U.Flame

Maker of Short Games

Age 27
Male
Unknown
Seen 14 Hours Ago
Posted January 17th, 2023
1,322 posts
15 Years
(Couldn't decide which forum this is most associated with. ^_^; It covers all games but mostly Pokemon. It's also for the purpose of a hack but is mostly a psychological debate. I'll post here but feel free to move it.)

So we're all used to the Pokemon series featuring silent protagonists for the sake of relating to the main character easier, and most of us like it this way. Generally, the more choices we have, the more gamers feel immersed to a game. Not all games follow this formula, as a lot of genres, typically JRPGs, tend to have defined characters with a straight story. This makes it easier to solidify the story telling of a plot-heavy game. So, which do you guys prefer: a silent protagonist to relate to, or an established character for a solid story?

For me, I feel more immersed with less choices. I play games for the story, so games like the Tales series appeal to me because all the characters are fleshed out people with their own dialogue and choices. The reason I don't usually like customizable and free protagonists is because we play from the perspective of gamers. We charge into battles because we saved, we get hurt because we can heal, so we don't consider our characters' feelings of mortality and pain. This ruins the story for me so I like games that are plot-heavy. There's nothing wrong with feeling the opposite way and liking silent protagonists, which is why this is a debate.

The reason this has dawned on me is because of the development of my hack. I've proceeded with a silent protagonist because that's how Pokemon games are. But I plan for my hack to be plot-heavy, with more feels than a normal Pokemon game. Having a silent protagonist will make this difficult, how can the main character remain silent and let the other main characters do the talking? It doesn't sit well with me, but because this has only recently dawned on me, I haven't considered a personality to give the main character were I to make him/her talk. Not to mention non-silent Pokemon protagonists aren't really well-received by the community. I've been making all major story decisions on my own, but this is one element I need input for. Should my Pokemon protagonist be silent or defined? That's the main reason I've started this debate, to see what helps immerse you guys most. Thanks for the input! :)
The more you learn about something, the more you realize just how much you don't know. I've shelved my more ambitious ideas in favor of smaller, more feasible projects and contributions. While I still have an ongoing project, and still intend to experiment with improving Gen 3's multiplayer, it's been much less stressful doing smaller things, like entries for Anthroyd's MAGM contests.

Of which you can check out here:
Naillevaihcam
Magical Altering Gym Menagerie
Male
Seen August 8th, 2022
Posted December 6th, 2019
82 posts
12.1 Years
In pokemon, I prefer a silent character.

I think of the character as my avatar. That's my name. Those are my pokemon. That's ME. And I don't want the game to put words in my mouth. I've seen a few hacks pull it off by just having the character say obvious things that any player would say, but as soon as the character starts giving a speech about "his" ideals and goals I turn the game off and play something else. The key to making a silent character work plot-wise is to remember that you're interacting directly with the player.

classiccartoonsftw

Nintendo is for awesome people

Male
Seen January 18th, 2017
Posted January 17th, 2017
9,225 posts
11.9 Years
I personally find silent protagonists bland and boring. That's why I never get attached to the main protagonist in the Pokemon games, but instead grow to love the Pokemon on my team.

In other words, I prefer characters with defined personalities.

skyluigi2

Male
United Kingdom
Seen October 4th, 2022
Posted July 21st, 2019
988 posts
13.6 Years
This is kind of a hard question to answer. I mean, you can have a silent protagonist that still has a very developed character. It's not Pokemon related, but Luigi is an example I'd give... especially in Luigi's Mansion 2. As for Pokemon, though... I really don't mind. It almost feels as if your character doesn't exist; they're just there to watch events unfold. And I'm totally fine with that.

T!M

Four Category MoTY (VG) Winner

Age 31
Male
Georgia, United States
Seen May 20th, 2016
Posted April 25th, 2014
1,422 posts
14.4 Years
I prefer me a silent protagonist, but I love games that employ that and choices. To me that is the full package in immersion. In that, you truly are the character. Because he only says what you would say.

U.Flame

Maker of Short Games

Age 27
Male
Unknown
Seen 14 Hours Ago
Posted January 17th, 2023
1,322 posts
15 Years
I prefer me a silent protagonist, but I love games that employ that and choices. To me that is the full package in immersion. In that, you truly are the character. Because he only says what you would say.
I've considered that as well, but choices are hard to do. Ruby Destiny Life of Guardians did a thing with dialogue being chosen through the "yes", "no" options but that would only allow two choices at a time. It'd be difficult to do, and proposes another issue. I like linear plots, not multiple branching. If I were to do this, I'd probably go the Mass Effect route and have the choices be character defining only with no effect on the story. It's a nice thought, and would probably be a likely option if I could do choices. As it is now, it doesn't look like I can.
The more you learn about something, the more you realize just how much you don't know. I've shelved my more ambitious ideas in favor of smaller, more feasible projects and contributions. While I still have an ongoing project, and still intend to experiment with improving Gen 3's multiplayer, it's been much less stressful doing smaller things, like entries for Anthroyd's MAGM contests.

Of which you can check out here:
Naillevaihcam
Magical Altering Gym Menagerie

T!M

Four Category MoTY (VG) Winner

Age 31
Male
Georgia, United States
Seen May 20th, 2016
Posted April 25th, 2014
1,422 posts
14.4 Years
You think you could branch but still focus on a linear story? Kind of like a mind trick where the choices affect the story at the time. But by the end the choices have not really affected the ending.

U.Flame

Maker of Short Games

Age 27
Male
Unknown
Seen 14 Hours Ago
Posted January 17th, 2023
1,322 posts
15 Years
I have some minor deviations in mind, but those are simply results of special battles, I don't know how far I'd be willing to branch the story while keeping it linear. The closest I can think of is, as I mentioned, Mass Effect. That series has choices that ultimately affect just the personality of the main character, not doing much to the story itself. I would like to do this, but choices would be hard to pull off, just being limited to two at a time.
The more you learn about something, the more you realize just how much you don't know. I've shelved my more ambitious ideas in favor of smaller, more feasible projects and contributions. While I still have an ongoing project, and still intend to experiment with improving Gen 3's multiplayer, it's been much less stressful doing smaller things, like entries for Anthroyd's MAGM contests.

Of which you can check out here:
Naillevaihcam
Magical Altering Gym Menagerie

pompayyy

Forever and Ever

Male
In a White Room with Black Curtains
Seen April 9th, 2019
Posted February 23rd, 2015
484 posts
10.3 Years
I like games that have silent protagonists, especially if you can customize them. It makes the game focus on the journey and adventure much more than if somebody said everything for you. A good example for this would be Animal Crossing (though it's not really an adventure).


Pink Moon is on its way.

CliCliW

I have a Ph.D in Horribleness.

Age 29
Female
Ireland
Seen August 15th, 2015
Posted August 15th, 2015
435 posts
10.4 Years
I suppose like you said it really does depend on the game. I like games where there is a talking protagonist if I want to know more about the story, about the people, etc.

That said, look at Jak and Daxter: The Precursor Legacy. Jak doesn't speak, but that's perfectly balanced in Daxter's yapping and the fact that everyone else explains most of the story/goings on and whatnot for you.

For a game like Pokemon, I think the silent character is better. How often do you really think your character makes a good contribution to the story? I think if your character were to talk it'd be a bit too intensive really. Rarely do I play hacks, and even less frequently do I find ones with intensive protagonist dialogue. Obviously it's a system that works and really, if it's not broke then don't fix it...

Alfabusa

Male
Sweden
Seen April 3rd, 2014
Posted February 13th, 2014
66 posts
13.7 Years
I have no mouth and I must scream.


It is nice to have the character be all silent, but I still think it would be cool to have the character going through atleast SOME kind of emotions. It feels as though the character isn't affected by anything, just doesn't care. No emotions!
I kinda liked the cinematic that played when the character faced with the legendary in X/Y. It displayed actual emotion coming from the character. More of that, please!
~TOTALLY LOOKIN' TO FILL MY POKÉMAN X FRIENDS LIST SO JUST THROW 'EM FRIEND CODES AT ME!~
FC: 2938-7447-8813
Friend Safari: Lampent, Phantump, Spiritomb.

My YouTube channel: http://www.youtube.com/user/alfabusa
*WARNING: alotta' swearing and stuff, and mainly for Warhammer 40k-fans.*


Shiny Bragging:
Breeding - Metagross, Cacturne, Stoutland, Gible
Fishing - Politoed, Octillery
Pokéradar - Zoroark
Friend Safari - Froslass, Hoothoot, Skarmory, Sneasel, Pancham, Noibat, Pawniard
Wonder Trade - Smeargle, Garchomp

Satoshi Ookami

Memento Mori

Age 30
Male
Abyss of Time, Great Seal
Seen August 5th, 2018
Posted July 3rd, 2018
14,253 posts
14.8 Years
Yea, infinite battle =D

For me it's like this...
If you can name your protagonist and it's a choice based game, I want silent protagonist.
If I'm playing as someone, I prefer developed character.
ROM hacking FAQ - Read before asking how to play a hack.

Anime List | PSN Trophy List

U.Flame

Maker of Short Games

Age 27
Male
Unknown
Seen 14 Hours Ago
Posted January 17th, 2023
1,322 posts
15 Years
This is such a great thread!

I think I can appreciate both styles (and the spectrum between them) equally. There are times where I absolutely agree with bcrobert's "my pokemon, my adventure" mindset. Other times, it's nice to be completely immersed into a story and some of my favorite games are dialogue-heavy with main characters interacting as, you know, actual characters.

I remember being a kid and thinking it was so weird that the main character wasn't talking. It didn't occur to me until I got older than the reason he wasn't talking was because he was supposed to be me, haha.
Thank you. This is such a big issue for me, the characters should interact as characters, but that strongly contradicts the personal adventure feeling. Then again, that's kind of a reoccurance of my hack, many things break the traditional Pokemon "formula". It's definately a hard decision.
The more you learn about something, the more you realize just how much you don't know. I've shelved my more ambitious ideas in favor of smaller, more feasible projects and contributions. While I still have an ongoing project, and still intend to experiment with improving Gen 3's multiplayer, it's been much less stressful doing smaller things, like entries for Anthroyd's MAGM contests.

Of which you can check out here:
Naillevaihcam
Magical Altering Gym Menagerie

Spinosaurus

Seen May 27th, 2019
Posted June 7th, 2018
4,569 posts
14.1 Years
That said, look at Jak and Daxter: The Precursor Legacy. Jak doesn't speak, but that's perfectly balanced in Daxter's yapping and the fact that everyone else explains most of the story/goings on and whatnot for you.
Ugh when they changed him into this angsty "I'm here to murder you" jerk I felt so pissed. Jak being silent in the first game helped Daxter radiate presence and gave him a bigger role. The two were a perfect contrast. Once they made Jak talk, not only did they hurt him, but they also hurt Daxter to the point that he felt he was just "there".
Age 30
Male
Seen December 13th, 2016
Posted February 28th, 2015
188 posts
9.8 Years
I'm cool with silent protags, but I like the main character when they talk. I like to see what they're thinking and feeling. I wanna empathize with them. I wanna see them grow as a person. In some games, though, I just prefer to have a silent protagonist. Like in Rune Factory.

Get away from my waifu, Lest.
Yo, isn't Finneon an Eevee evolution? I mean, it has -eon in the name...

Ozymandias

i'm going on a journey

under your bed
Seen March 10th, 2021
Posted February 24th, 2021
1,069 posts
10 Years
I gotta agree with Aus. I can respect both sides, some games work a lot better with silent protagonists (Elder Scrolls, Fallout) but some games need a developed main character (Last of Us, Bioshock Infinite, Walking Dead.) I think that games with developed main characters are the ones that attach on emotionally

U.Flame

Maker of Short Games

Age 27
Male
Unknown
Seen 14 Hours Ago
Posted January 17th, 2023
1,322 posts
15 Years
That is my goal, to create emotional attachment. A developed character seems logical, but it's unusual for Pokemon.
The more you learn about something, the more you realize just how much you don't know. I've shelved my more ambitious ideas in favor of smaller, more feasible projects and contributions. While I still have an ongoing project, and still intend to experiment with improving Gen 3's multiplayer, it's been much less stressful doing smaller things, like entries for Anthroyd's MAGM contests.

Of which you can check out here:
Naillevaihcam
Magical Altering Gym Menagerie

Fernbutter

Murder is the way.

Male
The depths of the internet
Seen June 10th, 2017
Posted June 2nd, 2014
821 posts
9.4 Years
Personally I like having a silent protagonist, it helps me focus more on the game than anything else, but at least giving them like emoticons popping up every now and then would make them actual people instead of soulless abominations that don't react to anything at all. But I'm chill with that.

But if its like a game where you play as a already developed character with a story and you just sorta follow with said story, then I would l enjoy it if they would be developed, because it helps me immerse myself into the game more.

There should be a signature here somewhere.
I wonder where it's gone.

Golden Warrior

Pokemon Professor

Age 25
Male
Hoenn
Seen August 30th, 2014
Posted May 30th, 2014
375 posts
12 Years
I personally enjoy a silent protagonist more as I feel I can react to things as if I were that character more then him/her reacting for me. Like yes/no answers in many Nintendo games or just not talking in some first 8-bit games, I truly feel like I AM that character.

With a pre-defined personality, I feel like I'm simply an onlooker, seeing the game happen, but not being that person doing the actions and reacting to the villains. This isn't always a bad thing, like The World Ends With you became my favorite RPG easily, but the protagonist is very un-silent. A silent protagonist can't have one thing a protagonist with a voice and personality can have: Character development. This is a very good plot feature in many games, but how can a protagonist with no personality get a better one? 0x10 is still 0.

So, I can either enjoy the game with good character development, or not have it and just feel like I'm the character and react on my own. In both cases, I am immersed.
Current Pokemon re-play through: XD: Gale of Darkness

3DS/Pokemon Y FC: 5300 - 9087 - 1138
I'll be up to battle or trade, I'll also always be up to multibattle. PM me if you add me here, give me a reason that you're adding me, and I'll be sure to add you back!

Friend Safari: Bug Type
Pokemon: Paras, Beautifly, and Pinsir.

Satoshi Ookami

Memento Mori

Age 30
Male
Abyss of Time, Great Seal
Seen August 5th, 2018
Posted July 3rd, 2018
14,253 posts
14.8 Years
A silent protagonist can't have one thing a protagonist with a voice and personality can have: Character development.
Voice.


Even silent characters can get development.
ROM hacking FAQ - Read before asking how to play a hack.

Anime List | PSN Trophy List

acatfrommars

Male
Seen February 5th, 2023
Posted January 9th, 2023
3,870 posts
9.6 Years
Developed characters. I feel like I get more into a game when I understand a character's story and their motives for what they are trying to accomplish. Also, if a character is developed over time like the Mass Effect or gears of War or God of War games then I get into it even more.