3-D vs. 2-D In Pokemon Games

Started by Akula February 23rd, 2011 2:13 PM
  • 6917 views
  • 40 replies
Age 26
Male
Florida
Seen May 14th, 2011
Posted February 27th, 2011
34 posts
12.2 Years
Well, I keep getting agitated with the new 3-D type of graphics Game Freak started using since D/P/P. I miss the simpler days with R/S/E and FR/LG.
It seems the games seem to feel more childish each new one.
I mean, I loved Emerald so much when it first came out. The graphics were awesome, and I loved the pokemon.
Now the new 3-D feel of Diamond/Pearl/Platinum and Soul Silver/Heart Gold and Black/White kind of ruins the game for me.
Am I the only one?
The Shark From The Deep

Team Aqua
Currently Working on Columbine Blue.

The 100 Mega Shock

Male
Seen March 10th, 2013
Posted March 23rd, 2012
1,234 posts
12.7 Years
It seems the games seem to feel more childish each new one.
I honestly can't fathom how 3D graphics of all things would make a game "feel more childish"

Personally I'm all for the games jumping to a completely 3D polygonal overworld and characters for the next-gen Pokémon instalments. It offers far more flexibility with the camera and the ability to pull off very impressive views which are currently being kinda held back by still using sprites for the overworld characters (Even though BW tries to pull off camera angle changing now the sprites mess up the effect). It also allows you to do more with the characters such as changing the models and texture of their outfits which would involve more work with sprites, or even allowing you to adjust the player's physical characteristics.

I also think there's a bit of rose-tinted glasses going on with the graphics of the RSE games because frankly they have some really awful tiles compared to the graphics in FRLG.
I'm going to move this over to Pokemon Gaming Central since this deals with the games and graphics.

I do find the older graphics nostalgic, but often times I can't continue to play my older games due to the poor graphics. I'm just too used to the cleaner look of the games now. So for me it's the opposite. The older the graphics the more likely the game is ruined for me.
Age 26
Male
Florida
Seen May 14th, 2011
Posted February 27th, 2011
34 posts
12.2 Years
I honestly can't fathom how 3D graphics of all things would make a game "feel more childish"

Personally I'm all for the games jumping to a completely 3D polygonal overworld and characters for the next-gen Pokémon instalments. It offers far more flexibility with the camera and the ability to pull off very impressive views which are currently being kinda held back by still using sprites for the overworld characters (Even though BW tries to pull off camera angle changing now the sprites mess up the effect). It also allows you to do more with the characters such as changing the models and texture of their outfits which would involve more work with sprites, or even allowing you to adjust the player's physical characteristics.

I also think there's a bit of rose-tinted glasses going on with the graphics of the RSE games because frankly they have some really awful tiles compared to the graphics in FRLG.
The 3-D feel just aggravates me. I mean, in the old games such as Fire Red, Leaf Green, Ruby, Sapphire, Emerald, and so forth, the graphics were total pixel art and 2-D. As the games progress, it's more 3-D and not so much as pixel art anymore.
It's losing the overall feel. :|
In Soul Silver, you can see many errors in the tiling and to be frank, it just ruins the game.
The Shark From The Deep

Team Aqua
Currently Working on Columbine Blue.

champagnepapi

exile

Male
new england
Seen September 4th, 2016
Posted June 25th, 2016
1,795 posts
12.5 Years
I prefer 3-D over 2-D, there's no reason to still be using tiles that look flat and use a diminutive amount of colors when the developers have the ability to do so
much more, graphically. I still appreciate GSC and FRLG styled graphics, when used in fangames and whatnot, but I prefer to play a 4th Gen game and walking through
an aesthetically pleasing overworld. I'm not in love with all of the 5th Gen Graphics, but I'm sure I'll get used to them.

paired to kaori & vrai

The 100 Mega Shock

Male
Seen March 10th, 2013
Posted March 23rd, 2012
1,234 posts
12.7 Years
In Soul Silver, you can see many errors in the tiling and to be frank, it just ruins the game.
I'd be very interesting in seeing these errors because I must have not noticed them when I was playing the game. I found HGSS was the point where Game Freak got more experienced with 3D graphics and making a pleasant game to look at.
Age 26
Male
Florida
Seen May 14th, 2011
Posted February 27th, 2011
34 posts
12.2 Years
I'd be very interesting in seeing these errors because I must have not noticed them when I was playing the game. I found HGSS was the point where Game Freak got more experienced with 3D graphics and making a pleasant game to look at.
In the tower place in the second city, when it shakes, the background gets messed up. Same in the gym some tiles are messed up.
At that point I set the game down. I'm not playing a game like that. Luckily I got it for twenty bucks with another video game from Best Buy.
The Shark From The Deep

Team Aqua
Currently Working on Columbine Blue.
Male
Glasgow, Scotland.
Seen November 13th, 2019
Posted October 14th, 2014
239 posts
13 Years
I first thought the 3D didn't really work in D/P but then I grew to love it.

HG/SS used a more cartoony 3D which worked aswell, and made the game "childish" as you put it, so I don't see how you can fault it.

I haven't played B/W yet, but from what I've seen the graphics look different but I'm sure I'll like them in the end :)
Male
Canada
Seen March 12th, 2011
Posted February 23rd, 2011
20 posts
12.2 Years
The the 3D felt awkward in Diamond and Pearl, due to the position of the blatantly 2D character near 3D tiles. However, in some areas like Spear Pillar, the 3D features were quite nice and made the area feel very unique.

I think the new overworld sprites in Black & White mix much better than the old Diamond & Pearl ones. Hopefully, the graphics continue to improve until we see a true 3D Pokemon game.

feelselectricman.

The 100 Mega Shock

Male
Seen March 10th, 2013
Posted March 23rd, 2012
1,234 posts
12.7 Years
Pokémon's entire graphical style has been heading in this way for a long time. It wants to look like a cartoon - look at any of the game intros or anything that shows the game graphics in a larger format.

In the tower place in the second city, when it shakes, the background gets messed up. Same in the gym some tiles are messed up.
I honestly cannot see what you're talking about here, and I think that's a very silly reason to put such a good game down for some vague things about tiles.

Sydian

fake your death.

Age 30
they/them
Georgia
Seen May 22nd, 2022
Posted November 29th, 2021
33,354 posts
15.2 Years
I personally don't care. The graphics aren't really groundbreaking for me nor do they annoy me. The most that annoys me about any game is DPPt's grass color. It's ugly. But as for 3D vs. 2D, I have no preference. I just wanna enjoy the gameplay.

And for the record, I find Black/White to be the least childish of all the games. I don't see how the graphics are "childish" at all. They feel grown up to me.
BURY ME SIX FEET DEEP COVER ME IN CONCRETE
twitter | twitch | youtube

The 100 Mega Shock

Male
Seen March 10th, 2013
Posted March 23rd, 2012
1,234 posts
12.7 Years
Yeah uh I don't see much change in the style between DP/HGSS/BW either.

Just a continuing improvement in the quality of the 3D graphics and their tile artists producing better thing. The biggest change is probably in adding outlines to many 3D assets to make them look better against other parts of the world and more use of alternate camera angles in BW.

champagnepapi

exile

Male
new england
Seen September 4th, 2016
Posted June 25th, 2016
1,795 posts
12.5 Years
In the tower place in the second city, when it shakes, the background gets messed up. Same in the gym some tiles are messed up.
At that point I set the game down. I'm not playing a game like that. Luckily I got it for twenty bucks with another video game from Best Buy.
That's your loss, really. HG/SS made the perfect transition from 2D to 3D, most of it's tiles looking nothing short of spectacular. The second city in the game is Cherrygrove City, and if memory serves, there is no tower there.

paired to kaori & vrai
Age 26
Male
Florida
Seen May 14th, 2011
Posted February 27th, 2011
34 posts
12.2 Years
Pokémon's entire graphical style has been heading in this way for a long time. It wants to look like a cartoon - look at any of the game intros or anything that shows the game graphics in a larger format.



I honestly cannot see what you're talking about here, and I think that's a very silly reason to put such a good game down for some vague things about tiles.
Nah. I just disliked the game all together. I enjoyed the older games much more than this one. Not because of nostalgia either, mostly because of more planned out games.
"Mr. Pokemon" Seems to be quite unoriginal... The other games were at least somewhat original.
The Shark From The Deep

Team Aqua
Currently Working on Columbine Blue.
Female
Route 30
Seen November 27th, 2011
Posted June 12th, 2011
3 posts
12.3 Years
Yeah, uh... No.

Game Freak isn't going to go back to R/S/E/FR/LG's graphics. Why would they use GBA graphics when the 3DS is coming out and they can do even MORE than they are now graphics-wise?

I see nothing wrong with the current graphics, besides the occasional lines at the edge of the screen. But hey, who cares. I play games for gameplay, not for graphics.

And what are you talking about? HG/SS had beautiful graphics, in my opinion. I loved what they did with the Sprout Tower, it looks just as good as it did back in the GBC era.

Seriously, go compare the HG/SS Sprout Tower and the G/S/C Sprout Tower. It looks exactly the same, except more colorful. The G/S/C Sprout Tower looked horrible, in my opinion. It looked like they were just shifting pixels, but with the 3D look of HG/SS it made it work.

EDIT: lolwut? Mr.Pokemon was in the original games as well. >___>
PM/VM me if you add my 3DS FC!

BenjiTheKid

Cooltrainer Benji

Non-binary
Spring Lake, NC
Seen August 24th, 2014
Posted May 19th, 2011
496 posts
14.3 Years
I enjoy the nostalgia of playing the old games as much as the next person, but to be honest, the graphics in R/B/Y and S/G/C weren't that great. That was always the one thing I didn't like about the games. Crystal seemed to improve (if I remember correctly... not sure if the improvement started in Crystal or Silver/Gold?) but it still wasn't the best. R/S/E brought better graphics and I was impressed. But I still don't miss the graphics. I miss everything about Pokemon 'back in the day' but the graphics.

I admit, the first time I played my sisters copy of Diamond, the graphics gave me a headache. Am I the only one that feels the tiles literally... move. Like, not just your person, but the entire scene seems to move when you walk... I don't know, but the whole 3-Dish thing took some getting used to. But when I got Platinum and finally got used to it, I prefer it to the graphics in Emerald version when I play it. I prefer SS's overall look, too. Emerald looks kind of bland in comparison.

EDIT:
besides the occasional lines at the edge of the screen.
Glad to know I'm not the only one who's noticed that. Heh... I thought I was going crazy.

'When you find an Escape Rope in a cave... you just know you're going to be in there for a while.'

LeafGreen|SoulSilver|Emerald|Platinum|Black
Male
Stuck in Generation 3 :(
Seen July 23rd, 2017
Posted June 9th, 2017
1,761 posts
14.8 Years
I honestly can't fathom how 3D graphics of all things would make a game "feel more childish"

Personally I'm all for the games jumping to a completely 3D polygonal overworld and characters for the next-gen Pokémon instalments. It offers far more flexibility with the camera and the ability to pull off very impressive views which are currently being kinda held back by still using sprites for the overworld characters (Even though BW tries to pull off camera angle changing now the sprites mess up the effect). It also allows you to do more with the characters such as changing the models and texture of their outfits which would involve more work with sprites, or even allowing you to adjust the player's physical characteristics.
I agree with a lot of this, but I haven't played BW for myself so I can't accurately judge yet. I do notice some sprite pixelization in screenshots, though.

I also think there's a bit of rose-tinted glasses going on with the graphics of the RSE games because frankly they have some really awful tiles compared to the graphics in FRLG.
Gwah? OK, now I definitely disagree. >_> I don't have a problem with tiles, though; it's just a minor issue with the overworld sprites. I played Sapphire first, and FireRed later on. Red's overworld sprite in FireRed looks...primitive or something to Brendan's overworld sprite in RSE. I can't describe it well...



(Bulbapedia doesn't have any good isolated Brendan sprites, so those will have to suffice...)

This would be a better comparison if I had Red's RSE sprite (when viewing link battles with FRLG in Emerald, Red and Leaf have redesigned sprites. Similarly, when viewing link battles with RSE in FRLG, Brendan and May get redesigned sprties, which look very different from the RSE variants, IMO).

Anyway, the 3D in DPPt/HGSS and BW looks amazing, and I haven't even played the games yet. Most of what I've gleaned are from screenshots. HGSS's renderings of Kanto buildings and wilderness look much more pleasing compared to the FRLG renderings.

In the tower place in the second city, when it shakes, the background gets messed up. Same in the gym some tiles are messed up.
At that point I set the game down. I'm not playing a game like that. Luckily I got it for twenty bucks with another video game from Best Buy.
OK, this seriously sounds like "The tiles are messed up?! Pokemon is RUINED FOREVER!!!" I can understand cessation of playing if the 3D causes problems/issues with your eyes or something, but if it's just minor errors, that is a very weak reason to just stop playing a game.

I personally have no drastic problems with any of the Pokemon games, and even though I slightly dislike FireRed's overworld sprites, I loved playing through the game and will likely continue to love playing through it, regardless of graphics.
"The balance of power has shifted." Regret | Solemnity | ElitenessIntensity

Currently in intermittent forum activity for 2017. ;_; Credit to Game Freak for avatar and signature. @Fenyx4 on Bulbapedia for more about me. Tune into TOONAMI!
Male
North Carolina
Seen December 5th, 2011
Posted November 28th, 2011
1,431 posts
12.9 Years
I'll admit that the BW sprites looked a little weird when the camera angle shifted, but that is the only problem I've had so far. Pokemon will not stop advancing in graphics until they have something like Colluseum and XD except it's a main series game. ON A HANDHELD SYSTEM. Deal with it.
In progress

Hoenn, 1 Badge
My Youtube Channel: Check out my Pokemon Red Walkthrough
Pokemon White FC: 2322 5491 2643

Graphics don't typically make or break a game for me as much as the gameplay itself. Graphics are nice to have when done right but it's really not a huge factor when I play Pokemon.
Both pseudo-3D and 2D in Pokemon are really nice to me, but the 3D needs to actually -become- 3D so the label is correct. :B

It might be hard for me to get used to full 3D, but it was fun when I played.. say, Pokepark and the Shadow Pokemon games. :] Someday would be nice. :3

Female
Lavender Town
Seen December 24th, 2011
Posted February 24th, 2011
115 posts
12.4 Years
Honestly, there's no point in complaining about it. Whether you like it or not, the graphics are going to keep moving toward 3D. Most people see that as an improvement (although I am aware that some don't).

I for one am very happy with the changes made. I think they have improved the look and feel of the game with each installment and generation. I love the 3D they've added to BW, and I'll be thrilled if they go even further with it in future games/gens.

I. Am. Awesome.

Challenges Completed

Username Challenge
Male
Stuck in Generation 3 :(
Seen July 23rd, 2017
Posted June 9th, 2017
1,761 posts
14.8 Years

Graphics don't typically make or break a game for me as much as the gameplay itself. Graphics are nice to have when done right but it's really not a huge factor when I play Pokemon.
Both pseudo-3D and 2D in Pokemon are really nice to me, but the 3D needs to actually -become- 3D so the label is correct. :B

It might be hard for me to get used to full 3D, but it was fun when I played.. say, Pokepark and the Shadow Pokemon games. :] Someday would be nice. :3

My minor issue about the advancement of 3D is about the actual battle screen. If Game Freak switches from depicting Pokemon with 2D pixelated sprites to using 3D models, exactly what is the point of the console game other than the RPG (already seen in the main series) and the mini-games (they don't exactly make a game; hence the term mini-games)? I'd prefer for the battle screen to continue using animated 2D Pokemon sprites to permit the console games to continue staying in relevance.

I mean, every console game to date has used 3D artwork while the main series handheld games continue to use 2D Sugimori artwork, so 3D does seem to be a main draw for the console games... :\
"The balance of power has shifted." Regret | Solemnity | ElitenessIntensity

Currently in intermittent forum activity for 2017. ;_; Credit to Game Freak for avatar and signature. @Fenyx4 on Bulbapedia for more about me. Tune into TOONAMI!