Flamebe Recoloring

[Firemaker]

I am doing recolors, I have examples

Here are my posting rules

• Decide Every color
• I do only pokemon, not trainers
• No Fusions
• Only 1 request per post
• I do only RS/FR,LG sprites,

Not all the colors will work, if they don't I will post that and you can RErequest. If you do not follow these rules, your post will be ignored

 

[Alex_]

Wow,your shading is pretty bad. You need to work on it big time.

 

[Umbreon's Shadow]

You seriously need to work on these.The Wailord is blurry,the Zapdos has praticly no shading,and the Eevee has no shading at all.1/10

 

[Firemaker]

I will metion a few things, these are my 1st recolors

How is my shading wrong?
Yes Wailord is somehow blurry, and Zapdos does have shading. Eevee doesn't but Zapdos does :\

 

[Alex_]

It just needs work,and if you're just starting,you really shouldn't be opening a request thread.

 

[Umbreon's Shadow]

Being your first is NO excuse.And by awful shading,i mean there is no darker or lighter colors to make it realistic.

 

[Firemaker]

Umbreon Shadow, There is shading, you cannot see it.
_Alex_ maybe you're right but I need practice recoloring and it is hard to decide.

 

[Alex_]

Firemaker there is little shading or none at all.

 

[Firemaker]

Firemaker there is little shading or none at all.

You are right there is little shading, but that is shading

 

[Umbreon's Shadow]

Thats the problem.Little shading isnt good.You need good shading.But train and you may get it right.

 

[Sylphiel]

Since others have mentioned shading, I'll mention other things as well:

My advice would just be to not use bright colors. Like the magenta on the houndour, or the lime green on the wailord...bright colors like that really don't suit pokemon sprites, and tend to stick out way too much.

Oh, and if possible, never ever save a sprite in .jpg format. The file compression tends to make sprites not look as good as they could be.

I actually see shading on the eevee, it's just that because there's not much in the way of value difference, it's not seen well enough. When shading, watch out for that - make sure there's enough of a difference between the lightness/darkness of the colors chosen, so that any shading/highlighting attempts can be seen.

I do like your porygon, though, just because of the colors used for it.

 

[Firemaker]

I am training by taking requests, that way I can hear an opinion other than you and _Alex_

 

[Shikon no Tama]

Firemaker there is little shading or none at all.

I agree with that statement. Firemaker, pratice your shading as much as possible BEFORE opening a request shop. Your first try is no excuse when it comes to spriting. Look at the Houndour, the shading is horrible on it, and Zapdos and Eevee don't even have any shading at all. Try harder next time, and
you'll get better. ;D

 

[Firemaker]

Ok then, this should be closed or and deleted

 

[Umbreon's Shadow]

Okay then il give you some simple things too do.Do not rush it or it will look bad.

Red Jigglypuff
Red Chansey

 

[Shikon no Tama]

Ok then, this should be closed or and deleted

The only ok recolours I see are Krabby and the sixth one.

 

[Sawyer]

well, i don't know much about spriting, but i can tell the difference between good and bad :x the only good one, imo is the porygon, because the colors don't look like normal MSPaint colors, as the rest do. i can hardly tell the Wailord is a wailord.. x.x
if you wanted people to see your first-try sprites, you should make a new thread, rather than make a request thread. i can, however, understand where he's coming from. maybe he wanted to get better and be good enough for other people to want his sprites... i see that a lot in G&P, only with banners, not sprites. *shrugs*

 

[Firemaker]

I know Chansey looks bad, that was because I used Paint Bucket instead of Selective Color

 

[Shikon no Tama]

I can't see Chansey's outlines! >.<;;; And those look like the default MS Paint colours too on Chansey. Jigglypuff looks good from what I can see.

 

[Alex_]

If you truly want me to close this,just say.