Off-Topic Hang out with people and talk about whatever. Feel free to suggest a better description for this forum as everyone seems to have an opinion. :D

Thread Tools
Old January 3rd, 2013 (7:48 AM).
antemortem's Avatar
antemortem antemortem is offline
farewell, fated few
  • Crystal Tier
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Texas
Gender: Male
Nature: Naughty
Posts: 7,590
When a movie is first released, whether it be locally or internationally, it garners a certain amount of success, be it a high grossing opening weekend or even a consistent weekly gross for a certain amount of time. Of course, a movie's success, if any, tends to deteriorate over a period of time, and sometimes people will think 'wow, that movie was such a success fifty years ago that we should remake it!'

This is a solid idea; remake a successful movie with even better actors, better cinematic displays and effects, and a few plot twists here and there. Media gold. Sometimes, however, said movie will bomb entirely and will have proved to be an ill-fated attempt at rehashing a dead franchise. The producers of the movie proceed to lose hundreds of thousands if not millions of dollars.

What are your feelings on remakes? Are they typically better than the originals, or have you seen your fair share of bombs? Perhaps it's hit-or-miss with you?
Reply With Quote

Relevant Advertising!

Old January 3rd, 2013 (8:32 AM).
Pinkie-Dawn's Avatar
Pinkie-Dawn Pinkie-Dawn is offline
Vampire Waifu
    Join Date: Dec 2012
    Location: California
    Age: 25
    Gender: Male
    Nature: Quirky
    Posts: 9,516
    Remakes tend to be a hit-or-miss. We get some really good ones such John Carpenter's The Thing and Peter Jackson's King Kong, but most of the time they get panned by critics such as Clash of the Titans and The Day the Earth Stood Still. The Horror genre seems to suffer the most from this issue, leading people to believe that the genre is dying, which means Hollywood is dying as well, thus caused the demand for more pure original blockbuster movies and the abandonment of book/comic/TV show/game/play adaptions and remakes/sequels/reboots.
    Reply With Quote
    Old January 3rd, 2013 (6:56 PM).
    Esper's Avatar
    Esper Esper is offline
    • Silver Tier
    Join Date: Jun 2009
    Location: California
    Posts: 10,703
    Remakes are best when they're done of bad old movies. Ocean's Eleven is a great example. The original was crap, but the remake was great, though the sequels to the remake are a mixed bag.

    I don't really like to see someone remaking a film who's trying to making it darker, edgier, sexier, faster, etc. It seems like lots of remakes are only attempting to update special effects, social norms, and cash in on a younger audience, who'll see the movie because it's got actors they know, while trying to rope in people who liked the original. And when you try to be all things to all people you're probably going to fail which is why it's better to remake something already bad to give yourself a better chance.
    Reply With Quote
    Old January 3rd, 2013 (9:20 PM).
    Toshiro.'s Avatar
    Toshiro. Toshiro. is offline
    • Silver Tier
    Join Date: Apr 2009
    Location: Johto
    Age: 25
    Gender: Male
    Posts: 4,814
    It really depends on the movies. Some remakes are fantastic while others are just horrid and should not even have been attempted. Some remakes I found enjoyable were The Posieden Adventure, which was a remake of Posieden, and When A Stranger Calls, which was a 2006 remake of a film under the same name from 1976.
    Reply With Quote
    Old January 6th, 2013 (8:16 PM).
    stiles's Avatar
    stiles stiles is offline
      Join Date: Jun 2012
      Location: United States
      Nature: Adamant
      Posts: 22
      I find that remakes are almost never as good as the original. I think it's because most of the things I see being remade are from when I was a kid and being a kid just makes most things ten times better.
      Reply With Quote
      Old January 6th, 2013 (9:15 PM).
      Squirrel's Avatar
      Squirrel Squirrel is offline
      • Crystal Tier
      Join Date: Sep 2011
      Location: England
      Age: 23
      Gender: Male
      Nature: Quirky
      Posts: 9,512
      Like Pinkie-Dawn said, remakes usually bring to mind the phrase "hit or miss". They're usually either exceptional and make the previous movie look like a case of "what were they thinking?", or they make the old movie look like gold and the new director look like an idiot; very rarely have I seen a remake which was just as good as the original and not better. I think the best remake that I've seen was Ocean's Eleven since every aspect of that movie got so much better with great new stars and cinematics. I just wish they'd remake some more old classics since it's always really interesting to see a new director's take on an old work.
      Reply With Quote
      Old January 17th, 2013 (9:38 PM).
      Stunna's Avatar
      Stunna Stunna is offline
      Hungry Boy
        Join Date: Mar 2011
        Gender: Male
        Posts: 13
        Sometimes they are necessary or a good idea. Most of the time, they're not.
        Big Screen Bedlam -- Movie Reviews
        ~I'm a Christian, saved by Jesus Christ~
        Reply With Quote
        Old January 17th, 2013 (10:09 PM).
        Sweets Witch's Avatar
        Sweets Witch Sweets Witch is offline
        I just love ham jerky.
          Join Date: Jan 2013
          Location: Old People Community, USA
          Age: 25
          Gender: Male
          Nature: Adamant
          Posts: 1,420
          I like remakes. Some effort is put into them in order to try to reboot a title. It's not like a book-to-movie transition that can be done horrendously and in the end it'll still sell some books on top of whatever measly crap it earned in the box office (Cirque du Freak is my biggest pet peeve in that regard).

          Still, I guess there are some really bad remakes out there. Most of them are horror movies because they're often just made gorier which isn't that big of a deal.
          Reply With Quote
          Old January 18th, 2013 (12:23 AM).
          gimmepie's Avatar
          gimmepie gimmepie is offline
          Funghi's Den
          • Moderator
          • Platinum Tier
          • PokéCommunity Daily
          Join Date: May 2012
          Location: Australia
          Age: 22
          Gender: Male
          Nature: Mild
          Posts: 16,977
          I tend to prefer originals (especially in horror) but there have been a few good remakes such as with 12 Angry Men for example and I'm looking forward to the remake of Carrie coming out this year. Don't get me started on The Nightmare on Elm Street remake though, WHY?!?! Is all I want to know.


          "Looks scary. But gentle hearted."

          Reply With Quote
          Old January 18th, 2013 (1:20 AM).
          Her's Avatar
          Her Her is online now
          • Super Moderator
          • Platinum Tier
          • Discord Moderoid
          Join Date: Jun 2008
          Age: 24
          Gender: Female
          Posts: 10,707
          Originally Posted by Toshiro. View Post
          It really depends on the movies. Some remakes are fantastic while others are just horrid and should not even have been attempted. Some remakes I found enjoyable were The Posieden Adventure, which was a remake of Posieden, and When A Stranger Calls, which was a 2006 remake of a film under the same name from 1976.

          Echoing Scarf's sentiments on Oceans, I felt that the remake is vastly superior to the original. Vastly superior! Fantastic! The original was....terrible, to say the least. Clooney and the gang made a terrific movie and blew the original out of the water, easily.
          It stands as an example as to how remakes should be done - don't mess around too much with the original premise, but change enough of it so it has a new lease of life. Then, have a cast which actually suits the premise of the film, not just floods upon floods of A listers who really don't have a feel for their character. Actually try to make the movie stand out for it's own merits, not just as a sub-par remake of a movie which should have been left alone in the first place, either for it being crap or for it being just too good to remake in modern times.
          Reply With Quote
          Old January 23rd, 2013 (11:23 AM).
          Mr Cat Dog's Avatar
          Mr Cat Dog Mr Cat Dog is offline
          Frasier says it best
            Join Date: Apr 2004
            Location: London, UK
            Age: 27
            Gender: Male
            Nature: Relaxed
            Posts: 11,411
            It honestly depends on the people involved in the remake as to how good it'll be. If it's a blatant cash-grab to update a cool concept from either a foreign language film or an older film, it's probably not going to be all that great. Unfortunately, most remakes tend to fall into this camp, as studios believe that the inherent 'brand recognition' in older films will give them a leg-up at the box-office. People will go to something that they have at least some familiarity with, on the whole.

            The good ones - which are, admittedly, few and far between - are the passion projects where people genuinely wish to improve an older/foreign film, or place a new spin on it for a new generation. Off the top of my head, one of the best remakes was The Departed (remaking and condensing the Hong Kong Infernal Affairs trilogy). By condensing it down - and having Martin Scorsese as the director! - it removed a lot of the fat from the original series and became much leaner as a result. Another favourite remake is His Girl Friday (remaking the film The Front Page), which changed one of the main characters from a man to woman making everything have this new sexual chemistry that was absent before. I'd highly recommend both to people sceptical about any remakes that can be good.
            Reply With Quote
            Old January 26th, 2013 (5:03 PM).
            Holofoil Holofoil is offline
              Join Date: Jan 2013
              Posts: 31
              Some remakes I have seen have been better than the original, but a lot have been worse too.
              I still like remakes though, provided they stick to the storyline and tell it better.
              Reply With Quote
              Old January 27th, 2013 (12:01 PM).
              SV's Avatar
              SV SV is offline
              See You Space Cowboy
              • Silver Tier
              Join Date: Mar 2011
              Gender: Male
              Nature: Relaxed
              Posts: 3,372
              Some have bombed completely (in my opinion), but not all have turned out bad. In fact, sometimes I end up liking the remake better than the original.

              IMO, movies in which the remake bombed, or at least wasn't as good as the original: Bad News Bears, King Kong, 12 Angry Men, Miracle on 24th Street, Nightmare on Elm Street come to mind, the Amazing Spiderman.

              IMO, movies where the remake was as good as or surpassed the original: 3:10 to Yuma, True Grit, The Dark Knight, Karate Kid.

              So sometimes remakes really work. Sometimes they don't. I think the film world may just be running out of ideas. xD

              A Legend once told me that roleplaying is about bringing people together and celebrating creative vision.
              Paired with the Artsy Infinite and the Spectacular Shak
              Reply With Quote
              Old February 12th, 2013 (7:55 AM). Edited February 12th, 2013 by Toutebelle.
              Toutebelle Toutebelle is offline
                Join Date: Jan 2013
                Location: New York, USA
                Gender: Male
                Nature: Sassy
                Posts: 123
                Remakes are, for the most part, an AWFUL idea.

                Some of them:

                1. 12 Angry Men. I don't have any idea why they really felt the need to make Juror #10 a member of the Nation of Islam. I know black people can be racist too, but come on, that defeats the whole purpose. The accused kid was supposed to be black!
                2. The Karate Kid. It was just a half-assed attempt to get Will Smith's son to star in a movie. Jaden Smith's character learns kung-fu (that's right, NOT karate) in a few days and does it perfectly. His character seemed like a jerk, unlike Daniel in the original. The kids were too young to be fighting over a girl like that. The original had hormonal teenagers, while the remake had prepubescent kids. I admit they do make a more menacing bully - now he's a genuinely evil bully instead of a severely misguided bully. But they made the evil sensei less menacing. Kreese was a guy to be feared - even Johnny was afraid of him. Not to mention the love interest is even more shallow than Ali in the original. Ali could call out Johnny's behavior, but Meiying was like a punching bag. And where was the iconic "sweep the leg" line? (I've written fanfiction for the original. It's mostly centered around Johnny.)
                3. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. I don't know if this one counts since it was based on a book, but I'll put it here anyway. On the plus side, it did get a lot of stuff right that the first one didn't (such as using squirrels and only having songs where they belong instead of all the time), but what really puts it on the list was the Freudian backstory that they gave Willy Wonka. Do you really need to give him daddy issues? And why did you need to make him some kind of reverse Michael Jackson when it came to children? The whole point of the story was to show Charlie being a good kid as opposed to say, Veruca or Mike or the other brats. It wasn't about daddy issues.
                4. Any remake where they feel the need to make it "politically correct". Did you see the Wurthering Heights where Heathcliff got a race lift?

                I can understand wanting to update a movie to change with the times. I mean, the original Karate Kid, even though it's a good movie, is kind of dated. A lot of the elements suggest that (such as the girls' hairstyles and the bad guys being blond pretty boy jerks, a staple of 80s teen movies).
                Reply With Quote

                Quick Reply

                Join the conversation!

                Create an account to post a reply in this thread, participate in other discussions, and more!

                Create a PokéCommunity Account

                Sponsored Links
                Thread Tools

                Posting Rules
                You may not post new threads
                You may not post replies
                You may not post attachments
                You may not edit your posts

                BB code is On
                Smilies are On
                [IMG] code is On
                HTML code is Off

                Forum Jump

                All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:21 PM.