tackle, bite, scratch)
- All other move names should be capitalized as they are in the Bulbapedia method.
- Example sentence: "The Pokémon trainer used a Potion on his Squirtle, returning him to his Pokéball and hopping on his bicycle to rush to the Viridian City Pokémon Centre."
- Example sentence 2: "Squirtle, tackle that Pidgey!" said the trainer, commanding the Squirtle to use Tackle.
- Example sentence 3: The Electrode shot a Thunderbolt at the Mudkip, who proceeded to eat the Oran Berry it was holding. The Mudkip then ran away, searching for other berries.
- The Pokémon-only method
- Capitalize all names of Pokémon species as they appear in the games.
- Do not capitalize the names of items or moves. They are not treated as proper nouns. (In some variants, only the items are left in lowercase.)
- Example sentence: "The Pokémon trainer used a potion on his Squirtle, returning him to his pokéball and hopping on his bicycle to rush to the Viridian City Pokémon centre."
- Example sentence 2: "Squirtle, tackle that Pidgey!" said the trainer, commanding the Squirtle to use Tackle.
- Example sentence 3: The Electrode shot a thunderbolt at the Mudkip, who proceeded to eat the oran berry it was holding. The Mudkip then ran away, searching for other berries.
- The Common Noun method
- Do not capitalize the names of species, only the names when they are used as proper nouns.
- Do not capitalize the names of items or moves, except when a move name is used as a proper noun. (In some variants, the proper-noun exception here does not exist. In which case, the "Tackle" in example sentence 2 should be lowercase.)
- Example sentence: The pokémon trainer used a potion on his squirtle, returning him to his pokéball and hopping on his bicycle to rush to the Viridian City pokémon centre.
- Example sentence 2: "Squirtle, tackle that pidgey!" said the trainer, commanding the squirtle to use Tackle.
- Example sentence 3: The electrode shot a thunderbolt at the mudkip, who proceeded to eat the oran berry it was holding. The mudkip then ran away, searching for other berries.
In the above rules, "used as a proper noun" means that it is grammatically a proper noun because it does not have an article (e.g. "the", "a", "one") preceding it, and it is not a plural noun. Take the sentence "Meet Squirtle, my Squirtle." The first Squirtle is used as a proper noun, and the second one is not.
So I'm just interested, fanfic writers. What convention do you use? You can justify your case if you want to, but I don't want this thread turning into a flame war about which which method is the right one.
Now, we agreed that the "Bulbapedia Method" was not going to be an acceptable name for the first method, but nobody else could come up with one that works.
Also, there actually isn't a poll, but that's because this is a secondary thread.