Pokémon Anime Are you a regular watcher of the Pokémon Anime and its Movies or just an old fan? Come here, and take part in all the various ongoing discussions about the Pokémon Anime.

Ad Content
View Poll Results: Who should stay?
Bring Misty back! 16 38.10%
No, May should stay. 6 14.29%
Neither of them! 2 4.76%
Both of them! 18 42.86%
Voters: 42. You may not vote on this poll

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools
  #1   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
Old February 21st, 2004 (2:13 PM).
Kayleigh Kayleigh is offline
     
    Join Date: Sep 2003
    Posts: 5,903
    Well, I've heard a lot of different opinions on this one, so I figured I'd make a poll. ^_^; Do you think Misty should come back for good, or should May stay?

    (Sorry, I can't remember if a thread like this has been made recently. All of the old ones don't seem to be active. o.o)
      #2   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
    Old February 21st, 2004 (6:32 PM).
    Sayuri no Hoshi's Avatar
    Sayuri no Hoshi Sayuri no Hoshi is offline
    ♥ i'm loving angels instead ♥
       
      Join Date: Oct 2003
      Location: ♥ with my arch angel...in spirit XD ♥
      Age: 32
      Gender:
      Nature: Impish
      Posts: 1,140
      I think May should stay and Misty to also stay when she comes back. I'd just like to see what would happen, lol. ^_~ It'd be good for May, because she'd actually have a girl with her on their journey and not feel like such an outcast with the three boys. I know I would...>_< Hopefully with May's fashion sense and non-stop shopping, she can find Misty some decent clothing to wear, lol. Sorry, I mean Misty would always shop, but you'd never see the clothes she bought or her wearing of them...something that bothered me...O_o
      __________________


      || be careful what you wish for 'cause you just might get it ||

      | c h r y s t i e | partners in crime | k a y l e i g h |
        #3   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
      Old February 21st, 2004 (6:38 PM).
      100marios's Avatar
      100marios 100marios is offline
      Reigning Dork Champion of PC
         
        Join Date: Sep 2003
        Location: *booming voice* What authority dost though have to ask this of me?
        Age: 29
        Gender:
        Nature: Quirky
        Posts: 5,341
        Quote:
        Originally Posted by Sayuri no Hoshi
        I think May should stay and Misty to also stay when she comes back. I'd just like to see what would happen, lol. ^_~ It'd be good for May, because she'd actually have a girl with her on their journey and not feel like such an outcast with the three boys. I know I would...>_< Hopefully with May's fashion sense and non-stop shopping, she can find Misty some decent clothing to wear, lol. Sorry, I mean Misty would always shop, but you'd never see the clothes she bought or her wearing of them...something that bothered me...O_o
        I agree! I can't imagine myself traveling around with 3 girls and no boys. That would feel a tad bit awkward hehe.....
        2 are better then 1 anyway! I'd like to see them both back in the group!
        __________________
        Dec. 2003:
        Quote:
        Don't be afraid to make fun of me...*gives glare* I can take it!
        ...And I still can!

        Signature under construction. Or I might just be saying this because I have no idea how to make one. Let your imagination guide you!... Please? *smiles* ;p
          #4   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
        Old February 21st, 2004 (6:41 PM).
        Mattokun's Avatar
        Mattokun Mattokun is offline
        Haruka ga daisuki desu
           
          Join Date: Feb 2004
          Location: Georgia, USA
          Age: 31
          Gender:
          Nature: Calm
          Posts: 228
          Misty was awesome yes but i love May as well. Misty should come back and the five of them should travel together. It's hard to pick between the two girls cause they're both cool and both are cute too^^
            #5   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
          Old February 21st, 2004 (6:46 PM).
          Timbjerr's Avatar
          Timbjerr Timbjerr is offline
          T-o-X-i-C
           
          Join Date: Sep 2003
          Location: Texas
          Age: 31
          Gender: Female
          Nature: Timid
          Posts: 7,426
          I hate Misty!

          *dodges arrows shot by pokshippers*

          I've never liked her mean, b*tchy attitude towards Ash...at least May treats Ash much better than Misty did...
          __________________
            #6   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
          Old February 21st, 2004 (6:57 PM).
          Mattokun's Avatar
          Mattokun Mattokun is offline
          Haruka ga daisuki desu
             
            Join Date: Feb 2004
            Location: Georgia, USA
            Age: 31
            Gender:
            Nature: Calm
            Posts: 228
            Quote:
            Originally Posted by tmbjr
            I hate Misty!

            *dodges arrows shot by pokshippers*

            I've never liked her mean, b*tchy attitude towards Ash...at least May treats Ash much better than Misty did...

            True Misty was mean to Ash sometimes but (at least in my opinion) it's cause she liked him. May may treat Ash nicer but still, Misty had her high points as well.
              #7   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
            Old February 21st, 2004 (7:33 PM).
            100marios's Avatar
            100marios 100marios is offline
            Reigning Dork Champion of PC
               
              Join Date: Sep 2003
              Location: *booming voice* What authority dost though have to ask this of me?
              Age: 29
              Gender:
              Nature: Quirky
              Posts: 5,341
              Quote:
              Originally Posted by tmbjr
              I hate Misty!

              *dodges arrows shot by pokshippers*

              I've never liked her mean, b*tchy attitude towards Ash...at least May treats Ash much better than Misty did...
              *gasps*
              .....TMBJR!! I expected better from you!! Especially since your a mod now!
              For shame!!
              Hehe....
              __________________
              Dec. 2003:
              Quote:
              Don't be afraid to make fun of me...*gives glare* I can take it!
              ...And I still can!

              Signature under construction. Or I might just be saying this because I have no idea how to make one. Let your imagination guide you!... Please? *smiles* ;p
                #8   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
              Old February 21st, 2004 (9:52 PM).
              Pokemaster10000's Avatar
              Pokemaster10000 Pokemaster10000 is offline
              ...
                 
                Join Date: Dec 2003
                Age: 27
                Gender:
                Posts: 4,731
                Quote:
                Originally Posted by tmbjr
                I hate Misty!

                *dodges arrows shot by pokshippers*

                I've never liked her mean, b*tchy attitude towards Ash...at least May treats Ash much better than Misty did...
                *Shakes his head*
                What Mattokun said. The only reason Misty treats Ash mean is because she likes him. Have you heard of the saying "PAIN IS LOVE". Well, thats what think it means.
                  #9   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                Old February 21st, 2004 (10:32 PM).
                Latios Master's Avatar
                Latios Master Latios Master is offline
                11 Year PC Member
                   
                  Join Date: Sep 2003
                  Location: Minnesota
                  Age: 31
                  Gender: Male
                  Nature: Adamant
                  Posts: 2,203
                  I want both Misty and May to stay. It would be cool to see how they treat each other. I could see them hating eaching other, but being good friends too. Who knows...
                  __________________
                  Pokémon White Friend Code: 4813 6266 9528
                  Pokémon Black 2 Friend Code: 1979 7985 3252
                    #10   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                  Old February 22nd, 2004 (11:35 AM).
                  Kayleigh Kayleigh is offline
                     
                    Join Date: Sep 2003
                    Posts: 5,903
                    Quote:
                    Originally Posted by tmbjr
                    I hate Misty!

                    *dodges arrows shot by pokshippers*

                    I've never liked her mean, b*tchy attitude towards Ash...at least May treats Ash much better than Misty did...
                    Fully censor out curse words, if you're going to say them. You should know that, being a moderator. o.o *poke*

                    Anyways, I want them both to stay. They're so different, it would make it interesting. With Misty's short temper and May's ditzyness, there would probably be a lot of funny parts during their travels. Plus having an extra girl wouldn't hurt. ^_^;
                      #11   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                    Old February 22nd, 2004 (12:32 PM).
                    ScArLetSkye's Avatar
                    ScArLetSkye ScArLetSkye is offline
                    Miss Understood. o.X
                       
                      Join Date: Jan 2004
                      Location: Flitting in and out of here and there.
                      Age: 25
                      Gender:
                      Posts: 3,408
                      Yes, I agree with Kayleigh.

                      Both girls should stay.Uh huh, there definitly would be funny parts with the two of them.:P

                      And having another girl around would be nice for May.:)

                      And well, the reason why Misty was a little...touchy with Ash was probally, most likely 'cause she likes him.;)
                      __________________
                      Paired up with: No one at the moment. Not anymore. =(

                      -Signature seriously under contruction.-

                        #12   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                      Old February 22nd, 2004 (12:36 PM).
                      Mattokun's Avatar
                      Mattokun Mattokun is offline
                      Haruka ga daisuki desu
                         
                        Join Date: Feb 2004
                        Location: Georgia, USA
                        Age: 31
                        Gender:
                        Nature: Calm
                        Posts: 228
                        Quote:
                        Originally Posted by ScArLetSkye
                        Yes, I agree with Kayleigh.

                        Both girls should stay.Uh huh, there definitly would be funny parts with the two of them.:P

                        And having another girl around would be nice for May.:)

                        And well, the reason why Misty was a little...touchy with Ash was probally, most likely 'cause she likes him.;)

                        Yep, my thoughts exactly
                          #13   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                        Old February 22nd, 2004 (12:40 PM).
                        Unown_'s Avatar
                        Unown_ Unown_ is offline
                        Sep.2003 - Mar.2010. Resigned
                           
                          Join Date: Sep 2003
                          Location: The Unown Dimension
                          Posts: 1,476
                          Bringing back Misty is ok imo. Under one condition: if she stops the earpulling-thing.
                          The group would have 5 travelers, which some ppl find a little too large. I believe this was one of the reason why the writers made Misty leave. But I think that 5 ppl in a group is just fine.
                          __________________
                          Resigned.
                          September 2003 - March 2010
                            #14   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                          Old February 22nd, 2004 (1:54 PM).
                          Kayleigh Kayleigh is offline
                             
                            Join Date: Sep 2003
                            Posts: 5,903
                            I guess it just doesn't seem like Pokemon without Misty... She was my first favorite character on there, she was always on the merchandise with Ash and Brock, and they were just the three main characters. =\ I've gotten so used to her being on the show that it's strange not seeing her on. May is also a great character, but I do wish that they would bring Misty back for good.
                              #15   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                            Old February 22nd, 2004 (3:04 PM).
                            ~*Silent Tattsu*~'s Avatar
                            ~*Silent Tattsu*~ ~*Silent Tattsu*~ is offline
                            Has gone~
                               
                              Join Date: Feb 2004
                              Location: Not at PC
                              Age: 28
                              Gender:
                              Posts: 581
                              Quote:
                              I guess it just doesn't seem like Pokemon without Misty... She was my first favorite character on there, she was always on the merchandise with Ash and Brock, and they were just the three main characters. =\ I've gotten so used to her being on the show that it's strange not seeing her on. May is also a great character, but I do wish that they would bring Misty back for good.
                              *Nods* Exactly the same here Kayleigh.... ;_; When i see a pic of Ash , Brock , Max & May it just looks so...well wrong and not Pokemon... Ash , Misty & Brocko are the people that spring to mind when i hear the words "Pokemon Anime" I am a huge Misty fan & to me without her its just not Pokemon :/ *...Cries...* *Ahem* Misty has been there every day with Ash & Brock for so long its imbedded in my memory for Pokemon. It is all of that , that makes me loath the writers of Pokemon & May & Max.

                              Well i think Misty should come back for good and Max & May
                              should stay in Hoen. I am a huge Misty fan & a huge Pokeshipper and when i heard Misty was officially leaving i almost cried , honest ^^;;;

                              I don't partically like Max & May , Max is cute , but too young for the group i think. I have hated May ever since i first saw her and i won't say why because then it will be Character bashing
                              ^^;;; I don't know really... i guess when i saw May i flared up because i could'nt help think she's like a replacement for Misty. I mean just like that ?!
                              Misty never to be seen again and the writers thought the viewers would'nt care ? I just can't belive that really....

                              I got some wise words from someone who was a Misty fan and new alot about the Anime who noted that May , who is the female character
                              in Ruby & Sapphire turned up in the anime to boost marketing ect. They brang her into the anime because the place was Hoen , R/S had just been released , and May was the female main character in it. That i belive is what makes me think that once Ash is finished in Hoen , May & Max will leave.

                              So yes i hope that May & Max leave at the end of AG , Misty comes back for good & Pokeshipping will become a reality ! ^o^
                              __________________

                              --- Why i left PC ---

                              Quote:
                              Originally Posted by Chairman Kaga's sig
                              << left PC and PROUD OF IT >>

                              I've come to my senses--PC makes me absolutely sick, I hate it. No, this isn't an attention-grab like some morons say it is, it's my stand against the degredation of this once-great place. It's clear to me that PC has been absolutely ruined, and I'll never be back. I'd like to thank the few of you who stand with me, especially people like Silent Tattsu and Frostweaver, as they have given me the strength to rise above this place. I need to get on with my life, especially after some of you have perverted and absolutely obliterated the old PC spirit. I'm not welcome here, and if I may say so, I don't care to be here. Just you wait, and PC will be dead. Not the forums themselves, as, at length, was stated in another topic, but the spirit of PC, more important than any individual member or group of members. It's fading fast, and I won't be around when it disappears, leaving an empty shell of a forum filled with members who delight in this new, ruinous order. So I have chosen to be brave and leave, even if it is unpopular or considered un-PC-ish. Well, as far as I'm concerned, I'm about as anti-PC as anyone can get right about now.
                              Nuff said. I don't need to explain, Kaga says it all. Please don't PM me, since i won't be here to check them. And while your at it stop giving Kaga bad rep points for his sig. One word i-m-m-a-t-u-r-e.
                                #16   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                              Old February 22nd, 2004 (3:24 PM).
                              *~Ashley~*'s Avatar
                              *~Ashley~* *~Ashley~* is offline
                              ♥ Matt
                                 
                                Join Date: Jan 2004
                                Location: Stalking you on the Who's Online page >D
                                Age: 30
                                Nature: Quiet
                                Posts: 5,062
                                i would much rather have misty back than may. i don't like may. she's really annoying and kinda reminds me of the way my sister acts. she's always whining about something. i liked misty. like kayleigh said they were a group of 3 main characters and now it's just weird without her.
                                __________________
                                  #17   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                                Old February 22nd, 2004 (7:58 PM).
                                orange*berry's Avatar
                                orange*berry orange*berry is offline
                                Has catching up to do...
                                   
                                  Join Date: Sep 2003
                                  Location: The Ohkido Residence
                                  Age: 31
                                  Gender:
                                  Posts: 826
                                  Quote:
                                  Originally Posted by tmbjr
                                  I hate Misty!

                                  *dodges arrows shot by pokshippers*

                                  I've never liked her mean, b*tchy attitude towards Ash...at least May treats Ash much better than Misty did...
                                  Blunt!

                                  I say... bring back good ol' Kasumi. Haruka's a Pokeshipping distraction. =P TeeHee. But! She is cute. She has a winey, yet cheerful dispostion. n.n()
                                  __________________
                                  Paired with Sableye! =3
                                  Official glomper of Scyther5 X3

                                  -Berrylicous Signature-
                                  My sitey is movin' to this place! ;.;

                                  Let's boogie!
                                    #18   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                                  Old February 23rd, 2004 (3:24 AM).
                                  Evil Togepi's Avatar
                                  Evil Togepi Evil Togepi is offline
                                  Yu-Gi-Oh GX owns my SOUL!
                                     
                                    Join Date: Feb 2004
                                    Location: Mirage land of the Evil Togepis
                                    Age: 35
                                    Gender:
                                    Nature: Calm
                                    Posts: 432
                                    I will admit I prefer May to Misty but it would be nice to have both of them :)
                                    __________________
                                      #19   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                                    Old February 24th, 2004 (7:52 PM).
                                    James Hawking James Hawking is offline
                                    Insane Newbie
                                       
                                      Join Date: Feb 2004
                                      Gender:
                                      Posts: 14
                                      Quote:
                                      Originally Posted by orange*berry
                                      Blunt!

                                      I say... bring back good ol' Kasumi. Haruka's a Pokeshipping distraction. =P TeeHee. But! She is cute. She has a winey, yet cheerful dispostion. n.n()
                                      Agreed. Misty should come back, so that AAML should come back, and we can finally see Pokmon the way it should be!
                                      Also, I agree with ~*Silent Tattsu*~, in the fact that Max and May should leave, to make room. Four people's a lot already, and five would be too much.
                                      A nightmare for AAML would be for Max and May to stay on for the next five (or is it four? Never stopped to check :P) seasons...
                                        #20   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                                      Old February 29th, 2004 (1:18 AM).
                                      Chiyo's Avatar
                                      Chiyo Chiyo is offline
                                      heh.
                                         
                                        Join Date: Feb 2004
                                        Posts: 350
                                        Well, it is stupid to take Pokemon only to contests. BUT! It is also crazy to
                                        take a bad mood all the time.....BUT!! Misty is sometimes nice while May's cute. So I take both..
                                          #21   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                                        Old March 5th, 2004 (4:00 AM).
                                        Misty-Chan Misty-Chan is offline
                                           
                                          Join Date: Mar 2004
                                          Gender:
                                          Posts: 8
                                          Welllllllll ... quite a tough little thing isn't this poll? Well I voted brink back Misty cos she's always been my favourite character, she gave the show so much more... OMG i cant think of the word... ummmmm... character!!! lol OMG i said that 7 words before and I couldn't think of it... how sad ^^... Don't get me wrong, May's cool, well she was in the two eps that Misty came back in anyway and in Japanese... but I don't know what she's like in English yet (once again... I live in Australia...).

                                          I think it would be cool to have MIsty and May they might have this rivalry but to me it looked like they could become good friends. It would be really cool to have the group as Ash, Misty, May and Max! :) but then they wouldn't do that would they? ok, well take out Max and Brock, bring back Misty and have a new guy. I don't know what you guys thing but Brock has always really annoyed me.

                                          And we can't take away the ear pulling, thats part of what makes Misty Misty!!!
                                            #22   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                                          Old March 5th, 2004 (7:04 AM). Edited March 5th, 2004 by dqle.
                                          dqle's Avatar
                                          dqle dqle is offline
                                             
                                            Join Date: Feb 2004
                                            Location: Millennium Town (more like a city now)
                                            Age: 32
                                            Gender:
                                            Nature: Brave
                                            Posts: 1,032
                                            Max pulls Brock's ear too!!!

                                            Anyway, I think that the producers of Pokmon are intentionally only letting three characters in Ash's group, including Ash. (More on May and Max below) They're trying to set an environment similar to a typical RPG world. For instance, in the popular Final Fantasy series, you can only battle with a certain amout of characters (usually 3) They're trying to set the show based heavily on the game itself and quite frankly, it's getting annoying.

                                            Because of endless hours in @*$! (school), I believe that the only reason there's four people in Ash's group is because May's and Max's character supplement each other. Without Max, May couldn't know where to begin and she has absolutely no knowledge about Pokmon. Without May, Max couldn't have gone with Ash in the first place and he really can't do anything on his own. (curse english!)

                                            I'd love the producers to change their mind on the 'RPG setting' and get with reality. I'd also like Misty to stay with the group again, but at the same time, I don't! First, I'd like to see how things turn out without Misty. Second, if Misty got back with the group, there'd be a significant chance that she would actually reveal her feelings to Ash! If that were to happen... Pokmon would end as we know it!!!!!! The fact is, if Ash knew, he'd be sidetracked and probably not become a Pokmon Master(Champion), thus ending the series entirely!!!! That musn't happen! Life would stop making sense! (although, it still doen't make any sense to me)

                                            Please don't hate me for this reply!

                                            P.S. Why's Plusle sorta cut in half?!?!
                                            Oh yeah, please send me some pics of Misty in her new outfit, Misty-Chan! I've been looking EVERYWHERE for them!!! I am planning to draw comics when I have the time.
                                            __________________
                                            In the morning when you wake up, Open your eyes to a new day.
                                            Look around at the gifts you've got. You've been so lucky along the way.
                                            Time to finish what you've begun. Have the faith, you're the one.
                                            Throw your hat high - up to the sun.

                                            Now you face your greatest test. Use the lessons that you've learned.
                                            Your goal is to be the best, And claim the prize that you've earned.
                                            Ever since you were a young man, You've kept your eye on the master plan.
                                            To reach for the top - and touch the sky.

                                            It's your destiny,
                                            To spread your wings and fly.


                                            Pokémon: 2.B.A. Master - You Can Do It (If You Really Try)
                                              #23   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                                            Old March 6th, 2004 (6:55 PM).
                                            Cosmo Cosmo is offline
                                            Is gone......
                                               
                                              Join Date: Feb 2004
                                              Location: Dimmsdale with Timmy and Wanda
                                              Age: 30
                                              Gender:
                                              Posts: 166
                                              I perfer both of them. Both Haruka and Kasumi are cool.
                                              __________________
                                              I changed my username XD again.
                                                #24   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                                              Old March 7th, 2004 (7:46 PM).
                                              ash_misty4ever's Avatar
                                              ash_misty4ever ash_misty4ever is offline
                                              We should be lovers....
                                                 
                                                Join Date: Sep 2003
                                                Location: At the Moulin Rouge!
                                                Age: 27
                                                Gender:
                                                Posts: 817
                                                Hehehe you know me! Whenever there's pokeshipping I'll be there! I think Max and May should be out because of the purpose of them staying with Ash. May lied to Ash in the beginning of the series and she just tags along, acting like she knows how to battle, and how to win contests. I would really like to see Ash and Misty alone in a series.

                                                I voted Misty only!!
                                                __________________
                                                I'm really sorry I haven't been on much. All I can say is that my reality life has caught up with me. I'm not the Pokemon Fan I used to be. I really hate to give all of this up after so long, but I can't quite help it. If I'm not online as much as I used to so very long ago, just remember it's my real life holding me back. BUT, when I become famous, I'll totally be sure to mention everyone of you in my acceptance speeches! Just remember the name EMILY MAYNARD!
                                                  #25   Link to this post, but load the entire thread.  
                                                Old March 7th, 2004 (7:52 PM).
                                                Flaming Torchic's Avatar
                                                Flaming Torchic Flaming Torchic is offline
                                                HalOWNED!
                                                   
                                                  Join Date: Nov 2003
                                                  Location: No longer at the top of the Forum Leaders page. ;_;
                                                  Age: 29
                                                  Gender:
                                                  Nature: Relaxed
                                                  Posts: 2,168
                                                  Yeah, I don't really see Mays purpose in the show, the only reason I actually care if May is in it is so I can see Torchic =3 I vote both, because I would miss seeing Torchic and it would be cool to see Misty back. :)
                                                  __________________

                                                  Experience a Gaming Revolution!
                                                  Closed Thread

                                                  Quick Reply

                                                  Join the conversation!

                                                  Create an account to post a reply in this thread, participate in other discussions, and more!

                                                  Create a PokéCommunity Account
                                                  Ad Content
                                                  Thread Tools

                                                  Posting Rules
                                                  You may not post new threads
                                                  You may not post replies
                                                  You may not post attachments
                                                  You may not edit your posts

                                                  BB code is On
                                                  Smilies are On
                                                  [IMG] code is On
                                                  HTML code is Off

                                                  Forum Jump


                                                  All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:12 PM.