2nd Gen G/S/C Rival=Giovanni's Kid?

Started by GodofPH August 3rd, 2005 5:51 PM
  • 1401 views
  • 25 replies

GodofPH

Submarket Zydrate Dealer

Age 32
Male
Graveyard
Seen August 10th, 2012
Posted May 13th, 2010
762 posts
17.9 Years
In FR/LG, on the rocket warehouse on 5 Island, a scientist mentions that Giovanni's kid has red hair. I know that any person in the pokeverse who has red hair can be Gio's kid, but the GSC Rival has red-hair and he has rocket-like tendencys. The GSC Rival often wanted to defeat Team Rocket, was that because he had a bad childhood? Or perhaps by defeating them, he could find out the whereabouts of his father, who was in secret training during G/S/C. What do you think of my theory?
If you never go over the top, you'll never see the other side.






I do signature banner requests. PM me if you are interested. (1/2)
Age 30
a cardboard box
Seen May 15th, 2008
Posted March 18th, 2006
155 posts
17.9 Years
i've seen this type of thread on another forum site (pokemon UK to be exact) and i have another theory for giovanni's son: Lance. It sounds farfetch'd (LOL) but in G/S/C, Lance was fighting TR with you at Mahogany town. He might have saw his father's evil ways and decided to go onto the side of good. I know other famous people have fought TR as well like Lorelei, but this is my crazy idea.
i'm back after a two year disappearance. i hope this place is just like the way it was when i left.

Zangooser

Lover of all Zagooses

Age 30
Jersey
Seen April 18th, 2007
Posted June 25th, 2006
297 posts
19.2 Years
Theory #1
Lance could have been abandon as a child because of Giovanni.......

Theory #2
Giovanni could have left Lance and his mother for Team Rocket

Theory #3
Lance is Giovanni's long lost son!

This sound's like another Star Wars movie..........
Pokemon are based on normal real life things
Zangoose- Mongoose
Hitmonlee- Bruce Lee
Mew- Cat or cry of a cat


Zangoose
*Zin Zin*
Level: 100 | Gender: Female | Nature: Hasty | Ability: Immunity
Attacks: Slash | Flamethrower| Crush Claw |Double Kick

Dizzy

My Father is a Baron!

Age 33
Formentera, Espana
Seen August 26th, 2005
Posted August 26th, 2005
6,377 posts
19.7 Years
Would you believe I've never heard any of that, but I'm definately in love with all the theories. I couldn't have come up with that if I wanted to, but yes, these are great theories.

Edit: About Rival being Giovanni's kid I meant.
The Baron Giacinto Vittorino da Silva VI
Thanks to Pincushion for the blinkie :)


Please join my fan-club. I have no fans

Chiru

I dun use this account any mo'

Age 31
Seen May 30th, 2013
Posted June 27th, 2007
1,228 posts
17.9 Years
I think you may be on to something. If it were just any old person with red hair, the game designers probably wouldn't have made that person be so specific; they probably would have just said 'Giovanni has a kid' or something like that. Maybe not even said it at all. And if Silver/Kamon is Giovanni's son in the manga, chances are they're touching upon it in the game as well.

If they ever do a remake of GSC (which I think is unlikely at this point but I'm still hoping for it) I hope they touch upon this even more. I guess that probably has something to do with the fact that he's my favorite rival character, though XD.
If you need me, I'm now using the account "BlueberryPoffin". Look for me. :D

Zangooser

Lover of all Zagooses

Age 30
Jersey
Seen April 18th, 2007
Posted June 25th, 2006
297 posts
19.2 Years
Lance would really hate Giovanni for Theory #2
He might take over Team Rocket and use it for good....
For him to take over Team Rocket he must battle Giovanni....
Man, Giovanni in for big trouble!
Pokemon are based on normal real life things
Zangoose- Mongoose
Hitmonlee- Bruce Lee
Mew- Cat or cry of a cat


Zangoose
*Zin Zin*
Level: 100 | Gender: Female | Nature: Hasty | Ability: Immunity
Attacks: Slash | Flamethrower| Crush Claw |Double Kick

shadow909

I'm the dragon master

Age 28
hawiie
Seen May 19th, 2006
Posted May 15th, 2006
447 posts
17.9 Years
Lance would really hate Giovanni for Theory #2
He might take over Team Rocket and use it for good....
For him to take over Team Rocket he must battle Giovanni....
Man, Giovanni in for big trouble!
actully i kanda agree with those theory cause i saw an episode when lance was in a team rocket to spy on team rockets. so probably he knows giovani is his fATHER cause why else would he know the rockets.

<...*EDIT*...> well you know what i mean.

e-MeR

<html>LONG STORY</html>

Digital Junkyard
Seen September 26th, 2010
Posted September 26th, 2008
84 posts
18.8 Years
Well both theories seem like possible though the rival idea comes more closer to me...
Anyways whatever...
June 18th, 2006 - I last visited PC.
September 17th, 2005 - Yes the day I got retired from my modifications site for some odd reason.
Anybody wondered me?
Years passed... D:


I WILL BE BACK WITH A DAMN BIG PROJECT SOMEDAY!BELIEVE IN ME!
Age 30
In a crummy world full of plot holes and spelling errors.
Seen March 20th, 2006
Posted March 20th, 2006
607 posts
18.9 Years
I'm not too sure about this but this was a mighty discussion on SPPF.

A plot hole in the Rival Theory:
He hates TR.

Although this could stem off the fact his father failed because of their stupidity and what not. I'm not sure.

Thanks for the banner Karli

Visit Batesy's Pokemon Site today!

Visit One Way Jesus today!

All Your Base Are Belong To Us

Chorus of Undertermined Time:
Great South Land - Hillsong

This is the great southland of the Holy Spirit,
A land of red dust plains, and summer rains.
And to this sunburnt land
We will see a flood,
And to this great southland
His Spirit Comes!"

Signomi

Age 32
Female
Britland (United Kingdom)
Seen 2 Weeks Ago
Posted October 10th, 2022
7,480 posts
17.8 Years
Once again, I shall tell you that In the Pokemon Special manga, The GSC Rival, or Silver/Kamon, is his indeed his son.

And plus Lance comes from a family devoted to the Dragon Clan, with Clair being his cousin. Would you think Giovanni has any relation? Otherwise he would use Dragon pokemon wouldn't he?

Dance, Carmen! ☆★

Paired with Aizuke » @instagram

Age 30
In a crummy world full of plot holes and spelling errors.
Seen March 20th, 2006
Posted March 20th, 2006
607 posts
18.9 Years
Once again, I shall tell you that In the Pokemon Special manga, The GSC Rival, or Silver/Kamon, is his indeed his son.
Uhhh... Are the games and Manga even related and the same (I'm talking about how the games and anime are completely different. Are the two the same in that context unlike the show)

Thanks for the banner Karli

Visit Batesy's Pokemon Site today!

Visit One Way Jesus today!

All Your Base Are Belong To Us

Chorus of Undertermined Time:
Great South Land - Hillsong

This is the great southland of the Holy Spirit,
A land of red dust plains, and summer rains.
And to this sunburnt land
We will see a flood,
And to this great southland
His Spirit Comes!"

Signomi

Age 32
Female
Britland (United Kingdom)
Seen 2 Weeks Ago
Posted October 10th, 2022
7,480 posts
17.8 Years
Yes, from what I know, the Manga is based on the games. To prove this:


* Pokmon (The Electric Tale of Pikachu a.k.a Dengeki Pikachu), a shōnen manga created by Toshihiro Ono. It was divided into four tankōbon, each with four separate titles in North American and the English Singapore versions: The Electric Tale of Pikachu, Pikachu Shocks Back, Electric Pikachu Boogaloo, and Surf's Up, Pikachu. The series is based mostly on the anime.
* Pokmon Adventures, a shōnen manga based on the video games.
* Magical Pokmon Journey (a.k.a. Pokmon: PiPiPi Adventures), a shōjo manga
* Pikachu Meets the Press (newspaper style comics, not released by Chuang Yi)
* Ash & Pikachu (a.k.a. Satoshi to Pikachu, not released by Viz)
* Pokmon Gold & Silver (not released by Viz)
* Pokmon Ruby-Sapphire and Pokmon Pocket (not released by Viz)
* Pokmon: Jirachi Wishmaker (not released by Viz)

Dance, Carmen! ☆★

Paired with Aizuke » @instagram