It's good to read over detailed posts from regulars in PvP for me. I can wager opinions together, and I sure enjoy knowing why and how they pick certain element instead of the rest. People like RHCP, Jamais, Nymphadora etc. always have posts that I look into. So it's great, though the interaction level here is little since there's no person agreeing/discussing views here, and there's minimum quoting other posts. I believe there should be some way to change things.
Good points! It's the nature of the forum, which is both comfortable but also a bit sad. If we tried to change it to be more like a game, it could be too similar to Pokémon Trivia. If we changed it to hold more discussion, it would be similar to PGen and thus sort of redundant.
... brainstorm idea here, but what if there were prefixes in PVP, called
[Detailed] and
[Casual]? For Casual threads, posting a line or two would be okay and the main goal would be to summarize the votes once the thread has gotten some, to see what the general opinion really was - much like now. With Detailed threads, you'd get the chance to write LOOOONG replies with loads of details :D not necessarily like in a discussion. But if you feel bored and just really want to write a lot about a rather simple choice, you could do so in Detailed threads.
Thoughts? :3