I'm already working on revamping the Smash roleplay. I looked back at the IC post and I realize the mistakes I made (it was so cringey). That's one roleplay I'd like to go back!
Hello, you may remember me from PTA. I know your name, but it has been a while since I have RPed.
I am also wanting to see another PTA RP. I don't know if it should be exactly the same, and I think it should be a bit bigger than an island. I think it should also be far more wide spread. If you are just on an island with 1 school and 1 town, you run out of stuff to do and it is hard to spend so long on just an island without a change. When I joined, it was starting to slowly becoming inactive. We were on a single JP for almost a year before more activity was brought back in, but then it completely vanished because it took forever for that JP to be put in.
But yes, I would really really love another PTA RP. And I have had hopes for someone to make a new one or to revive PTA in a way. I do think there needs to be some type of storyline in it, as there wasn't much of a storyline in PTA it was almost too sandboxy.
I can't say much on the others as I have not played Splatoon before, and I don't know much about Nintendo games outside of Super Smash Bros, Pokemon and Mario Kart. But if that one RP is similar to Smash Bros, I am not sure I like the idea too much if it is nothing, but fighting like the games. I think it would become boring after a while.
As for the combat heavy plot, I understand it, but again, I think it could be boring after a while. And I find it really hard to write stuff that involves guns or gun like things. Playing a combat heavy game is fun, but just don't know if it would be too fun with RP.
If you do make a new PTA or something similar, please please please let me know.
One reason I liked "As the Dust Settles" was because I found it similar to PTA, but my group completely fell apart before we even got to the first mission and we had so much planning in the mission. I think combining the things from both the RPs could be amazing. Especially if you divided it into Team Valor, Mystic, and Instinct, and possibly a 4th team.
I don't think I remember you when I was part of the roleplay. Remember, it's been almost 3-4 years since I was last active. xD
I really really love your idea of sorting students by GO teams. It's a great idea and I think people can use their GO personas from their account. I was leaning towards making a Pokemon GO roleplay, but my ideas weren't up to par. Back then we separated students by Suicune, Raikou, and Entei.
I will let you know if I do decide to make a new, revamped version of PTA...except it won't be called PTA, or be extremely sandboxy...but I really want to make this roleplay beginner-friendly.
Keep them coming, guys. I'm actively working behind the scenes right now so I should get some work in by this weekend or so. Really appreciate the input <3