miyo

grass pokemon trainer

Age 33
my own grass gym
Seen August 13th, 2010
Posted August 13th, 2010
676 posts
17 Years
I was watching the power of one movie again, and happen to have seen the part where prof oak was conversing with prof ivy.. and brock was running around behind prof ivy..

which makes me wonder about the johto region.. why did brock come back? he appeared to be devastated when ash and co mentioned prof ivy's name.. was the reason why brock left ivy shown in the series? anyone can tell me the reason?
Aipom and Pikachu are so cute!!
I watch World Cup, do you? xD
Age 35
Aussieland.
Seen January 20th, 2008
Posted December 24th, 2007
161 posts
17.6 Years
R18 version-She raped him(He would be traumatised... I think, curtain males would get a kick out of that)
MA15+ Version-She has whips... like Jessebelle(Brock and James are similar in ways)
PG Version-The girls ment more to her(She paid attention to him at all realy?)
G Version-She had a husband

MegaDitto

Windsor ™

Seen June 27th, 2013
Posted July 7th, 2011
8,495 posts
18.4 Years
I also read about this reason ... she used to be a He
Proof? Seriously.

I just think Ivy told Brock that it was best to be a bredder and he was heartbroken.

Ivy:Brock, you have helped us so much

Brock:Oh it's nonthing

Ivy:Brock your place ins't here. You could countiune breeding. You shouldn't wasted your time here.

Brock: Heartbroken.
~Paired with Miyu-Chan~

Sweet Smoochum

Banned

Female
NEW JERSEY, Sayreville. 08872.
Seen April 13th, 2013
Posted March 9th, 2013
1,402 posts
17.4 Years
My complicated theory: Maybe Professor Ivy was dying of a fatal disease called pokerus...(cause: by too much interaction with pokemon)
Bill (p.c. dude) probably used her in an experiment to turn her into a Magikarp and she was put in the lake in front of his house. She got pokerus from being in the water with all magikarp...lol (I know that pokerus isn't that, I just made it up...)
Ivy told Brock that she was dying, Brock was heartbroken and he was told to go back to his friends...The End... :(

miyo

grass pokemon trainer

Age 33
my own grass gym
Seen August 13th, 2010
Posted August 13th, 2010
676 posts
17 Years
Hmmm.. I liked the simple theory of the "she had a husband". Perhaps her husband came back few months later.. and to add on to the effect, Brock wanted to propose? to her exactly at the time when he realised that she had a husband?

Let's not forget Pokemon's an anime also meant for the young kids, so anything like prof. Ivy being a 'he', or anything else deemed unfitting for young kids, shouldn't be in. I think 'she had a husband' would be more suitable.

Well, that's my opinion after reading the others' posts ^^
Aipom and Pikachu are so cute!!
I watch World Cup, do you? xD
Kingdom of Clow
Seen January 2nd, 2007
Posted December 10th, 2006
44 posts
17.5 Years
Takeshi came back because the writers wanted to. Seriously, fans weren't too happy about him leaving in the Orange Islands, so it was just a ploy.
I really forgot brock said about what happened between him and Prof. Ivy.Its been like 1 or2 years since I saw that episode.
He didn't even say what happened at all....
R18 version-She raped him(He would be traumatised... I think, curtain males would get a kick out of that)
^ I go with this theory. :P

Har D Har

Master Mapper Supreme!

Age 30
Village Hidden in the Leaves
Seen May 27th, 2012
Posted April 5th, 2010
361 posts
17.2 Years
Naw, Brock would enjoy it:laugh:
Quote
Ben: Oh, you guys. Stop calling them. You can call me all you want.

Laura: Okay...

Eric: Oh, oh, okay.

Ben: Just don't make it between the times of midnight and 6:00 AM because I am sleeping.

[Andrew laughs]

Ben: And if my speakers go off...

Andrew: [Laughs] No you're not.

Ben: Yeah, well, sometimes I am. Occasionally.

Eric: And people of the world, don't call him on Skype, Sundays between like 3:00 and 8:00 PM because that's when he edits the show.

Andrew: When he does, yeah.

Ben: If you call me...okay...you think a dementor is bad? You think Lord Voldemort is bad? [In deep voice] You haven't felt the wrath of Ben Schoen.

miyo

grass pokemon trainer

Age 33
my own grass gym
Seen August 13th, 2010
Posted August 13th, 2010
676 posts
17 Years
eeek. you guys are weird.. no offense, but it's really ridiculous to put stuff like that...... ><;;

I would have to agree that fans wanted him back, and the writers had no choice but to bring him back. I am one very good example.. I was devastated because Brock went away.. not only me, several others that I know of feel the same way too..

Hey, we might be able to get our Misty back too.. If fans' speculations could bring Brock back, I see no reason why Misty can't be back by popular demand.. :P
Aipom and Pikachu are so cute!!
I watch World Cup, do you? xD

miyo

grass pokemon trainer

Age 33
my own grass gym
Seen August 13th, 2010
Posted August 13th, 2010
676 posts
17 Years
I think that Ivy had something for Brock, but saw him flirting with other girls, and scolded him.
Hmmm. I think Ivy should know how uncontrollably flirtatious Brock is after working with him for quite some time (Brock was with Ivy the whole Orange Islands season...). I'm still sticking with other theories like the 'Ivy's husband came back' theory..

But it is still possible that your theory is correct.. who is to say it is wrong? lols
Aipom and Pikachu are so cute!!
I watch World Cup, do you? xD

Forci Stikane

..

Seen August 11th, 2009
Posted August 11th, 2009
4,227 posts
18.2 Years
R18 version-She raped him(He would be traumatised... I think, curtain males would get a kick out of that)
Maybe if he was drugged at the time or something......lol.

But I seriously think that maybe it was something else: When all the Pokemon went crazy during the second movie Onix accidentally knocked part of Ivy's roof down. Brock was so ashamed and Ivy was so annoyed that he had to leave. Now, where did the hat and robe come from......?
----------------------------------------
Evolution Chain:
Ichapokemr -----2000 Posts-----> Ichaste Pekoni (5/8/2007) -----3500 Posts (12/29/08) -----> Forci Stikane

miyo

grass pokemon trainer

Age 33
my own grass gym
Seen August 13th, 2010
Posted August 13th, 2010
676 posts
17 Years
Maybe if he was drugged at the time or something......lol.

But I seriously think that maybe it was something else: When all the Pokemon went crazy during the second movie Onix accidentally knocked part of Ivy's roof down. Brock was so ashamed and Ivy was so annoyed that he had to leave. Now, where did the hat and robe come from......?
Yup.. yet another possiblity.. it's interesting.. very typical anime-like ^^
Aipom and Pikachu are so cute!!
I watch World Cup, do you? xD