• Ever thought it'd be cool to have your art, writing, or challenge runs featured on PokéCommunity? Click here for info - we'd love to spotlight your work!
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.
    Register

Which pokemon was Ash dumb enough to give away?

Which pokemon was Ash dumb to give away?

  • Total voters
    30
It was the worst thing to give Charizard away.
Well I think this would be better in Pok?mon TV Shows and Movies.
*Moved*
 
I think he should have kept Pidgeot

I would have helped a lot in the Silver Conference
 
i think he did the right thing... he got a heroic image to keep up you know... "must allow the Pokemon to go to the path s/he desired". Even Musashi and Kojirou got influenced by satoshi and even they are starting to release their pokemon (but that was one sad episode...)
 
Major Characters-
Satoshi- Ash
Kasumi- Misty
Takeshi- Brock
Shigeru- Gary
Kenji- Tracey
Kojirou- James
Musashi- Jessie
Masato- Max
Haruka- umm... you know... same as the 5th month

i should make a list of these japanese names somewhere...
 
frostweaver said:
Major Characters-
Satoshi- Ash
Kasumi- Misty
Takeshi- Brock
Shigeru- Gary
Kenji- Tracey
Kojirou- James
Musashi- Jessie
Masato- Max
Haruka- umm... you know... same as the 5th month

i should make a list of these japanese names somewhere...
Click to expand...
Oh Jess and James. Ok now I know who you are talking about.
 
Even though Butterfree needed to mate, Ash REALLY should've kept it. I guess the anime thought having something known for spreading sleep powder around a lot too powerful.
 
i chose larvitar man!
i mean, ash with a tyranitar (after it evolves), who doesn't wanna see that?!
 
I don't think it's right to call him 'dumb', I guess he does the right thing.
Like with Lapras, there were family matters. And he gave Charizard to that girl so his Charizard could get stronger. And he left Squirtle because Squirtle's squad was hopeless without Squirtle.

I do sorta agree with the Larvitar matter...but, like with Lapras, family matters.
I mean, can you imagine what the Tyranitar mother would've done if he'd kept it away from her? :dead:
 
it is a close tie between Butterfree and Pidgeot...

Butterfree could use Sleep Powder and end a battle almost instantly (or at least by how battles go in the anime...)

Pidgeot could've easily become an awesome aerial battler if he had kept it (it's gust attack was awesome in the one episode it appeared in)

I wouldn't consider Charizard "given away" as Ash could just call upon Liza and she will send it right over.
 
Ash shouldntve give any off his Pokemon away!!! well, exept for a few, like Larvitar, and Lapras. Ash always says he'll see them soon, so whens soon? when hes 30? i choose Charizard, cause hes probly the strongest Pokemon Ash'll ever have!
 
I think he should have kept them all.... but it's his Pokemon so I don't really care.
 
He should of kept Butterfree or Pidgeot... They are powerful pokemon and it could help him in a tight spot.
 
lol i think he gave away primeape was stupid i loved him !
 
G-LANCE said:
i chose larvitar man!
i mean, ash with a tyranitar (after it evolves), who doesn't wanna see that?!
Click to expand...
D*** straight, Kenny boi!! If I were Ash, I'd take the Larvitar and train it to be TYRANITAR!!! *roars* Larvitar's a VERY good pokemon with great stats!! He should have kept it!! ARGH! Sorry if I'm getting out of shape but I am such in a crappy mood today, cus I got the crap beaten out of me by my grandpa cus I didn't buy his drinks.. : P But yes, Larvitar is very strong. Also Charizard and Pidgeot.. I cried when he let go of Pidgeot!!! *cries*

*Pidgeot kills CaRtOON*

~CaRtOON
 
I just think ash iz the dumbest trainer giving his pokemon
away if he wanted to do that he shouldent have caught
them in the first place and also he wants to be a pokemon master right! than why doesent he catch the
wild pokemon he seez.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top