Bronzong!

Started by Squirrel August 22nd, 2013 12:30 PM
  • 1180 views
  • 11 replies

Squirrel

Age 28
Male
Seen 4 Days Ago
Posted July 10th, 2021
9,551 posts
11.7 Years
Source: http://bulbanews.bulbagarden.net/wiki/On_the_Origin_of_Species:_Bronzor_and_Bronzong

Spoiler:
Bronzor and Bronzong are a pair of Pokémon whose origins eluded me for some time. At first glance, their designs don't seem to make a lot of sense, and it's hard to see how they're even related to each other. Bronzong is clearly a large bell, and I originally presumed Bronzor to be a gong, before learning from its Pokédex entry that it's a mirror. A bronze mirror, specifically – these were manufactured in China from 2000 BC, and made their way to Japan in around 300 AD. It's only in the last few hundred years that glass mirrors have become commonplace.
So, we have a bronze mirror and a bronze bell. Apart from being made of the same metal, what do they have in common? Not much, really, unless you happen to be familiar with a Japanese legend that is best known by the title Of a Mirror and a Bell. It appears in a famous collection of stories entitled Kwaidan: Stories and Studies of Strange Things. The book was published in 1904 and was compiled by Lafcadio Hearn, an Irish-Greek journalist who became a Japanese citizen. Hearn produced numerous accounts of Japanese culture and mythology that served to introduce the West to a people who, at the time, still must have seemed very exotic and unfamiliar.
The story that concerns us begins hundreds of years prior, in Mugenyama in Tōtōmi province. There, the priests wanted a new bell for their temple, and asked for the local women to donate old bronze mirrors, which could be melted down and cast into a bell. One of the mirrors to be donated came from a farmer's wife.
After a while, though, the woman started to regret giving away her mirror, which had been in her family for many years. An old proverb said that a mirror was the soul of a woman, and she started to worry that in giving away her precious mirror, she had also given away her soul. She didn't have the money to buy the mirror back, and whenever she went to the temple, she could see it in amongst the pile of others. She longed to steal it back, but the opportunity never came.
Eventually, all of the mirrors were sent to the foundry to be melted down. Mysteriously, one of the mirrors would not melt: a sign that whoever donated it must not have wanted to give it up. Since the offering wasn't presented with all her heart, her mirror remained attached to her, kept cold in the furnace by her selfish desire. When it was discovered to whom the mirror belonged, the woman couldn't bear the shame, and drowned herself. But before she died, she left a letter stating that, once she was gone, the mirror could be melted and used to cast the bell. However, anybody who struck the bell hard enough to break it would be rewarded with riches by her ghost.
The locals took this dying promise quite seriously, as the last wishes of anyone dying in anger were thought to possess a mystical power. Thus, the possibility of breaking the bell and becoming rich seemed very real. Once the newly-made bell was hung in the temple, people flocked to ring it, striking it as hard as they possibly could. The bell held firm, but still people tried to break it, day after day. This proved hugely annoying for the priests, who had to endure the near-constant ringing of their bell. Soon tiring of the constant noise, the priests took the bell and rolled it down a hill, into a deep swamp. The bell sank in, never to be seen again... and the woman, from beyond the grave, had succeeded in destroying the bell that had caused her so much misery.


A bronze bell, or dōtaku. This particular example dates from the 3rd century AD.
Though the story ends here, and we can clearly see the relationship between the mirror and the bell that gave rise to Bronzor and Bronzong, there is still more to be said about this legend... as, curiously enough, it spawned legends of its own. A powerful concept in Japanese folklore is that of nazoraeru (準える), or substitution. An example that Hearn himself gives is that of making a temple to Buddha. The average person could never afford to do this, but by simply laying a pebble before an image of Buddha, with the same degree of dedication that would prompt you to build a temple if you had the means, you would acquire the same merit as if you had actually built one. Essentially, if you don't have the means to do something, you can do something else with the same feelings, and reap the same rewards.
The story of the bell of Mugen, or Mugen-kane (無間鐘), supposedly captured the public's imagination. Though the bell was lost, and with it any chance of reaping the reward for breaking it, that didn't stop imaginative individuals from substituting other items for the lost bell, and breaking them in the hopes of being rewarded. While this might sound like an absurdly desperate act of greed, it's worth pointing out that, in many versions of the legend, the financial reward came at the cost of the person's soul: they would gain riches in life, but be cast in to a particularly nasty corner of Hell upon dying. So the act of re-creating and then breaking the bell of Mugen took on a sacrificial quality, and there were many plays about parents or spouses doing such a thing to provide money for their loved ones, sacrificing their future happiness in order to help those that they loved.
A famous story concerned Umegae, lover of the Heian period samurai Kajiwara Kagesue. Kajiwara had apparently spent all of his money on Umegae, and had to pawn his armor, which became problematic when he was subsequently called to arms. In order to get the armor back, Umegae took a bronze basin and beat it until it broke, while crying out for three hundred pieces of gold. A guest of the inn where they were staying heard the commotion and, upon learning of her plight, actually gave her the money she had cried out for. Thus, the washbasin of Umegae became as much of a legend as the bell of Mugen that had inspired it. Hearn tells us of a song about Umegae's basin that was still being sung by dancing girls at the start of the twentieth century: "If, by striking upon the wash-basin of Umegae, I could make honorable money come to me, then would I negotiate for the freedom of all my girl-comrades."
I've mentioned in previous columns how many Japanese legends seem to mix the tragic and the bizarre, and here we have a tale of suicide, poverty and eternal damnation that nonetheless involves the comical image of people smashing up objects in the hope that they'll be rewarded by a ghost. Hearn wasn't exaggerating when he subtitled his collection Stories and Studies of Strange Things. The motivations of the woman in the origin myth seem especially difficult to comprehend from a modern perspective: giving something away and then regretting it is certainly a very mild form of selfishness, and probably not shameful enough to merit suicide. And perhaps I'm just not romantic, but I have to wonder what sort of samurai pawns his armor to impress his girlfriend.
One reference to the legends in the design of Bronzor and Bronzong that might not be immediately obvious is in their abilities. Both can have the Heatproof ability, rendering them resistant to fire, just like the mirror that refused to be melted down. There are also a few oblique references to the myths in their Pokédex entries. Bronzong, incidentally, is mentioned to be a bringer of good harvests, and the dōtaku (銅鐸), the type of bell on which it is based, was used to pray for good harvests in ancient times. But my favourite Pokédex entry for Bronzong has to be the one from Diamond: "One caused a news sensation when it was dug up at a construction site after a 2000-year sleep." Might this Bronzong, then, be the actual bell of Mugen, finally recovered from the swamp? If so, one should exercise caution while battling it. The payout upon defeating it may be unexpectedly high, but once it's Game Over, there'll be hell to pay..

Quite simply put, this Pokémon family is absolutely fascinating. If you can't be bothered to read the story, it boils down to Bronzor being based on a bronze mirror and Bronzong a bronze bell, fitting in with an old Japanese legend of a church asking for bronze mirror donations to smelt into a new bronze bell for the church. A woman gives her bronze mirror as a donation but is still attached to it and regrets it, so the mirror will not melt (Heatproof). She wants the mirror back and contemplates stealing it, which drives her to suicide from the guilt she feels. This allows for the mirror to be melted down with the rest of them to form the bell, however the woman left a note upon death stating that if someone could break the bell that had forsaken her life so much, they would be rewarded with great riches. This also carried a curse however, that they would then be sent to an eternity in hell once they've died. The story ends with the bell causing so much trouble with people trying to destroy it that the church rolls it into a swamp, where it was then left (playing on Bronzong's Diamond Pokédex entry).

The actual story is somewhat darker and there's a lot of interesting context/facts provided, so it's certainly worth a read if you haven't. What I'd like to know is how do you feel about Bronzong in light of this story? Do you like Bronzong? Did you like Bronzong before and you don't now, or vice versa? Is it a Pokémon that you expected to have such an interesting story to it? Had you ever contemplated Bronzong's design and background before?


Feel free to answer all, any or none of the questions when responding, but I personally found this story to be absolutely incredible haha. Some Pokémon origins truly are fascinating!

François

#FutureSun&MoonMod

Age 27
Male
Batisques
Seen November 12th, 2016
Posted November 8th, 2016
396 posts
10.3 Years
This is the best story I've read on that series of Bulbagarden articles. Some pokémon have such obscure myths behind them, it really is quite fascinating. The family this thread is focused on always did look quite mysterious, though, so I'm not at all surprised at their origin!

Aeroblast

Male
Basement
Seen February 25th, 2017
Posted February 25th, 2017
4,173 posts
9.8 Years
A lot of Pokemon are based on lores, some of which are fascinating to look into. Obvious example is Magikarp line with leaping over mountains but I digress.

If talking about gameplay, Levitate Bronzong + Rain = Great Wall.

Savant

Natural Born Breeder

Age 29
Male
Trinidad and Tobago
Seen November 15th, 2013
Posted November 15th, 2013
65 posts
9.7 Years
I always liked Bronzong. I even used one in my Diamond playthrough and it served me well all through the E4 and Champion. I prefer bulkier and more tank-like Pokemon over the frail speedy ones anyway.

Slow and steady wins the race.

3DS FC: 1564-2977-3425
Friend Safari: Psychic (Drowzee - Espurr - ???)

my.anime | my.manga | Circle of One | Pokemon Breeders FC | Fire Emblem FC

moon

they/them
Seen 11 Hours Ago
Posted 22 Hours Ago
37,443 posts
15.5 Years
That is cool~ There are surprisingly many pokémon that are based on Japanese myths and legends and events that we in the western world don't quite understand. Arcanine being legedary (that's chinese though?) and Lombre's origins etc. And this, apparently!

I've never used Bronzong or Bronzor, except for in one roleplay where I did battle a Bronzor in a cave. But that's all, iirc. They never attracted me much because of their rather inanimate and boring looks, tbh. Sadly, maybe, as they have quite the interesting origin once you got to know it.

I guess Bronzor is cute. But I wouldn't want to evolve it ;) Thanks for sharing, Ozzy.
paired with Ivysaur

Snowdrop

Back and ready to babble!

Female
Penguin Jail
Seen May 22nd, 2017
Posted May 2nd, 2017
628 posts
10.8 Years
Aw, it's weird that you mentioned that! I was just reading all of Bulbagarden's Origin of Species yesterday! If you like Bronzong's origins, you'll love Parasect's!

... but I still dislike Bronzong lol. It's ugleh and though I think it was extremely creative to base a Pokemon on this myth I don't think it has a very good design. Or I'm just biased because I don't like inanimate objects.

Squirrel

Age 28
Male
Seen 4 Days Ago
Posted July 10th, 2021
9,551 posts
11.7 Years
Or I'm just biased because I don't like inanimate objects.
This is a very interesting point about Bronzong for me! Ordinarily I would agree with you - I dislike Pokémon like Vanillite, Trubbish, Honedge, etc, because the idea of an inanimate object coming to life like that is silly to me; Bronzong however is one that I've always loved. I can't really explain why, I guess it's probably to do with there being an obvious legend/story behind its creation which gave it the life that it has, or perhaps it's just because he looks like a huge derp of a Pokémon with that cheeky smile and those spaced out eyes, but Bronzong has always been one of the only inanimate object-based Pokémon that I've actually liked. And that's saying something considering it's a Psychic-type, one of my least favourites haha.

(And yes Parasect is creepy! May post a thread on him soon ;))

Snowdrop

Back and ready to babble!

Female
Penguin Jail
Seen May 22nd, 2017
Posted May 2nd, 2017
628 posts
10.8 Years
Yeah, same here except I think Honedge is kind of cool. I always really liked Muk and Grimer for some reason even though they're just sludge piles with arms and faces.

That is a little bit of a dark story to base a Pokemon off of though, seeing as it involves a woman's suicide (is killing yourself over a material item supposed to be dark comedy or something?). But hey, cultures vary :D

ChipmunkGamingInc.

Owner of Chipmunk Gaming Inc.

Age 24
Female
Does it really matter?
Seen November 29th, 2013
Posted November 19th, 2013
70 posts
9.8 Years
Wow, I never understood why this-this-this CIRCLE-Y shape that was supposedly made of bronze, could evolve into a... upside-down ice cream cone with the tip cut off and a long bronze ribbon glued to the top. Yeah, weird analysis of Bronzong, but hey... I'm overly creative sometimes. Anyways, I've always pondered this, and now it makes sense.

Now, to explain Luvdisc...?

*~Maelstrom~*


Join the Poké Dance Party! Gen II at it's best!
Male
In a Rabbit
Seen July 13th, 2022
Posted June 9th, 2022
824 posts
9.8 Years
I read all of the Origin of Species articles when they came out. After playing Diamond/Pearl, Bronzong was among my least favorite pokemon of all time, only second to Probopass. Usually after reading the Origin articles, I tend to have more respect for the pokemon, such as Mawile and Castform. But with Bronzong, reading this actually made me dislike it more.

1. If this entire backstory has to do with a woman's spirit haunting a bell, then why wasn't Bronzong Ghost/Steel? But instead, they just made a third Steel/Psychic line, when that typing is better suited for artifical intelligence. For anyone who thinks this would have been overpowered, they could have lowered its BST.

2. If this backstory is about a woman possessing a bell, why couldn't Bronzong be a 100% female pokemon, which was a cross between a ghostly woman with, say, the bronze bell for a dress/body? Yet instead, they made it a genderless, nearly-faceless inanimate object.

3. Why doesn't a Bronzor, a steel-type pokémon based on a mirror introduce in gen IV, not learn Mirror Shot, a steel-type move introduced in gen IV? Not learning Mirror Coat is understandable, but not this. Furthermore, it should have had a reflective surface in its center, because it's current design is difficult to make out as a mirror, as opposed to a coin or gong.

This story made me dislike Bronzong more because I felt as though it was a waste of a backstory with a lot of potential for a design. As for my third point, it seems to me like Bronzor was a half-baked idea.

Now, to explain Luvdisc...?

They do look like hearts, don't they?

This was quite the interesting read, I do agree. I have always looked at Bronzong as a compelling Pokemon and he is one of my favorite Pokemon that was introduced in gen 4, but I now have a much higher opinion on him after reading this. Pokemon that were based on objects with this amount of history are just so fascinating to me. This is quite deep of a story that I never would have even imagined a Pokemon to be based on. Very nice story, Alex!