Why was Pokemon Z skipped?

Started by Gold and Red May 16th, 2016 6:51 PM
  • 8571 views
  • 96 replies
Male
Obscure cities, that are dark.
Seen July 4th, 2016
Posted July 4th, 2016
611 posts
8.5 Years
In part because of the anniversary meaning that they wish to release something more notable, but in general they might not have any particular plans for a Z that they made that much effort on, or the release of OR/AS, and on the side the earlier games, was deemed sufficient without needing a third version. They might not have felt that a third version including perhaps a Zygarde would have been something they could pull off properly at the time, or alternatively it would have not if they went ahead with such things have made the impact they would prefer for this year, which at least gives them some apparent momentum with the fanbase if they wanted to try releasing a new game.
When it dawns that Keats' idea of 'negative capability' is basically reducible to the public perception of Lucario.


Male
Seen October 29th, 2022
Posted September 30th, 2019
198 posts
7.7 Years
Masuda flat out said he wanted to surprise people instead of doing things people expect like Grey or Z version.

Also, I don't know about you, but I'm a lot more excited for a new game with new Pokemon and a new region than a rehash that's 95% the same thing as XY but with some post-game content slapped on. If they want to include Zygarde stuff they can do that without doing another Platinum or Emerald style game.

ZangooseClaw

Pokemon Philosopher

Male
East Coast, Sinnoh
Seen June 3rd, 2016
Posted June 3rd, 2016
17 posts
7 Years
The developers' efforts to create a trilogy have obviously slowed since generation four so perhaps this means an overall shift in strategy to brand new regions.

It's easy to get off topic on a thread like this with multiple cases of missing third links, but why Z specifically was skipped is anyone's guess. Sure, it had a more substantial storyline than others & an overhaul in game design/mechanics so why fix what isn't broken and instead move on to the next great adventure?
Age 33
Female
United States
Seen December 10th, 2017
Posted December 10th, 2017
1,011 posts
7.7 Years
I think we should take into consideration that they've basically been hyping us up for Gen 7 since we seen that Backpacker with the Strange Souvenir in XY. That shows they've had at least Alola's location basis in SM planned out since XY's developement. To my knowledge, they've never blatantly foreshadowed an upcoming region in that manner. For whatever reason, they felt it was the right time during XY's release to give us a hint at what was coming.

I do think we'll be able to obtain Zygarde's other Formes in SM. Like I said in the other thread, they gave them height and weight stats, which are usually specific for the main series games. Those stats are completely useless in the anime, so it doesn't make sense to give them those stats but yet keep them in the anime and side-games.

Also, what ever happened with that Unown Z in Super Mystery Dungeon that blabbered on about "I've got to tell somebody about Z!"?

blue

gucci

Male
United Kingdom
Seen September 26th, 2021
Posted August 7th, 2019
21,056 posts
15.4 Years
Yeah Masuda himself stated that Z would be predictable and he'd prefer to surprise people. That doesn't mean a Pokemon Z style game can't exist as different titles, I'm still guessing that Sun and Moon will have connections to X/Y.

Ho-Oh

used Sacred Fire!

Age 31
Female
QLD, Australia
Seen June 5th, 2022
Posted April 23rd, 2022
35,988 posts
17.5 Years
I expect to be disappointed with Sun & Moon. Since XY and ORAS my expectations are really low since both kind of lacked a lot of Post Game and XY felt unfinished.
The cool thing is that they were a few years ago. Consider how much the games have changed from RBY to ORAS. Even ORAS improved on the basic post-game - you had a whole sub-plot dedicated to Rayquaza, which is pretty awesome. Just think what we can potentially have in Sun and Moon, it's pretty exciting! :)

Anyway it does feel a little off that there wasn't a 'Z' but I think that opens up potential a lot more. When remakes time comes - we'll get Pokemon Gray and Pokemon Z then (which is possibly a contributing factor - why make a ****ty half-assed version when you hold off and give those titles a game that is actually worth the title... with full on graphics, Pokemon, etc).

Desert Stream~

Holy Kipper!

She/Her
Seen 3 Weeks Ago
Posted July 3rd, 2021
3,269 posts
7.5 Years
Do we really need a third version every single time? The truth is, a ton of games have secrets, but that doesn't mean they are "unfinished" It just means that the game developers wanted to do something different.
https://discord.gg/nqfg9UE Please join I need members ;_;
Female
Seen April 22nd, 2018
Posted March 2nd, 2018
895 posts
8.4 Years
Remember that this is Masuda we're talking about. His idea of "surprising" people usually equates to pulling the rug out from under them and leaving them hanging.

Just look at what he did with the very first games he directed. Most fans were expecting a GSC sequel and a continuation of the Kanto/Johto story, and instead, we got a hard reboot set on an isolated tropical island. (Hmm, sound familiar, doesn't it?) Yeah, he sure "surprised" people there, enough to drive a large chunk of them into quitting the franchise, that is.

To be honest, I think the idea of sequels is dead for as long as Masuda continues to be in charge of the games. Even if he hasn't come out and said it, he doesn't seem to be a fan of sequels. His very first games went out of their way to break ties with previous games, and every single consecutive gen released since then has been an isolated entity with no connection to any previous gens.

As far as I know, even B2W2 were only made because of Nintendo. Since the games were on the dying DS handheld, Nintendo thought that sequels would sell better than a standard third version, possibly one of the only times ever that executive meddling actually improved a series.

Jeischita_Homaji

Resident of the Acalia Region

Male
Canada (Acalia Region)
Seen June 9th, 2016
Posted June 2nd, 2016
31 posts
7 Years
It wasn't skipped, there were never any plans for it to begin with and, frankly, it wasn't needed.

"This signature is exactly 225x600 so it had better not get removed. The old one was 225x750".
"Not sure why thats such a huge deal but I won't argue with the set rules".

LilBueno

Boy Wonder

Male
Straight Outta Gotham
Seen July 11th, 2018
Posted May 30th, 2018
243 posts
9.5 Years
I agree with this 100%. Not sure why everyone wanted more Kalos, I thought it was on of the weakest regions plus it's the 20th anniversary they are obviously going to do something special, Z would have been anything but special.
As much as I could take or leave a Z version, I don't agree with that mindset. A third version could have been made to fix the weakest region, especially considering how monumental the first 3D region should have been.
Contributor for Comic Book Global
Latest Article: 10 Ways Flashpoint Will Affect Season 3 of 'The Flash'

KH-Vids
Your Number 1 Source for All Kingdom Hearts Media!

COOLTRAINER♂

Speedball 2: Brutal Vanilluxe

Male
Seen July 1st, 2019
Posted January 2nd, 2017
235 posts
9.5 Years
Just look at what he did with the very first games he directed. Most fans were expecting a GSC sequel and a continuation of the Kanto/Johto story, and instead, we got a hard reboot set on an isolated tropical island. (Hmm, sound familiar, doesn't it?) Yeah, he sure "surprised" people there, enough to drive a large chunk of them into quitting the franchise, that is.
This sounds pretty hard to source tbh.

Hikamaru

Age 30
Female
Australia
Seen January 24th, 2019
Posted September 4th, 2018
50,214 posts
12.2 Years
Like the others said, Masuda loves throwing surprises and we haven't had a proper third game since Platinum. I'm not sure if Zygarde will have a role since it's not a 7th Gen Pokemon but it will be interesting to see how it's handled.
Gone forever for personal reasons.
Visit my Tumblr page if you wish to contact me.

http://daikenkki.tumblr.com/

Keiran

[b]Rock Solid[/b]

Age 31
New Jersey
Seen March 14th, 2022
Posted July 25th, 2018
2,441 posts
12.1 Years
It's pretty obvious why Z was skipped.


Year Platform Title Sales(in millions)

1996 GB Pokémon Red, Blue, and Green 31.38

1998 GB Pokémon Yellow: Special Pikachu Edition 14.64

1999 GB Pokémon Gold and Silver 23.10

2000 GBC Pokémon Crystal 6.39

2002 GBA Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire 16.22

2004 GBA Pokémon FireRed and LeafGreen 12.00

2004 GBA Pokémon Emerald 6.32

2006 DS Pokémon Diamond and Pearl 17.63

2008 DS Pokémon Platinum 7.60

2009 DS Pokémon HeartGold and SoulSilver 12.72

2010 DS Pokémon Black and White 15.60

2012 DS Pokémon Black 2 and White 2 8.52

2013 3DS Pokémon X and Y 14.70

2014 3DS Pokémon Omega Ruby & Alpha Sapphire 11.84


Remakes and third versions don't sell nearly as well as completely new games. With how poorly XY were received, it's no surprise that Kalos has been abandoned. Gen 4 sales were up due to the popularity of Gen 3 (hence Gen 3 gets a remake), but sales have slipped consistently since. When sales trend downward you need to rethink your strategy which is what they're doing.
Mod of Trade Corner| Pair | Trainer Information

When kings upon the main have clung to pride
And held themselves as masters of the sea
I've held them down beneath the crushing tide
Till they have learned that no one masters me

COOLTRAINER♂

Speedball 2: Brutal Vanilluxe

Male
Seen July 1st, 2019
Posted January 2nd, 2017
235 posts
9.5 Years
I'm not really sure on that because of the time and staff savings of creating an enhanced version of your previous game vs a brand-new title even if you sell single millions rather than double-digits.
Besides since there are differences in how many of each console were produced to begin with, I feel X and Y and OR/AS did quite well to nearly match the later DS Pokemon games since the amount of DSes sold grew very fast around 2008 - 2009.
Female
Seen April 22nd, 2018
Posted March 2nd, 2018
895 posts
8.4 Years
Remakes and third versions don't sell nearly as well as completely new games. With how poorly XY were received, it's no surprise that Kalos has been abandoned. Gen 4 sales were up due to the popularity of Gen 3 (hence Gen 3 gets a remake), but sales have slipped consistently since. When sales trend downward you need to rethink your strategy which is what they're doing.
Also, don't forget about this:

http://www.hngn.com/articles/188089/20160312/classic-pok%C3%A9mon-3ds-re-release-shatters-eshop-sale-records.htm

The re-release of RBY is already proving itself to be an easy profit, especially when you consider that GF and Nintendo didn't have to spend hardly a dime on it (vs a full-blown remake). With the VC now becoming a more viable solution for bringing old, outdated games onto current hardware, we might see remakes become a thing of the past. Why spend time and money remaking an old game when you can just re-release the originals for a more guaranteed proft, after all?
Age 28
Male
Oregon
Seen September 24th, 2018
Posted July 3rd, 2018
17,520 posts
13.1 Years
It's pretty obvious why Z was skipped.


Year Platform Title Sales(in millions)

1996 GB Pokémon Red, Blue, and Green 31.38

1998 GB Pokémon Yellow: Special Pikachu Edition 14.64

1999 GB Pokémon Gold and Silver 23.10

2000 GBC Pokémon Crystal 6.39

2002 GBA Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire 16.22

2004 GBA Pokémon FireRed and LeafGreen 12.00

2004 GBA Pokémon Emerald 6.32

2006 DS Pokémon Diamond and Pearl 17.63

2008 DS Pokémon Platinum 7.60

2009 DS Pokémon HeartGold and SoulSilver 12.72

2010 DS Pokémon Black and White 15.60

2012 DS Pokémon Black 2 and White 2 8.52

2013 3DS Pokémon X and Y 14.70

2014 3DS Pokémon Omega Ruby & Alpha Sapphire 11.84


Remakes and third versions don't sell nearly as well as completely new games. With how poorly XY were received, it's no surprise that Kalos has been abandoned. Gen 4 sales were up due to the popularity of Gen 3 (hence Gen 3 gets a remake), but sales have slipped consistently since. When sales trend downward you need to rethink your strategy which is what they're doing.
Damn, and people call Gen III the low point of Pokemon. If you only compare the original pairs (since they all share one) then RS did have a big drop compared to GS before it, but even then DP did managed to bring sales up. However, BW and XY see a downward push again. If this continues then SM will have like 13 Million or so in sales. Right now Pokemon is that a historical low point, sales wise. Of course sales doesn't mean if the game is good or bad. I enjoyed Emerald, but it's the worst selling one up there. And others say that BW were the best games yet (I think the Gen IV metal games were the high point), but they didn't do as good. Of course Yellow, Crystal, Emerald and all of Gen V might've suffered due to being at the end of the game's life time, thus they didn't do as good. That can't be said for Gen VI though.

@ Betty, then we'll be seeing a new generation every two years or so since Third versions, Sequels, and Remakes have been used to drag on the generation. At that point we might as well toss the idea of generations or we'll be doubling the number of Gen in less time than the first Seven.
I'm currently working on some novels. If you're interested you can read them here:
https://www.wattpad.com/user/ImperialSun

Z25

Team Player

Age 25
Male
Seen September 25th, 2021
Posted February 26th, 2018
1,800 posts
10.3 Years
Let's put it this way, pokemon Z wasn't "skipped"
It was never going to exist in the first place.
This. There was no thought of doing Z. Sun and moon already had stuff being worked on for it during XY as that's what the Strange Souvenir was for. ORAS and XY were meant to be filler imo. XY lacked quite a lot from the 5th gen which gave everything fans wanted, story, many new pokemon, old pokemon, challenge, and more. All of which ORAS lacked but seem to be building to Sun and Moon for, as evidence by the backpacker talking about qamazing sights in his region( possibly a nod to the graphics update and the amazing places in Hawaii that will be featured in Sun and Moon) and new battle facility.

The anime using Z should have been a dead giveaway that Z was coming as well. they want Sun and Moon to be the big focus, answer all of Gen 6's questions, and give the fans what they want while celebrating the Series anniversary,

Keiran

[b]Rock Solid[/b]

Age 31
New Jersey
Seen March 14th, 2022
Posted July 25th, 2018
2,441 posts
12.1 Years
Damn, and people call Gen III the low point of Pokemon. If you only compare the original pairs (since they all share one) then RS did have a big drop compared to GS before it, but even then DP did managed to bring sales up. However, BW and XY see a downward push again. If this continues then SM will have like 13 Million or so in sales. Right now Pokemon is that a historical low point, sales wise. Of course sales doesn't mean if the game is good or bad. I enjoyed Emerald, but it's the worst selling one up there. And others say that BW were the best games yet (I think the Gen IV metal games were the high point), but they didn't do as good. Of course Yellow, Crystal, Emerald and all of Gen V might've suffered due to being at the end of the game's life time, thus they didn't do as good. That can't be said for Gen VI though.

@ Betty, then we'll be seeing a new generation every two years or so since Third versions, Sequels, and Remakes have been used to drag on the generation. At that point we might as well toss the idea of generations or we'll be doubling the number of Gen in less time than the first Seven.
I'm expecting S&M sales to be higher than X&Y actually. With the 2DS, and how cheap it is now, a lot more people will have access to S&M. Plus the game should be a lot more appealing since a lot more development time went into it (or should have), since a third version was skipped. But we'll see about that.
Mod of Trade Corner| Pair | Trainer Information

When kings upon the main have clung to pride
And held themselves as masters of the sea
I've held them down beneath the crushing tide
Till they have learned that no one masters me