Graphic Rating Thread Page 37

Started by Sawyer June 1st, 2005 6:47 AM
  • 47389 views
  • 1050 replies

Loki

x

Seen March 23rd, 2022
Posted June 14th, 2020
6,822 posts
17.8 Years
Guys, it would help to put the name of the person's graphics that you're rating. If that made sense. xD

And also, it would help if you didn't just demand ratings, but gave good ratings back to people.

Honestly, the giving holiday is only like, three days away, and nobody's giving out ratings. ;<

Relyt; The font hurts. :/ The font, the stroke, it just doesn't fit at all. The render doesn't take too much focus, which isn't good at all. The 'burned' effect around the whole banner looks extremely unnatural... though the way you made that single strip in the middle clear and the rest of the background blurry is really cool, and the background itself is nice. Just work on text, render positioning, and blending. It's definitely blended, but it looks... odd to me. xD;;

Aaron; On your most recent banner, blending would definitely help a bit. The text is painful here too. Stands out wayyy too much. The drop shadow would be best replaced with just a plain border too. *not a fan of the drop shadow border*


Mizt, if you'd like me to rate your banner/whatever on page 36, it would do plenty good to re-post it, because I'm not going to go out of my way to look for it. ^^

Chikara

ʕ´•ᴥ•`ʔ

Age 31
Female
Missouri, why? ◉◡◉
Seen April 11th, 2021
Posted March 27th, 2021
8,284 posts
18.6 Years
I made a banner~

It's made of just 2 colors, and it took forever to come up with how to make the picture not look stupid. But we shall see then. AND it's Atsushi Otani from Lovely Complex <3


Chikara

ʕ´•ᴥ•`ʔ

Age 31
Female
Missouri, why? ◉◡◉
Seen April 11th, 2021
Posted March 27th, 2021
8,284 posts
18.6 Years
Well if you want someone to do it then I will XD;

1) I don't like how grungy it looks. I LIKE grunge, but, it's just too much. The text fits though, and the avatar is cool so 6/10

2) You can barely see Mario in that ._.
The background is nice, but I think you made the overlay on Mario way too dark. You can barely see the text on both the banner and the avatar that HAS the text. 4/10

Out of the two of them, I have to say I like the first one better.
I"m no good at this so if anyone else wants to rate him, go ahead XD;

Loki

x

Seen March 23rd, 2022
Posted June 14th, 2020
6,822 posts
17.8 Years
Color Me Evil; O_O AMAZLING. I really really like this banner, the render positioning is awesome, the text positioning is perfect, along with that crescent-thing that sort of helps the text that's subtle stand out just a bit more. The tiny text on the bottom of the actual text gives it a really nice effect too, and the color layers work out really really well. Point-blank, I love this banner like no other. 10/10

(I love color layers! >:D Even though they never really work for me. xD)

Mizt;

Well, both of them have an insanely huge problem. The focus is nowhere.

1. Text is way too big, stands out way too much, the black brushing in the corner stands out too much as well, it's hard to read the text in the black brushing, the render is pretty much gone under all the effects, and the banner is annoyingly huge. Just to name a few problems that irk me. If there wasn't the fact that your render looks as though it's disappearing behind the busy background, and there wasn't a render at all, then it'd look a lot better. Lower the opacity on the text or something next time.

2. You're blending, too much. If you don't blend at all, then it looks like you just stuck a picture on top of a background. But if you blend too much, you lose your focus, and it just looks like a big red thing with darker red pixels splashed across it. The text is impossible to read, and it's just... overdone. AKA; I think you overdid it on this one. To be dead honest, I'm not really liking this banner at all. :/

Chikara; Cuuuute text positioning! :O You're definitely getting better, but the scratchy effect on the stock that doesn't apply to the rest of it is a major... well, I don't really like it. xD *Has always hated filters* I think you could've made the stock stand out in a different way. Perhaps if you'd left the stock as it was, and just made the color of it darker than the color of the text, that'd be- oh wait, you were going for the two-tone color scheme.... xD; Well, I wouldn't know how to remedy it then. </3 The starry brushes on the right are nice, but you probably could've added more.
In your charasmatic fantasy.
Seen July 16th, 2014
Posted July 16th, 2014
1,625 posts
15.8 Years
O_O I think after that ill just give up...
I'll just post my last set(for a member at another forum):

if you want to see the banner pm me. bye (mabye forever) *shot*

mizt~
Pokemon Copper Version - Now on PC!
New pokemon, new region, new adventure!

i am a graphic designer :: want to help me w/ pokemon copper?

Loki

x

Seen March 23rd, 2022
Posted June 14th, 2020
6,822 posts
17.8 Years
o_o;

No need to take it so personally.

You asked for the comments in the first place, it's not like I guarunteed that they'd be telling you how wonderfully masterful your banners are. If you just stop now, then I'll end up saying those things to you forever, but if you work on making them better, then I'll probably say a few more positive things. Besides, it's not like I'm speaking for the whole community. <_< Those comments are just me.

But you know, you do what you want, what you think is best.

Also, this is a graphic rating thread, not a random comments thread. I've ignored it up to now, but try and make your replies a little less off-topic Mizt.



Anyway, I forgot to ask this to be rated, so if anyone would be so kind as to give me some useful comments...


I think the scanlines might be too obvious, but oh well. :/
In your charasmatic fantasy.
Seen July 16th, 2014
Posted July 16th, 2014
1,625 posts
15.8 Years
o_o;

No need to take it so personally.

You asked for the comments in the first place, it's not like I guarunteed that they'd be telling you how wonderfully masterful your banners are. If you just stop now, then I'll end up saying those things to you forever, but if you work on making them better, then I'll probably say a few more positive things. Besides, it's not like I'm speaking for the whole community. <_< Those comments are just me.

But you know, you do what you want, what you think is best.

Also, this is a graphic rating thread, not a random comments thread. I've ignored it up to now, but try and make your replies a little less off-topic Mizt.



Anyway, I forgot to ask this to be rated, so if anyone would be so kind as to give me some useful comments...


I think the scanlines might be too obvious, but oh well. :/
I dont know what the cra* youre talking about, anyways 10/10 nice
one more:

if you want to see the banner pm me
Pokemon Copper Version - Now on PC!
New pokemon, new region, new adventure!

i am a graphic designer :: want to help me w/ pokemon copper?

Loki

x

Seen March 23rd, 2022
Posted June 14th, 2020
6,822 posts
17.8 Years
I don't think you need to censor the word crap.

Anyway, this one is considerably better. A border would be good, and maybe if the red value and contrast weren't quite so heavy on the Typhlosion.


Evilcheese; I didn't rate your banner because you were too lazy to rate anyone else's. So I guess I was just too lazy to rate yours. Sorry.
In your charasmatic fantasy.
Seen July 16th, 2014
Posted July 16th, 2014
1,625 posts
15.8 Years
I don't think you need to censor the word crap.

Anyway, this one is considerably better. A border would be good, and maybe if the red value and contrast weren't quite so heavy on the Typhlosion.


Evilcheese; I didn't rate your banner because you were too lazy to rate anyone else's. So I guess I was just too lazy to rate yours. Sorry.
ehehehe why thank you! I'll think of that! :D
I'm not sure how to make the broken up border though :(
Pokemon Copper Version - Now on PC!
New pokemon, new region, new adventure!

i am a graphic designer :: want to help me w/ pokemon copper?

Shika

F o r e s t Wizard

Age 29
Seen September 17th, 2009
Posted September 20th, 2008
1,192 posts
16.1 Years

I think the scanlines might be too obvious, but oh well. :/
OMG! This is the one for Musashi-kun right?
The scanlines settings are perfect! They are not too obvious in my opinion.
And it's blended too well that I don't know where the render starts and end. 8D
For the C4D usage, the think the one on the render's hair should be erased. To be exact, it's around 105 degrees from the render's left(on my side) eye.
I can't really read the last text though. 'Uiew' I guess.

Anyway, the positioning is well done and it's as expected from Mizzy chan 8D

Double Edit: I forgot that there is a word called 'View' xD
I dont know what the cra* youre talking about, anyways 10/10 nice
one more:

if you want to see the banner pm me
You are using filter effects too much and did you just used paint bucket tool for the background?

Side Note: Did you get any pm from people bugging you to show them your secretly hidden banner? I guess not...

----------

EDIT: I wanna get more comments from other people about this banner.
Up to now, I only got that the render is not blended enough.

| Pokemon Claims: + - + | Bishie Claims: Mx0: + | Naruto: + - + | Fairy Tail: + - + - + |

Shika

F o r e s t Wizard

Age 29
Seen September 17th, 2009
Posted September 20th, 2008
1,192 posts
16.1 Years
I missed two. heehee
Rate please! =O



It's pretty old. xD
The total outcome is nice even though I would lower the Musical Notes layers so it won't get all mixed with the text. And shades of '>'s are nice but seeing one shade twice is not that good. Maybe make the text darker? After all, i still love this one.

i guess you didnt see that anyways I love the text of that banner it fits in very well ^^
The render is not cut off great. You did this one just to test the border right? Experiment failed. Look at the two sides of borders, one thiner and one thicker! If you call that 'style' it's not appealing to me. And the text needs to be more visible. And the decorations under the text is just OVER the limits.
Render placement wrong, render not cut well, not blended well, background empty, too much text decorations, border not appealing. ^^'
You did it quick right?
| Pokemon Claims: + - + | Bishie Claims: Mx0: + | Naruto: + - + | Fairy Tail: + - + - + |