WPC #29 - POLL

FISH FILLET


  • Total voters
    11
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
  • 2,971
    Posts
    16
    Years
    Weekly Pixel Art Challenge: #29 - POLL
    Hosted by: Logiedan
    Vote for only one entry this week.

    Voting Rules:

    • One vote per person (unless stated otherwise)
    • You may not vote for yourself
    • You can post which one you voted for and why
    • Critique is really appreciated to help those who struggled in votes!
    This Week's Rules:

    • Canvas Size: Unrestricted. BOTH sprites must be in one image
    • Palette Requirements: 18 colours max each sprite.
    • Transparency: Optional (WILL NOT COUNT AS A COLOUR)
    • Animation: None
    • Other: N/A
    List of Contestants:
    NOTE: This is in no particular order or related to the order of entries below.
    ShadowMirror, Shadowraze, GolurkIsDaBomb, Discordant and Fenneking.

    Entry 1
    [PokeCommunity.com] WPC #29 - POLL

    Espeon + Girafarig
    PURPLE + YELLOW
    ----------
    Entry 2
    [PokeCommunity.com] WPC #29 - POLL

    Torchic + Spheal
    BLUE + ORANGE
    Note: Torchic's is classed as red but is an exception for orange in this case
    ----------
    Entry 3
    [PokeCommunity.com] WPC #29 - POLL


    Camerupt + Lilligant
    GREEN + RED
    ----------
    Entry 4
    [PokeCommunity.com] WPC #29 - POLL


    Electivire + Nidoking
    PURPLE + YELLOW
    ----------
    Entry 5
    [PokeCommunity.com] WPC #29 - POLL


    Dragonite + Lapras
    BLUE + ORANGE

    ---
    Good luck!
     
    Last edited:
    I believe Entry number 4 is Electrivire not Elektrike. :/

    I voted for Entry no.3 as it is the most beautiful one and would most likely win the wpc imo.
     
    Last edited:
    Entry 1:

    It's unfortunate to see that this one doesn't have any votes yet given that the sprite work is good and each sprite is transformed. Though, the spriter could have had a more clear concept in mind. Overall, this is a great entry. 8/10

    Entry 2:

    Definitely not bad. I do think that there was a limitation on your artwork given the choice to fuse two smaller pokemon. Some of the sprite work is muddy especially on the blue torchic; it is hard to make-out if that is a tail or huge hand on its right side. 6/10

    Entry 3:

    Most innovative and intricate of the designs. Maybe a bit too over designed; other than that great. 8/10

    Entry 4:

    From a pixel standpoint, this entry has the most flaws. The blue shading under electrivire's jaw does match the color scheme, and there is a lack of outline on the top of its right hand. The lack of an outline on Nidokings' tail. The top of Nidoking's head has a jagged outline, and on the back of its head, near the neck, there is a completely unfinished area with no shading or outline. Overall, the concept is nice, but the execution of pixel art, outlines and shading, needs a lot of improvement. 4/10

    Entry 5:
    This is one simple, yet clear and distinct in its concept and execution. Though, that also works against it, given it is a bit underwhelming. But perhaps simple and clean is better than conmplex and diffuse. I will give this one an 8/10 as well.

    I have narrowed it down to 1,3, and 5. They're are all evenly great.

    But, I really do think that 1 deserves a vote since they're obviously made with great thought and execution in the design.
     
    Last edited:

    And the winners are...

    [PokeCommunity.com] WPC #29 - POLL

    1st Place - Fenneking
    [PokeCommunity.com] WPC #29 - POLL


    [PokeCommunity.com] WPC #29 - POLL

    2nd Place - ShadowMirror
    [PokeCommunity.com] WPC #29 - POLL


    [PokeCommunity.com] WPC #29 - POLL

    3rd Place - GolurkIsDaBomb
    [PokeCommunity.com] WPC #29 - POLL


    [PokeCommunity.com] WPC #29 - POLL

    3rd Place - Shadowraze
    [PokeCommunity.com] WPC #29 - POLL


    ---
    Congratulations to all. Good luck on the next poll.
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.
    Back
    Top