Text Bubbles, or Text under panel? Page 2

Started by Ark Kuvis October 29th, 2005 10:32 AM
  • 2004 views
  • 54 replies
  • Poll

Speech Bubbles, or Under Pannel?

Avatar

Age 33
He/him
Denmark
Seen April 3rd, 2023
Posted March 11th, 2022
2,405 posts
19.7 Years
#Order - the reader can read all the text in the correct order without getting confused, no more: "which bubble do I read first??"
Then you obviously don't know much about the making of comics. Speech Bubbles do have order, if you know how to make comics, you'd know this.

*whipes tear off**claps*, nice speech, and I agree everybody doing the same style would be boring.
No offense, but if all you can do is say "I agree" then I don't think you should be debating here.

Karasuma

It's beemo time!

Male
Onett, NJ
Seen June 1st, 2021
Posted May 6th, 2018
6,455 posts
17.7 Years
Okay I got an idea that will settle this once and for all. Lets tell the administartor to make a Fan Fic section, that way we can post our fan fics there and this will be for sprite comics. Isn't that a better idea?
| Who wants to play video games? |
Age 32
Seen October 6th, 2009
Posted November 1st, 2007
1,329 posts
18.6 Years
Then you obviously don't know much about the making of comics. Speech Bubbles do have order, if you know how to make comics, you'd know this.
Ahh, now I was going to say something about this. You see speech bubbles can have order but sometimes they don't. But with text under panels, unless the comic maker is seriosly thick, it's always in order because all you do is read from top to bottom.

It all depends on the comic maker I suppose.

Anyway I don't know why we are having this debate, some people like one style, some people like another, why do we have to have this huge war about it?
Newten5, your friendly neighborhood anti-hacker!

I run Legit checking and cloning services, PM me

Check my thread: Hacked Pokémon to avoid!

Name: DANIEL Code: 3565-8791-4434
Seen August 11th, 2007
Posted August 10th, 2007
147 posts
17.6 Years
cuz it's a debate thread.

No its because noob's just think that other cant be difrent....
that is why theres no need for this thread....


92% of teens have moved on to rap.
If you are part of the 8% who still listen to real music,copy and paste this into your signature (Started by Blaziken Lover)
Seen August 11th, 2007
Posted August 10th, 2007
147 posts
17.6 Years
I dunno. In overworld comics, I do under, rather next to the panel. In comics like my PC series, I use speech bubbles.

meh... thats a allright idea you have there.


92% of teens have moved on to rap.
If you are part of the 8% who still listen to real music,copy and paste this into your signature (Started by Blaziken Lover)

blueguy

No capitalization required. ;D

Age 32
Seen August 20th, 2013
Posted September 19th, 2010
738 posts
18.3 Years
Oooh....! I'll participate.

My opinion: A sprite comic is called a sprite comic for a reason, because it's a comic, using sprites.

Speechbubbles = organization, aesthetic beauty, effort
Text under panel = too much text and/or lazyness

If you find that your characters are doing monologues, perhaps you would be better suited to doing a fanfic.
Age 30
*Insert something witty about stalkers etc.*
Seen February 2nd, 2008
Posted February 2nd, 2008
683 posts
18.3 Years
Text bubbles have to be used correctly. All problems are easily neutralized as long as you put enough effort into it. So yeah, don't wanna put effort into your comic's basic features, don't put it up on imageshack/photobucket.

Roy-Kun

t i t l e g o e s h e r e

Male
In the house, next to the car, that is close to the sea.
Seen January 25th, 2011
Posted April 30th, 2010
1,018 posts
18.1 Years
i got bored of speech Bubbles, now i'm using comics writing the text under pannel

Curremt obsession: (MMO)RPG, and S4 League.


Spoiler:

Credits to WindLord for the FE9 Roy sprite, and RoyLover for Sig and avvy.

Avatar

Age 33
He/him
Denmark
Seen April 3rd, 2023
Posted March 11th, 2022
2,405 posts
19.7 Years
That has more then enough room for speech bubbles, but OW sprite comics are smaller and don't use to much room for the picture like that one does.
Sprite comics like that should use speech bubbles, OW comics should use text under panels.
It makes no difference what kind of sprite comic it is, when all comes to, it's still a sprite comic.

Text under panels isen't being lazy, its a different way of making a comic.
Text under panels require NO skill to make, while speech bubbles are alot harder to get right, and usually has a better outcome if done correctly.
Seen August 11th, 2007
Posted August 10th, 2007
147 posts
17.6 Years
Oh and just to prove that text buubbles can be used have a look at my comic that is on this site its called Mega mix


92% of teens have moved on to rap.
If you are part of the 8% who still listen to real music,copy and paste this into your signature (Started by Blaziken Lover)