which starter did Red choose?

Started by Ggpokerbiel March 8th, 2022 3:58 PM
  • 1512 views
  • 5 replies
Male
Brazil
Seen 7 Hours Ago
Posted 1 Week Ago
13 posts
2.4 Years
So... a while ago, when the last episode of pokemon evolutions was released, I remember getting into a discussion that had to do with the fact that Red's starter was changed, well then I said that the protagonists' pokemon always would be changed to represent the player (something I always believed) so much so that red had already had his starter changed several times

Then I got an answer that left me wondering: "but he was never shown having a squirtle as his starter", and I really couldn't remember anywhere he had a Squirtle or a Blastoise (except when he was with the three initials, of course), so it led me to many questions, such as: "what was the pokemon that each protagonist got?", "why do some things appear in some games and then are treated as if they never existed?", "What is the real story of pokemon games anyway?"

well, so I had these questions in my head, if anyone wants to help me with this I'll be grateful

and i'm using google translate so sorry for any grammatical errors

ZeoStar

Seen 2 Hours Ago
Posted 1 Week Ago
11,391 posts
5.6 Years
I assumed Yellow is the canonical version because he leads with a Pikachu in most (if not all) battles. Pikachu is the only starter in Yellow.

Sheep

She/Her
Australia
Seen 2 Hours Ago
Posted 21 Hours Ago
39,243 posts
16.6 Years
Yeah, I always did assume starters changed around in different episodes to better represent the player. In my head Red owns Charmander, Blue owns Squirtle, and Green owns Bulbasaur, but canonically in the manga Red has Bulbasaur, Blue has Charmander, and Green has Squirtle so that's what I've always tried to follow in my head. Makes more sense when you know that in Japan Blue and Green's names are swapped, so Blue (Green in localized content) has Bulbasaur so it fits pretty well aha. :D;
Seen 1 Day Ago
Posted 1 Day Ago
990 posts
2.6 Years
I've never read the manga, so Red = Charmander allways seemed the most obvious choice, or at least I suppose that was the original idea since the moment we have a character called Red and the Pokémon Red cartridge shows Charizard. It seems, however, that at some point Game Freak wanted to make a weird Red-Ash (or Red-Yellow, if Yellow is actually a canon character) fusion to cater the anime fan-base and they gave it a Pikachu and the other starters in gen 2. So in my head canon, I assumed modern "Red" is actually a "Red+Yellow" hibrid who had two starters, then Bulbasaur and Squirtle which he caught later.
Age 34
They/Them
Pennsylvania, USA
Seen June 22nd, 2022
Posted June 22nd, 2022
97 posts
1.2 Years
I actually found a video I enjoyed that did a basic level analysis looking at games, manga, advertisements, promotional and splash art, cards, and anime to try and work out what each main character's canon starters would be.
https://youtu.be/IaMH0Mp9o1A

Palamon

Silence is Purple.

Age 26
he/him
Snezhnaya, Teyvat.
Seen 1 Hour Ago
Posted 2 Days Ago
7,783 posts
14.3 Years
It depends on the interpretation. I honestly like the idea that Yellow Red is the canon Red, and he got Pikachu as his starter, but was able to get the Kanto starters in a similar fashion to how you would get them if you played Yellow. But, I can also see Bulbasaur being his starter since in Pokemon Adventures, he received a Bulbasaur from Professor Oak when he had to go recapture all of Oak's Pokemon that broke from the lab.

But, to be honest, I don't think there's any definite answer since he has all three Kanto Starters and Pikachu when you face him in both G/S/C and HG/SS, but only Venusaur and Pikachu in LG/PE, which is a callback to Pokemon Adventures.

So, I'm more inclined to say Bulbasaur.

I've never really seen Charmander as his starter because I've always seen that as Blue's due to the manga, but really, it just depends on your interpenetration. If you think his starter is Charmander because Red = Fire, then that's on you. Different canons take completely different approaches to which starter he gets.

For me, though, I'm going to go with "it depends". But, like the idea of either Pikachu or Bulbasaur being his starter depending on which canon we're following.