Fourth Generation Diamond, Pearl, and Platinum kicked off the fourth generation of Pokémon. Two years later, fans of the Johto region were treated to a remastered adventure in HeartGold & SoulSilver. Discuss the games, explore the features, share your experiences, and help other players out!

View Poll Results: Which do you prefer?
HeartGold 54 47.37%
SoulSilver 60 52.63%
Voters: 114. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools
  #1    
Old December 15th, 2013 (3:23 PM).
Nick Nick is offline
Banned
     
    Join Date: Nov 2009
    Age: 19
    Posts: 5,220
    In 2010 a pair of remakes for Gold and Silver were released, respectively named HeartGold and SoulSilver.

    Which one of the two games do you prefer, and why? Do you think that they games were feature-rich, or lacking any thereof? What should they have kept from G/S/C that they ended up slashing?
    Reply With Quote

    Relevant Advertising!

      #2    
    Old December 16th, 2013 (2:38 AM).
    curiousnathan's Avatar
    curiousnathan curiousnathan is offline
    • Crystal Tier
     
    Join Date: Sep 2009
    Location: Australia
    Gender: Male
    Nature: Adamant
    Posts: 7,828
    I prefer HeartGold, mainly because it was the one I bought out of the two when they were released, and because I had owned Pokemon Gold as a kid. So in summary, I prefer HeartGold for nostalgic reasons.

    Also, I added a poll to this thread because wynaut?
    __________________
    Former moderator of First Generation, Second Generation and Fourth Generation
    Reply With Quote
      #3    
    Old December 16th, 2013 (2:46 AM).
    Hikamaru's Avatar
    Hikamaru Hikamaru is offline
    Razor Shell
    • Platinum Tier
     
    Join Date: Mar 2011
    Location: Australia
    Age: 24
    Gender: Female
    Nature: Quirky
    Posts: 47,403
    Despite being one who never played the originals, I voted SoulSilver because at the time, my brother got HeartGold so it was fitting I got the opposite version. He sadly retired from Pokemon afterwards but I was glad I picked SoulSilver because it had the version exclusives I liked better, and I'm more of a Lugia person than a Ho-Oh person in general.
    __________________
    pair | tumblr | twitter | poketrivia | us/um | ama | supporter
    Reply With Quote
      #4    
    Old December 16th, 2013 (4:04 AM).
    Diversion Diversion is offline
       
      Join Date: Feb 2013
      Location: No.
      Age: 16
      Gender: Male
      Nature: Serious
      Posts: 99
      HeartGold, it was the third game I played in the Nintendo DS.
      HeartGold had Growlithe, Arcanine, Kyogre, Gliscor and you'd get Ho-oh first.

      Aside from the version exclusives, I played Gold before Silver, mainly because I wasn't interested in the color Silver (hah lol). And besides I'm not a fan of Lugia.
      Reply With Quote
        #5    
      Old December 16th, 2013 (4:36 PM).
      PhoneHome PhoneHome is offline
         
        Join Date: Dec 2013
        Gender: Male
        Posts: 23
        I always thought Gold> Silver, except in the days when i really wanted Ledian.
        __________________
        Reply With Quote
          #6    
        Old December 17th, 2013 (2:20 PM).
        Tessica15's Avatar
        Tessica15 Tessica15 is offline
           
          Join Date: Nov 2013
          Location: Ohio
          Age: 22
          Gender: Female
          Nature: Relaxed
          Posts: 4
          I prefer HeartGold for unknown reasons, but I owned both. I used HG as my main game and SS as my trial and error game for my action replay.
          __________________
          Tess.19.Ohio

          Reply With Quote
            #7    
          Old December 17th, 2013 (9:07 PM).
          Aslan's Avatar
          Aslan Aslan is offline
          the pretender
          • Gold Tier
           
          Join Date: Mar 2013
          Location: Sydney
          Gender: Female
          Nature: Modest
          Posts: 2,241
          Heartgold because it has Growlithe. Hands down. Really though, there's not much difference besides version exclusives. I like the Pokemon HG has to offer more so that's why I went with it. :p
          __________________
          MISCHIEF MANAGED.
          Reply With Quote
            #8    
          Old December 18th, 2013 (12:03 AM).
          Apollo's Avatar
          Apollo Apollo is offline
          怖がらないで
             
            Join Date: May 2012
            Gender: Male
            Nature: Hasty
            Posts: 1,335
            My sister got HG, so I got SS. I liked the version exclusives more, and I prefer Lugia more than Ho-oh.
            __________________

            there is no fire like passion
            Reply With Quote
              #9    
            Old December 18th, 2013 (4:43 AM).
            Consulting Detective's Avatar
            Consulting Detective Consulting Detective is offline
               
              Join Date: Dec 2012
              Location: 'Straya
              Gender: Female
              Nature: Modest
              Posts: 37
              I wound up buying HeartGold because of Ho-oh. I remember looking up the differences and really, there weren't that many that really changed my mind.
              __________________



              Reply With Quote
                #10    
              Old December 18th, 2013 (6:02 AM).
              Kikaito plush's Avatar
              Kikaito plush Kikaito plush is offline
              Angeline plushxKikaito plush
                 
                Join Date: Dec 2009
                Location: plushies resort
                Age: 24
                Gender: Male
                Nature: Naughty
                Posts: 5,302
                Even though I got Soulsilver first I prefer Heartgold because it has better version only pokemon.
                __________________
                Reply With Quote
                  #11    
                Old December 19th, 2013 (9:49 AM).
                Sheep's Avatar
                Sheep Sheep is online now
                • Administrator
                • Silver Tier
                 
                Join Date: Sep 2011
                Age: 26
                Gender: Female
                Nature: Bashful
                Posts: 21,469
                HeartGold because Ho-Oh is one of my very favorite legendaries. Totally awesome design.. and gold > silver anyday. :D
                __________________

                . pair family twin mal lv llsif .
                Reply With Quote
                  #12    
                Old December 21st, 2013 (1:27 PM).
                Crzyphl's Avatar
                Crzyphl Crzyphl is offline
                The Crazy Phil
                   
                  Join Date: Dec 2013
                  Location: Ohio
                  Gender: Male
                  Nature: Impish
                  Posts: 17
                  Soulsilver because Lugia>Ho-oh in my opinion... At least, the design. Stat-wise I prefer Ho-oh.
                  __________________
                  A Horde of Level 100 Blissey appeared!
                  Reply With Quote
                    #13    
                  Old December 21st, 2013 (5:26 PM).
                  I've Come to Bargain's Avatar
                  I've Come to Bargain I've Come to Bargain is offline
                  • Silver Tier
                   
                  Join Date: Jul 2012
                  Location: New York, USA
                  Posts: 11,878
                  I had both games, but personally, I preferred SoulSilver more. Vulpix was exclusive to this game, which is my most favorite Pokémon. SoulSilver had access to Skarmory as well, which is also my favorite. Also, Pokémon Silver was my first ever second-generation game, sooo… there's that. xD"
                  __________________
                  Reply With Quote
                    #14    
                  Old December 21st, 2013 (10:47 PM).
                  Ramsie's Avatar
                  Ramsie Ramsie is offline
                  Currently in Unova
                     
                    Join Date: Feb 2008
                    Location: Miz-er-ee not Mis-er-uh
                    Gender: Female
                    Nature: Timid
                    Posts: 101
                    Though I played Silver more as a child and have fond memories of doing so, I got HeartGold first because I wanted a Growlithe on my team. And I have one, so it all works out.
                    __________________
                    Pokemon X Friend Code:
                    Fiona: 0834-2018-2824
                    Please PM me if you add me!
                    Safari Type: Poison
                    Cascoon|Swalot|Whirlepede
                    Reply With Quote
                      #15    
                    Old December 22nd, 2013 (4:53 AM).
                    Starry Windy's Avatar
                    Starry Windy Starry Windy is offline
                    A resonating melody ♫
                    • Crystal Tier
                     
                    Join Date: Dec 2012
                    Location: Liberty Garden
                    Age: 24
                    Gender: Male
                    Nature: Modest
                    Posts: 7,998
                    I picked HeartGold because I like Ho-Oh, it's one of my fave Legendary Pokémon.
                    __________________

                    PokéCommunity | MyAnimeList | My Pairs | Blog | Science & Technology | #TeamTrivia
                    Ask this resident Victini some questions in my AMA thread!
                    Reply With Quote
                      #16    
                    Old December 25th, 2013 (1:32 PM).
                    Palmer-Granate's Avatar
                    Palmer-Granate Palmer-Granate is offline
                    The Champion Jester
                       
                      Join Date: Oct 2013
                      Location: The end and the beginning of the Universe.
                      Gender: Male
                      Nature: Relaxed
                      Posts: 128
                      I vote both. They are equal in their own way. I love HG just as much as SS, and Ho-Oh and Lugia are equally as beloved by me. Ultimately, it doesn't matter.
                      __________________
                      While traveling from Johto to Kanto, you'll end up at a certain building in Viridian City. When you go against the trainer there, that's not just Feraligator biting you, that's life.

                      Note: Seriously, the dude always has all three starters. How cool is that?
                      Reply With Quote
                        #17    
                      Old December 25th, 2013 (3:43 PM).
                      OtakuVox's Avatar
                      OtakuVox OtakuVox is offline
                         
                        Join Date: Dec 2013
                        Location: The one and only ;) 12 <3
                        Gender: Male
                        Nature: Jolly
                        Posts: 20
                        I actually love both HG and SS. But in this case, I will got for SS because I do prefer Lugia x)
                        __________________
                        @________@ WOBWOBWOBWOB

                        Reply With Quote
                          #18    
                        Old December 25th, 2013 (3:58 PM).
                        momine's Avatar
                        momine momine is offline
                           
                          Join Date: Feb 2013
                          Location: The Netherlands
                          Age: 21
                          Gender: Male
                          Nature: Adamant
                          Posts: 10
                          I choose SoulSilver because an old friend of mine gave me years ago Silver and i enjoyed the game really much. And oww i am more a Lugia person.

                          Sorry for my bad English.
                          __________________
                          http://www.pokecommunity.com/signaturepics/sigpic372790_1.gif
                          Subscribe!
                          Reply With Quote
                            #19    
                          Old December 30th, 2013 (5:28 AM).
                          Evening's Avatar
                          Evening Evening is offline
                          defiance
                          • Silver Tier
                           
                          Join Date: Dec 2013
                          Location: (Blank)
                          Age: 16
                          Gender: Male
                          Nature: Relaxed
                          Posts: 808
                          HeartGold of course!
                          There are three reasons why I like HeartGold better, let’s discuss about it shall we?

                          No. 1, COLOR: Despite liking the color SILVER right now, I’ve always been a better fan of the color GOLD.

                          No. 2, EXCLUSIVES: I like majority of HeartGold’s exclusives than SoulSilver.
                          It’s as simple as that.

                          Last but not least, No. 3, VERSION MASCOT: I like Ho-oh better than Lugia.
                          Ho-oh is like, more offensive than Lugia and it has an impressive Attack stat, to me at least.
                          Reply With Quote
                            #20    
                          Old January 1st, 2014 (10:20 AM).
                          Venitardus's Avatar
                          Venitardus Venitardus is offline
                          Breeder
                             
                            Join Date: Jan 2013
                            Gender: Male
                            Posts: 1,003
                            Gold was my first gen2 game, so I'm going with heart gold.
                            __________________
                            Proud owner of the Breeders club.
                            • X: Joey •Alpha sapphire: Kimmy • Sun: Joey
                            I am a shiny hunter.
                            3ds FC: 4468-2394-4701
                            Completed Challenges:Shiny Badge Quest
                            Reply With Quote
                              #21    
                            Old January 1st, 2014 (11:09 AM).
                            Outlier's Avatar
                            Outlier Outlier is offline
                            Goodbye, Grace
                               
                              Join Date: Nov 2013
                              Gender: Male
                              Nature: Lonely
                              Posts: 881
                              Soul Silver for aesthetic reasons because Lugia is one my favorite Pokemon.
                              Reply With Quote
                                #22    
                              Old January 1st, 2014 (10:28 PM).
                              Prairie's Avatar
                              Prairie Prairie is offline
                                 
                                Join Date: Dec 2013
                                Nature: Impish
                                Posts: 71
                                Soul Silver! I have fond memories of playing Pokemon Silver back when I was a kid. Loved it a ton, and I played it a lot, too. I can't remember how many times I've beaten it, haha.

                                I guess it's nostalgia that made me like it more. That, and I also prefer Lugia's design to Ho-Oh's. :>
                                Reply With Quote
                                  #23    
                                Old January 5th, 2014 (3:10 PM).
                                Hainline15's Avatar
                                Hainline15 Hainline15 is offline
                                   
                                  Join Date: Aug 2013
                                  Gender: Male
                                  Posts: 59
                                  I used to have both of them, but recently i rebought SoulSilver. I like SoulSilver better because I have always loved Lugia way more than Ho-Oh, and because as a kid i had several level 100 pokemon and on gold i did not.
                                  __________________
                                  My Favorite Pokemon!!





                                  Pokemon Y Friend Code: 4012-4710-8473
                                  Reply With Quote
                                    #24    
                                  Old January 5th, 2014 (3:35 PM).
                                  Deceit's Avatar
                                  Deceit Deceit is offline
                                  Toxic.
                                     
                                    Join Date: Jan 2013
                                    Location: Pastoria Great Marsh
                                    Gender: Male
                                    Nature: Timid
                                    Posts: 165
                                    HeartGold is my favorite, mainly just because I prefer Ho-oh over Lugia. But the reason I bought it was because I played Silver when I was younger, and I wanted to try the other version.
                                    Reply With Quote
                                      #25    
                                    Old January 6th, 2014 (7:47 AM).
                                    Kobiashi Kobiashi is offline
                                       
                                      Join Date: Dec 2013
                                      Age: 23
                                      Gender: Male
                                      Posts: 19
                                      Soul Silver based soley on the fact that my brother got heart gold even though he quit pokemon shortly after :/ just wished I could pokebank with soul silver
                                      __________________
                                      3DS Freind Code: 1392-5586-9798
                                      Reply With Quote
                                      Reply
                                      Quick Reply

                                      Sponsored Links
                                      Thread Tools

                                      Posting Rules
                                      You may not post new threads
                                      You may not post replies
                                      You may not post attachments
                                      You may not edit your posts

                                      BB code is On
                                      Smilies are On
                                      [IMG] code is On
                                      HTML code is Off

                                      Forum Jump


                                      All times are GMT -8. The time now is 8:59 AM.