The whole "allowing request/recruitment threads" thing is just something we're testing out. Right now, we're going with a more open door policy that will allow members (whose request threads would traditionally be closed) to become more integrated with the community. We're running on the idea that if we don't lock a member's thread = they may feel more inclined to post. Anyway, I hope I answer this satisfactorily!
At least, that was my rationale behind the rule change. To make it easier to invite more people in/not turn them away.
Which makes sense to me! Artists usually aren't going to go to the hack/game thread to see where they're needed and it makes more sense for those that need help to seek those that can give them help. We're also not active enough/inundated with requests that we would have to worry about our galleries getting pushed to the bottom of the page. Most of us update enough that it's not a problem. It might be slightly annoying, but it's one of those things you can just ignore if it is.
Exactly. There's very few negative side repercussions to allowing requesting threads, and with one of the possible benefits being more people included in the community, it's a small price to pay.
Oh, does this effect the rule of asking for requests within a gallery though? Was I imagining that there was a rule there in the first place? If people are able to ask for requests in the forum, they shouldn't be allowed to ask for requests in the gallery, I think. A VM or PM is more appropriate and it would be better to make a thread so they can see multiple people who are interested.
Yes and no. Shops will still exist. 9.9 times out of 10, people who post request threads aren't looking for signatures, avatars, and profile designs; the main things offered by those who run shops. In the case of other request/recruitment threads it's usually a more complicated job and the public setting is helpful. However, if they want to hire a specific artist, they can use a personal platform for that.
So as an example:
-Request thread about needing a new avatar/signature > OP is directed towards any thread denoted as a [shop] if no one takes the request first. Either the OP (hopefully) finds what they're looking for in the thread, or the thread becomes clutter because they found what they were looking for outside the thread.
-Request thread asking someone to make a Youtube banner / looking to hire a sprite artist > Thread stays open with the hopes someone will take it up.
-Request thread asking for [insert user] to make anything > OP is encouraged to contact the user specifically. Thread most likely closed.