Map Rating/Review Thread Page 143

Started by Christos April 1st, 2007 9:39 AM
  • 838240 views
  • 5964 replies
Age 27
Seen May 19th, 2009
Posted May 18th, 2009
104 posts
14.1 Years
Hope this get better compliment...
Map name:?????
From:Fire Red
Comment:It takes me an hour to do this...
Rate It...
Spoiler:
well, i like the overal idea of it, but the dirt kinda throws me off- and the rocks to- and the top edges of the mountain can't be done with the rocky edge if the rest is grass- example
i give it a 7
New Bark Town, Johto
Seen September 26th, 2012
Posted August 14th, 2009
12 posts
14.1 Years
Name: ???
Made on: Congbu
Great map, however, iSpy a tile error to the south of the map, with the trees.. >.<
9.5/10
Let the bodies hit the floor ;
Let the bodies hit the floor ;
Let the bodies hit the floor ;
Let the bodies hit the ...
FLOOOOOORRR
Living tomorrow .., Today ~

TB Pro

Old-timer

Age 28
Male
Midwestern USA
Seen March 6th, 2016
Posted October 4th, 2012
2,707 posts
18.5 Years
Name: ???
Made on: Congbu
Spoiler:
Comments: Well, the first thing I notice is the extreme amount of flowers in this map. Now you see, flowers add a good feel to a map, and they're almost NEEDED, but not in this extreme amount. Anyways, on to other stuff. I like the tree placement, as well as the path placement, so not really any complaints there, except for the tile error in the southern area(in a screen at the bottom of the post). The shape of them is pretty nice. K, now for the mountains. The shape of them is pretty good, but in spots there are too many turns in them(if you understand). Everything else is pretty good except for the water. There are quite a few errors with it(also posted in screenshot).

Rating: 8/10

Suggestions: Remove some flowers, fix the errors, and take out some of the turns in the mountains.

Screenshot:
Spoiler:
--I'm a creepin'..
Age 30
Male
Tokyo, Japan
Seen April 9th, 2023
Posted September 16th, 2013
860 posts
16.4 Years
Great map, however, iSpy a tile error to the south of the map, with the trees.. >.<
9.5/10
Thank you and that is now fixed in the Revision.

i really like this map- i see 1 tile error (with the trees) but it is still a great map! 9.5/10
also, how did you make the tiles look like that?
Thank you :) is fixed and with palettes ;)

Comments: Well, the first thing I notice is the extreme amount of flowers in this map. Now you see, flowers add a good feel to a map, and they're almost NEEDED, but not in this extreme amount. Anyways, on to other stuff. I like the tree placement, as well as the path placement, so not really any complaints there, except for the tile error in the southern area(in a screen at the bottom of the post). The shape of them is pretty nice. K, now for the mountains. The shape of them is pretty good, but in spots there are too many turns in them(if you understand). Everything else is pretty good except for the water. There are quite a few errors with it(also posted in screenshot).

Rating: 8/10

Suggestions: Remove some flowers, fix the errors, and take out some of the turns in the mountains.

Screenshot:
Spoiler:
Thank you bro ;) I fixed the things you mentioned. Except the mountain thing I might change that later or not (A)

Revision
Age 27
Male
Best City OCE
Seen October 18th, 2021
Posted April 1st, 2013
5,978 posts
15.1 Years
http://img257.imageshack.us/img257/305/newbark.png

This is a New Bark town remake. I tried to make it as exact to the GS one as possible, which is why there's that city pathway. I might edit it later to make it like HG/SS, with grass instead of path.

No, I'm not making a GS remake, there's absolutely no point (before there was a little bit) now that there's HeartGold and SoulSilver. This is just part of a new ROM hack.
Everything ends,
and that's always sad.
But everything begins again, too,
and that's always happy.
Age 28
Male
Rust
Seen July 30th, 2011
Posted December 29th, 2010
1,196 posts
14.8 Years
http://img257.imageshack.us/img257/305/newbark.png

This is a New Bark town remake. I tried to make it as exact to the GS one as possible, which is why there's that city pathway. I might edit it later to make it like HG/SS, with grass instead of path.

No, I'm not making a GS remake, there's absolutely no point (before there was a little bit) now that there's HeartGold and SoulSilver. This is just part of a new ROM hack.

Rating: 10\10
Why: It's a perfect remake. Nothing bad about it.
Ideas: Nothing
I'm looking for some good (When I say good,
I mean you can hold your own by yourself)
N**i Zombies players, to form a team or even a
clan, to play with casually.
Send me a PM with your Highest Level and your PSN,
and I'll get back to you.
Age 31
Female
Chi Town
Seen July 12th, 2010
Posted March 2nd, 2010
1,040 posts
14.8 Years
Originally Posted by Ninja Caterpie
http://img257.imageshack.us/img257/305/newbark.png

This is a New Bark town remake. I tried to make it as exact to the GS one as possible, which is why there's that city pathway. I might edit it later to make it like HG/SS, with grass instead of path.

No, I'm not making a GS remake, there's absolutely no point (before there was a little bit) now that there's HeartGold and SoulSilver. This is just part of a new ROM hack.
Rating: 9/10
Reason: Because it looks nice~ ahehe i just really dont like the style lol xD thats why 9!
BUT IT'S THE BEST ^_~

Originally Posted by ~Satoshi Sugimori~
Name: ???
Made on: Congbu
Rating: 9.5/10
Reason: Really cool! Looks like Japanese Nice Tiles Nice Palettes Nice Mapping!
Except for some Error that's why i didn't give you a perfect score xD ^_^ but still great!

Post More you guys!
all i ever wanted was happiness
Age 27
Seen May 19th, 2009
Posted May 18th, 2009
104 posts
14.1 Years
Name:???? Village
From:Fire Red
Info:I redo everything..i mean i did not edit the map i post the last time..this is what i made from scratch..it took me 45 mins to do this...
Rate it guys...
Spoiler:
Alot Better! I Like It (except the fences- they sorta throw me off)- also there are a couple places you can get off the map (but thinking if it were in a game, you would just run into the border trees)
8/10

http://img257.imageshack.us/img257/305/newbark.png

This is a New Bark town remake. I tried to make it as exact to the GS one as possible, which is why there's that city pathway. I might edit it later to make it like HG/SS, with grass instead of path.

No, I'm not making a GS remake, there's absolutely no point (before there was a little bit) now that there's HeartGold and SoulSilver. This is just part of a new ROM hack.
i like it except it is kinda blandish for my tastes- also, the path doesn't really work with me- maybe try the other path? (the one that looks like White and Grey bricks)
i give it....... well........ 7.5

Ray Maverick

Age 27
Male
Seen 7 Hours Ago
Posted 2 Days Ago
3,411 posts
14.3 Years
http://img257.imageshack.us/img257/305/newbark.png

This is a New Bark town remake. I tried to make it as exact to the GS one as possible, which is why there's that city pathway. I might edit it later to make it like HG/SS, with grass instead of path.

No, I'm not making a GS remake, there's absolutely no point (before there was a little bit) now that there's HeartGold and SoulSilver. This is just part of a new ROM hack.
:\
Everyone can copy this map from Zel.
5,41/10
the tiles are boring,but i pretend i never see them cause its a remake.

Haz

Haz ya seen my hack?

Female
Australia- Aussie, Aussie, Aussie!, Oi, Oi, Oi!
Seen August 16th, 2011
Posted October 21st, 2010
698 posts
14.5 Years
Okay because I really want to improve my mapping, can someone please rate this? It's for my hack, Moon-Glow.

Name: Curse Woods
Rom name: Fire Red
Commments: This replaces Viridian Forest.
Spoiler:


DeviantART: Haz-Za

Fanfiction.net: Ha-Za-A


Credits to Galukxy for this awesome banner :)

Haz

Haz ya seen my hack?

Female
Australia- Aussie, Aussie, Aussie!, Oi, Oi, Oi!
Seen August 16th, 2011
Posted October 21st, 2010
698 posts
14.5 Years
I counldn't see any tile errors except for one. Also, I posted the wrong map, that was the old one.
Also, I know about the dark green spot above the trees, it's part of the rom base, it can't be helped.

EDIT: Posted wrong map again. Posted new one.
EDITb 2: Photobucket keeps wrecking map. Placed it in an attachment instead.
DeviantART: Haz-Za

Fanfiction.net: Ha-Za-A


Credits to Galukxy for this awesome banner :)

Alice

(>^.(>0.0)>

Age 31
Female
Oregon
Seen April 30th, 2015
Posted April 29th, 2015
3,077 posts
14.2 Years
I counldn't see any tile errors except for one. Also, I posted the wrong map, that was the old one. Here is the new one:
Spoiler:



I know about the dark green spot above the trees, it's part of the rom base, it can't be helped.
EDIT: Posted wrrong map again. Posted new one.
I see more tile errors at the bottom left in the mountain and trees.
Age 27
Male
Best City OCE
Seen October 18th, 2021
Posted April 1st, 2013
5,978 posts
15.1 Years
:\
Everyone can copy this map from Zel.
5,41/10
the tiles are boring,but i pretend i never see them cause its a remake.
So, uh, right. I get a 5.4 for a near-perfect remake because the tiles are "boring" and Zel's done it before. >_> Hell nice, huh. Originality is not an issue, nor is the tileset. I'm not whinging (actually, maybe I am...) but, seriously. A 5.4 because it's been done before. :|
Everything ends,
and that's always sad.
But everything begins again, too,
and that's always happy.

Haz

Haz ya seen my hack?

Female
Australia- Aussie, Aussie, Aussie!, Oi, Oi, Oi!
Seen August 16th, 2011
Posted October 21st, 2010
698 posts
14.5 Years
http://img257.imageshack.us/img257/305/newbark.png

This is a New Bark town remake. I tried to make it as exact to the GS one as possible, which is why there's that city pathway. I might edit it later to make it like HG/SS, with grass instead of path.

No, I'm not making a GS remake, there's absolutely no point (before there was a little bit) now that there's HeartGold and SoulSilver. This is just part of a new ROM hack.

I like it. It reminds me of a little old villiage in the middle of nowhere. I recommend fixing the pathe so it's not so wide. So overall a 8.5/10.
DeviantART: Haz-Za

Fanfiction.net: Ha-Za-A


Credits to Galukxy for this awesome banner :)

Ray Maverick

Age 27
Male
Seen 7 Hours Ago
Posted 2 Days Ago
3,411 posts
14.3 Years
So, uh, right. I get a 5.4 for a near-perfect remake because the tiles are "boring" and Zel's done it before. >_> Hell nice, huh. Originality is not an issue, nor is the tileset. I'm not whinging (actually, maybe I am...) but, seriously. A 5.4 because it's been done before. :|

Do you request a higher rating?I dont rate the map by its mistakes,i rate it by the sight mistakes.
And i decided i dont like these pallets to New Bark town. @[email protected]


Anyway,here is a map i made for fun.Trebuh may like it enough to put it in his hack.

Spoiler:



i'll post a version with trees soon.I dont know if it looks better with trees,but i think its original to see a place without many trees/mountain/water.So,i thought to create that place.
Age 30
Male
It is for me to noe and all of you to find out
Seen April 17th, 2022
Posted October 16th, 2021
1,318 posts
14.2 Years
Do you request a higher rating?I dont rate the map by its mistakes,i rate it by the sight mistakes.
And i decided i dont like these pallets to New Bark town. @[email protected]


Anyway,here is a map i made for fun.Trebuh may like it enough to put it in his hack.

Spoiler:



i'll post a version with trees soon.I dont know if it looks better with trees,but i think its original to see a place without many trees/mountain/water.So,i thought to create that place.
i really love the tiles...
i don noe why but this map simply make me like it...
i love the placing of the houses..
i rate this 9.9/10
the 0.1 you can add a bit more trees or mountains...