Anime Tournament II Round 1 Match 1: Nanoha vs. My HiME

[digi-kun]

Since you were so lazy we had to do all the work, lazy bums >>

Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha

My HiME

credit to ANN as usual

 

[Ryoutarou]

This one is a no brainer, for me at least. XD

My HiME is a whole lot better than Nanoha.

 

[Natsuki]

I didn't miss the poll for once! :OOO!

Anyway, I vote for My HiME as well. X3 I've been watching the series lately and think it's pretty good. =D

Also...I've never heard of Nanoha, so yeah. XD

~Kelsey

 

[Samurai X]

I've never heard of Nanoha either and I kind of like My HiME so it gets my vote here.

 

[Lucy Lu]

My HiME gets my vote. It looks better than Nanoha anyway. I haven't seen My HiME or Nanoha, but I know My HiME is soo much better.

 

[Chikara]

Wow, I guess this one is a bit one-sided. My HiME

 

[Karasuma]

Never seen Nanoha so my vote goes to My Hime~

 

[kohei]

What's with all these people who havn't watched both and are still voting O_O;

Lyrical Nanoha (both first season and A's) gets my vote simply because I like the storyline better, and the fact that the weapons/magical devices look ten times more cooler.

Plus it actually made me cry, while Mai-Hime didn't.

[EDIT]: Also series length. Mai-Hime is too long imo.
Infact to me, all anime series over 15 episodes or so are long. Infact the only long series I'm wtaching right now is Fate Stay/Night, so go figure.

 

[mewthree w/armor]

From the little of it I've seen My HiME gets my vote.

 

[buster_wolf]

Mai Hime's all right, but Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha is the BEST Mahou Shoujo out there. It's got a really good story line... Sadly though, nobody else has seen Nanoha... >( I voted for Nanoha.

As for long series animes... I pretty much prefer Comedy.

Like Mahoraba, Pani Poni Dash, and so forth. But short series are so much easier to follow. =P