Ideas for Pokemon Evolution Methods

Started by ReKoil July 3rd, 2021 11:07 AM
  • 3519 views
  • 15 replies

ReKoil

Male
Netherlands
Seen 7 Hours Ago
Posted 7 Hours Ago
31,016 posts
2.9 Years
Not sure if this is the right section tbh, but I feel like it doesn't necessarily have to be an evolution from/for in-game, so this would be the better section?

Sword/Shield introduced a couple new evolution methods, for example: galar yamask needs to take 49+ damage in one battle and then you need to take it to the big rock thing to evolve it into runerigus. Galar Farfetch'd needs 3 critical hits in one battle to evolve into Sirfetch'd.

So my question is as follows: what do you think could potentially be a new evolution method in the future, be it in pokemon games or just the pokemon universe in general?
Or perhaps you'd like to replace a current evolution method with a new one? For example: replace trade evolutions with a method that does not require trading? Replace certain (or all) level up evolutions with time of day or location or affection evolutions? Go crazy =)

Personally I think a mon that would evolve based on a status condition could be cool. It could start out, say a pure Grass type. It gets poisoned in a battle and survives the battle and evolves to become a Grass/Poison type! However, if it were to have been paralyzed, it would evolve into a Grass/Electric type instead! Burn? Grass/Fire! Frozen? Grass/Ice! Asleep? Grass/Dark!
Also feel like the current evolution stones have gone underutilized. Most evolve only a handful of pokemon. Why not make, for example, Milotic evolve by Water Stone?
Flying the flag for Estonia in the 2023 PokéCommunity Eurovision Event!


Eurovision Event 2023

Trade Shop | My HA pokemon trade sheet. | My Shinies. | My VPP.
Mega Swampert @ Level 100: 31,081 | Dragonair @ Level 100: 30,291

Sheep

She/Her
Australia
Seen 2 Hours Ago
Posted 21 Hours Ago
39,243 posts
16.6 Years
With the absurd evolution method they gave Galarian Yamask (which should be replaced with...almost anything else, really) I definitely think there are lots of possibilities. Hopefully none that stressful but based on status condition as you said would be interesting, and maybe a few based on having less friendship/learning Frustration? Though that probably won't happen since it's encouraging being mean to your Pokémon haha. But I did see a fanmade Pokémon in a fangame recently that had split evolutions depending on if it learned Return or Frustration and that was a really cool concept! Though I don't know how to rework it so Frustration continued to stay viable, since leveling anything up naturally gives it friendship and reduces Frustration's power.

Also, a Pokémon in your party evolving only if you catch another specific Pokémon would be neat and unique!
Seen 1 Day Ago
Posted 1 Day Ago
990 posts
2.6 Years
-A spirit (Probably Ghost type) Pokémon designed around the concept of draining energy. It would evolve after draining more than XX HP from a single opponent in battle (and defeating it). It could evolve into different forms depending on the type of the opponent it absorbed energy from, but of course limited to a few specific types (for example Dark or Fairy)

-A Pokémon that evolves after receiving a critical hit that takes 90% or more of its HP. It would acquire Battle Armor or something similar upon evolving.

-A (Fighting?) Pokémon that evolves after single-handedly defeating three or more opponents in a single battle.

I would get rid of trade evolutions because they just never made any sense. Pokémon are supposed to evolve upon achieving something, like reaching a certain level, or a strong friendship bond with their trainer, learning a specific move, etc. or by being exposed to an energy source that powers them up. But what's even the lore explanation for why a Pokémon evolves upon abandoning it and giving it away to someone else?. All these games' speech about raising your Pokémon with love and care goes down the toilet the moment you have to give a Pokémon away so that another person can get its evolved form. The fact that Happiness drops all the way down once a Pokémon is traded is an obvious sign that they don't like to be traded at all.

Devalue

Any pronoun
Online now
Posted 9 Minutes Ago
16,512 posts
2.2 Years
For Pokemon like Munchlax or Milcery: Feed them a berry three times in one battle.

For Pokemon like Sneasel and Nickit: Steal a held item

For a Fighting type Pokemon: Max out its Effort Values

For friendly Pokemon: Use Celebrate a total of 15 times

For Pokemon like Inkay: Reach +6 OR -6 in any stat. Evolves very differently based on which occurs. (Could see this as a precursor to Plusle and Minun too.)
Current Virtual Pokemon Pet: Serperior
Level 100 at 16432 posts
No current Tag-Team
Flying the flag for Georgia in the 2023 PokéCommunity Eurovision Event!


Eurovision Event 2023

Game Journal Thread
Most Recent Entry: Chained Echoes

ReKoil

Male
Netherlands
Seen 7 Hours Ago
Posted 7 Hours Ago
31,016 posts
2.9 Years
Though I don't know how to rework it so Frustration continued to stay viable, since leveling anything up naturally gives it friendship and reduces Frustration's power.
Just a thought that immediately popped into a mind upon reading this: the games have an item called Soothe Bell, which helps your pokemon grow friendlier to you faster. maybe add an item that does the opposite? While it holds it it will grow more frustrated until reaching rock-bottom and it stays there. Even if it gains some happiness from leveling up it can be undone again by such an item.
Flying the flag for Estonia in the 2023 PokéCommunity Eurovision Event!


Eurovision Event 2023

Trade Shop | My HA pokemon trade sheet. | My Shinies. | My VPP.
Mega Swampert @ Level 100: 31,081 | Dragonair @ Level 100: 30,291

Duck

🦆 quack quack

he, they
Seen February 23rd, 2023
Posted February 22nd, 2023
5,750 posts
2.4 Years
Also, a Pokémon in your party evolving only if you catch another specific Pokémon would be neat and unique!
We do kinda have that. Mantyke needs to level up with Remoraid in the party, and Accelgor / Escavalier need to be traded with each other.

In a broader sense I'd either try to keep away from the more quirky methods like "Flip the game system upside down", "Trade with this specific Pokémon (and they're version exclusives)" or "Take 49 HP damage then go to this place", or go balls to the walls with them.

Like, if we're going quirky, we're going quirky. Why not steal from Digimon and have "knockout X Pokémon of Y type" as an evolution requirement, or "be bred in captivity + have Pokemon of Z type as a father", or even have "faint in battle" as an evolution method into the Ghost type. Heck, I'd be down to go all the way to "dance around a stone during the full moon" with QTE.

Is it very weird and different from traditional Pokémon, yup? Could it be awesome and help set the tone of New Pokémon (since they're clearly trying to usher a new era of Pokémon games with different expectations here)? Also yup.

That said, I do love the status idea given, I think it could be super fun. I'd also suggest that hypothetical Grass Type to evolve into a carnivore plant if they end the battle under Infestation.

Sheep

She/Her
Australia
Seen 2 Hours Ago
Posted 21 Hours Ago
39,243 posts
16.6 Years
Just a thought that immediately popped into a mind upon reading this: the games have an item called Soothe Bell, which helps your pokemon grow friendlier to you faster. maybe add an item that does the opposite? While it holds it it will grow more frustrated until reaching rock-bottom and it stays there. Even if it gains some happiness from leveling up it can be undone again by such an item.
That would be cool! Or maybe they can just evolve and never gain happiness as one of the Pokémon's gimmicks. Probably not the hardest thing for GF to work around.

We do kinda have that. Mantyke needs to level up with Remoraid in the party, and Accelgor / Escavalier need to be traded with each other.
Yeah, I meant more actual catches triggering evolutions, not having the required Pokémon already in your party. Those two methods are cool though, and I think it'd be neat to see more of that style!

faint in battle
This is a really interesting concept for a ghost type and I'm surprised I hadn't thought of it until now.

Evolution methods differing depending on nature would be interesting to consider too. 👍 A Rash Pokémon could be more likely to evolve via fainting things for example, and a Timid one might be more leaning towards something like leveling up via x number of rare candies since it doesn't like to battle much itself.

Sheep

She/Her
Australia
Seen 2 Hours Ago
Posted 21 Hours Ago
39,243 posts
16.6 Years
I wonder if it was because they were trying to keep evolutions simple back in gen I (or even couldn’t add more complex evolutions like that due to tech limitations). Either way I’d love it if they actually involved Shellder in some way. Or a third evolution that actually does haha.

Adam Levine

I have tried all of your remedies

Age 20
he/they
Kara's Flowers
Seen 6 Hours Ago
Posted 1 Week Ago
5,183 posts
11.6 Years
Having Wishiwashi evolve into its School form by catching a bunch of other Wishiwashi

Geewithabee

Mess with the Grookey, you get the bazookey.

Age 38
He/Him
Seen November 26th, 2021
Posted November 18th, 2021
100 posts
8.6 Years
The Mantyke/Remoraid situation is what I've always liked, and I think there should be more scenarios like that. With so many Pokes to utilize now, I think that many connections could be made between any two from any generation to work out an evolution condition.

Geewithabee

Mess with the Grookey, you get the bazookey.

Age 38
He/Him
Seen November 26th, 2021
Posted November 18th, 2021
100 posts
8.6 Years
True. Those three methods are the original Gen 1 methods. Obviously the trading was to encourage people to get out there and interact with each other. GF hasn't really leaned into that over the years as much as I thought they would, instead branching out into a bunch of new, crazy ways to evolve in your solo game.

EmTheGhost

I say a lot of words

Age 23
Any
Ohio
Seen March 24th, 2023
Posted December 15th, 2022
1,198 posts
5.4 Years
I've always had the idea of a Pokemon evolving after being hit with a certain kind of move - e.g. a Pokemon with a cocoon evolving after being hit with Cut, Slash, Fury Cutter, etc., because it cut open the cocoon.

WAIT WAIT WAIT - I have an even better idea: a bug Pokemon that has the "normal" stages of larva, cocoon, bug all achieved through level-up, but then if the cocoon stage gets hit by a cutting move, you get a creepy, half-melted (in a cartoony, Grimer/Ditto way because this is still Pokemon) bug Pokemon, because it got cut out before it was ready!
Male
Italy
Seen 1 Week Ago
Posted August 29th, 2021
54 posts
3.4 Years
This is literally an idea factory for my fangame. Thank you all, I will credit you if I steal one idea of yours
I see now that the circumstances of one’s birth are irrelevant. It is what you do with the gift of life that determines who you are.
Currently developing Pokémon Entangled