Ash,Manga/Game Red

Started by XpokeX April 12th, 2014 12:33 AM
  • 937 views
  • 11 replies

XpokeX

I'm a ninja and im..... gone

Age 22
Male
Seen 1 Week Ago
Posted April 20th, 2014
154 posts
9.3 Years
First of all,I'm not sure if this is the right place so please move if not.

Ash is basically the star of the pokemon anime

Manga Red is from the manga of course(pokemon adventures)

Game red is from the games (B/R/Y,G/SC,HGSS and FR/LF)

Which one of the three do you prefer or would you think would be the best in an all out showdown?

I like manga red out of all of them to say,(that spiky hair on the front looks cool) and I'd say a tie with the two reds if they battle :)

"Pokemon is my escape from reality,no one to judge or fight,it's just me having fun"

moon

they/them
Seen 11 Hours Ago
Posted 22 Hours Ago
37,443 posts
15.5 Years
Ash wouldn't stand a chance :p

Manga Red is ingenious while Game Red has ridiculously high leveled pokémon - including all three Kanto starters. I somehow feel like it's difficult to compare game Red and manga Red since they are more similar than Ash in comparison. Just going from their teams though, I'd say game Red might win in a showdown.
paired with Ivysaur

Satoshi Ookami

Memento Mori

Age 30
Male
Abyss of Time, Great Seal
Seen August 5th, 2018
Posted July 3rd, 2018
14,253 posts
14.8 Years
Considering that manga Red can get help from legendaries it might be him who would win...
Unless you count game Red as the one who caught Mewtwo and legendary birds.
ROM hacking FAQ - Read before asking how to play a hack.

Anime List | PSN Trophy List
Male
Seen November 13th, 2019
Posted November 15th, 2018
2,581 posts
11.8 Years
Considering that manga Red can get help from legendaries it might be him who would win...
Unless you count game Red as the one who caught Mewtwo and legendary birds.
That The Origin Red !
Game Red catch any pokemon we did and NPG Red only uses 3 kanto starter , Pikachu , Lapress/Espion.
But Ash doesn't a chance against any one of them .
It foolish to think a Boy who get his ass kicked by a total Beginner 3 times in a row is any match for Red.
The True Beauty of Anime

Rengoku

炎えん柱

Age 31
Male
Taishō-era Japan
Seen 2 Weeks Ago
Posted January 2nd, 2023
1,484 posts
13.7 Years
I always consider manga and in-game Red equal, though.
But I love the manga ones if I have to consider them as separated entities, he's much lively and does not only goes "..." :P
"However, if you bare your fangs at innocent people, my bright red flame blade will burn you to the bone!."
Private property what the heck are you doing here get out
Seen 6 Days Ago
Posted 4 Weeks Ago
693 posts
11.1 Years
If Game Red counts as the one you actually play as, rather than the one you face in Gold/Silver, then yeah, he'd win without a doubt. Being the character you play as gives him the capabilities to easily become the most powerful trainer in existence, at least when compared to anyone he can face in-game.

(Plus, with saving and all, he technically has control over time. If he loses, he can just reset and load the game :P)
Woah holy moly this boi's got a funky old signature

XpokeX

I'm a ninja and im..... gone

Age 22
Male
Seen 1 Week Ago
Posted April 20th, 2014
154 posts
9.3 Years
That The Origin Red !
Game Red catch any pokemon we did and NPG Red only uses 3 kanto starter , Pikachu , Lapress/Espion.
But Ash doesn't a chance against any one of them .
It foolish to think a Boy who get his ass kicked by a total Beginner 3 times in a row is any match for Red.
Isn't game red and Origin red the same?

"Pokemon is my escape from reality,no one to judge or fight,it's just me having fun"

Hiatus

Seen 1 Day Ago
Posted July 24th, 2021
12,283 posts
10.8 Years
I don't know... probably the in-game one. This Red put a lot of training into his Pokémon, while other two did not. Well, they did, but just not as much, I suppose. ;o; Ash focuses more on love and friendship between his Pokémon than anything, and same could be said for manga Red. Game Red, though; for him, this doesn't really seem to be the case.

Brendino

The Ruins of Alph
Seen 3 Days Ago
Posted April 6th, 2023
8,567 posts
13.4 Years
Unfortunately I don't have any knowledge of the manga, so I don't know how well that Red would fair against the other two. What I do know, is that Red from the games would probably walk all over Ash. Ash has shown that he's a good trainer with flashes of brilliance (some of the movies, Pokemon Leagues and the Battle Frontier are examples of this), but he makes far too many rookie mistakes for someone as accomplished as he is.

Satoshi Ookami

Memento Mori

Age 30
Male
Abyss of Time, Great Seal
Seen August 5th, 2018
Posted July 3rd, 2018
14,253 posts
14.8 Years
Isn't game red and Origin red the same?
Game Red is mostly the one you battle on Mt. Silver while Origins one had Mewtwo.
ROM hacking FAQ - Read before asking how to play a hack.

Anime List | PSN Trophy List
Male
Seen November 13th, 2019
Posted November 15th, 2018
2,581 posts
11.8 Years
Isn't game red and Origin red the same?
Nope , Game Red is the player character we use !
You can say that almost every people who played FRLG is Red themself .
However , Origin Red is the different Red with his own personality ,Background , skill & Pokemon.
The True Beauty of Anime