It's a unique idea, but honestly, I doubt it'll ever really take off in regards of activity. It's not so much the Pokemon but more the way they're grouped together, ie the Amity Square, and it's just less... generalized. Basically, it feels like the only reason they fit together is because they're all allowed in the Amity Square, so it'd be like making a club for route 1 Pokemon, even though they don't really have much in common. But then again, I hardly know anything about the Amity Square, but just from looking at the list of the Pokemon allowed in it, I don't see anything characteristic for the Pokemon that really connects them, apart from the fact that a lot of them are cute Pokemon, and we already have a club for those.
In the end it's up to you whether you want to make the club or not though, since I have nothing against those types of clubs, I just feel like it'd be better for you to pick a club that covers something more general if you really want to make one, as they are more likely to have more interested people. But it's all up to you:)
Not removing this from my signature!
