The UndergroundUnderneath the surface lies a deep, dark secret. Hidden from plain sight is a forum dedicated to betrayal, justice, and, of course, murder...games! Welcome to PC's mafia game hub!
What I don't understand is how the Bingo Hall would be able to send the message the same night as they tried to recruit the Whippersnapper, as they wouldn't know their action failed until the night was over. Or was this a day message then?
Ya I don't think I trust this "bingo card," since we haven't seen anything like it before. Unless the people who have received the previous ones were not inclined to share the info it had, this doesn't make sense to me.
JD brings up a good point too. If Klippy was the player they were planning on converting, why would they also target him with the bingo card and potentially leak one of their own?
So Nimsy was a recruit... interesting. I'm not sure what this says about Twiggy but I kind of want to say it makes him look more inno? The only way Twiggy could be mafia would be if the Bingo Caller attempted to recruit him earlier and the cult knew he was (but then I think Nimsy would have tried to push a lynch on him instead of me).
While Bard did post those possibilities regarding Golgari's potential alignment, I think he's most likely town. At least based on the interaction between him and Johnny on D1, I can't see them being teammates.
The whole message thing is weird to me though. Why is it only now that someone has come forward with a message? (if we're assuming this is from the likely cult'd Prankster). The Prankster can send up to 5 messages per day phase. It just doesn't make much sense for no one to have come forward with any messages they've received, even if the Prankster was unsure of who to send messages to or afraid or didn't know what to say, why not test the waters so to say and send a message to at least one person and see what happens? If anyone out there is withholding any other messages they should probably speak up. (Of course, there's the possibility of the ability being changed after being recruited but hnnnnng let's not get into that).
Still though, I agree with what Bard has said. [Execute] Klippy
Guys, the Prankster is like a Town Crier. His messages are broadcast to everyone in the thread, not to one specific individual. So the message wouldn't have come from that role. The "Bingo Card" is something else entirely if Golgari is telling the truth about it.
It's okay, guys. I have no way to dispute the evidence against me, except to say I'm innocent, so :(
I'm just casting this in return, against doof2, since he's the person bringing up the Bingo Card out of nowhere and is framing me. Good luck, Old Timers.
I honestly do not really understand the Bingo Card thing myself, but then again I am very new to this and so it's probably super obvious and that I'm just too blind to see it.
Anyway, I do agree that if Klippy turns out to be an inno we should look at Golgari for tomorrow. [Execute] Klippy
Klippy, when/which phase were you brought back into the game? I thought you were replacing an inactive player and would therefore have a role...
Also, Bard, you did a really good analysis of the current predicament we're in, but I feel like it's not complete. What if both are inno and the info that Golgari was given came from a non-Nursing Home source? I don't think it's too farfetch'd for the Prankster to get a modified ability after being converted. Or the Bingo Caller can do something else we weren't aware of... Or we're all just getting played for fools, idk.
I'm going to hold off voting for Klippy/Golgari just yet, but this is the only "lead" we have right now...
I might be very wrong about this, but I do remember the mafia being inactive night one. Klippy replaced someone, correct? Klippy could have very easily replaced the inactive mafia. I wasn't really able to follow earlier in the game so this probably was cleared up already(may it be a selection to do no one, or the mafia becoming active again). I just want to bring this to light-
eeeee.. i'm really confused about this whole bingo card thing and it's a little odd seeing the first one surface the thread on day 5 but i always have a hard time believing klippy [execute] klippy
I have a bad feeling that we're getting played, but I can't tell if it's that the bingo card was lying to Golgari, or that Golgari is lying about the card to begin with... But I feel like that would be a terrible play on Golgari's part cause the fos would be on him the next day, soo I guess [Execute] Klippy
It appears that the only third party roles left are the bingo caller and nanny, we also know for sure that there are at least two more children - the thief and moody teenager were both mentioned, and we don't have a confirmed number of bingo players, but I'm going to guess they have somewhere around 3-4 members. It also appears that the bingo card I received was correct about Klippy.
2 people are probably Whippersnappers, 2 third party (nanny, and bingo caller), and the bingo goers, and the innos left.
We could say that nanny is probably a werewolf role, because they drained a whippersnappers life?
If at most we have 4 or more potential candidates. Juno and I have softclaimed, but most probably the bingo caller has gotten us so that is not so much reliable. But it does prove that we are not whippersnappers or the nanny, or the bingo caller. jd probably softclaimed but idr if he did.
tbh, im fosing on bard and twiggy tho... maybe even superjolt :x idk why but i feel bard could probably be the bingo caller coz he's been a recruiter for how many times now, and i cant shake the feeling that he's one as well. however thats just my gunner gut talking and you guys know how "reliable" it is so take that with a grain of salt >.>
__________________
Flying the flag for Ireland in the 2021 PokéCommunity Eurovision Event!
It's been a while since the last phase, I need some time to remember a lot of things that have happened lol
Wasn't there also the Old Maid? Did they die too?