Do you want Brock to return ?

[tough]

Brock character was really pure golden epic during the Kanto and Johto era,but in Hoenn he started to become a little bit stale and in Sinnoh he became a horrible boring character thanks to the terrible DP series.

 

[Railgun]

I enjoyed him in AG but in DP he was over shadowed sadly.

 

[Raizhu]

Yes. I agree that he sort of faded into the background in DP, but if the same thing didn't happen again I'd love to see him and Croagunk again.

 

[Sheep]

He was a great character for people who have been watching since the Kanto days but unfortunately he got boring in D/P... almost always in the background and really only explained typing and stuff for the younger viewers. So I'm going to say no; they've done all they could with him, really. x:

 

[AshPikastar]

I have to admit, Brock was a good character within the Pokemon series but like what everyone is saying, Brock became boring in the DP series. Even though he was part of the team Galactic plot, he still didn't do much in the series at all. I liked him better in the AG series. I'm glad that they changed it up a bit and had finally let Brock work on something he actually wants to do besides traveling with Ash. It would be great to have him come back in one episode like how they did with Misty and May but other then bringing him back into the series, I would have to say no.

 

[Kirbychu]

No, unless they're willing to salvage his personality.

 

[blue]

Yes! I love Brock, he's so great and he was there right from the start!

 

[Squirrel]

Not unless they want to make him somewhat interesting again, he really wasn't necessary throughout DP. The only episodes he was important in were the less interesting ones in my opinion. And sure he had the lake guardian team up with him and follow him, but he still managed to do that without any emotion. :/ I think ti could be nice to see him come back for a couple episodes as a little one off story seeing him come in as a doctor or something, maybe even healing a main characters Pokemon from a near-fatal injury? But other than that no, I wouldn't like to see him back for a long time. :p

 

[Charicific]

Yeah....though I didn't notice how lame he was in DP since the poison jabs made it up for him xD
I want Brock back at some point, if the DP Brock was boring then i will have to agree with you...but I gotta say, I LOVE CILAN!!!

 

[PlatinumDude]

I wouldn't mind if Brock came back. I can't help but wonder how he and Cilan will interact with one another; they could exchange recipes and Pokemon training/breeding tips.

 

[~*!*~Tatsujin Gosuto~*!*~]

Maybe in a few episodes while traveling with Ash in the Unova region. For some odd reason the Sinnoh region was just horrible for him. Maybe if he acted the way he did in the Hoenn, I would want him back.


:t354:TG

 

[Kenshin5]

As a Main Character traveling through out the region no. Unless they actually add something or somethings good to him that make him interesting and fresh again. Otherwise I am content with him just being a reoccurring character in cameos or traveling with Ash in Post Saga arcs like Misty did in Battle Frontier. I'd love to see him as Doctor Brock for sure though.

 

[Jorah]

What? Brock died well before DP; more like somewhere in Johto, just like Misty. All he was was a running gag that mostly stood in the background, and that is true for him for pretty much every series he's been in. I don't care if we ever see him again.

 

[psyanic]

The writers totally squandered Brock. He had so much potential, yet the writers decided not to dwell into his breeding or whatever. Instead, they used him as a womanizer and a Pokemon tutor. I guess he's better off as a doctor since they really don't want him anyway and won't bother using him. And he can flirt with all the Nurse Joys he can count on his toes.

Yeah, I don't really want him back now that I think about it.

 

[Mario The World Champion]

Do I want to have Brock back on the show? No. God, no. The main reason I can't stand him was because the writers made him into a girl crazed pervert who hit on any girl in the series. It got to the point where I wished that each time he hit on an Officer Jenny, she would pepper spray him and brutalize him.

He has been pretty much ruined by the writers. Keep him away for good.

 

[X80relianthope]

i think brock should return because he was the only actual pokemon trainer or breeder that was mature on the show but i think its good he finally found something for him :)

 

[Uecil]

Brock was cool and all that jazz, imo, but I sort of like Cilan better. So, I don't really want him to return unless it's like a guest appearance.

 

[tough]

Brock was really great and he had a cool personality i hope he get a cameo that will be cool if that happen.

 

[Darthbane2007]

Other than an episode or 2, no. His character got old and redundant starting with Johto anyway..

 

[tough]

Brock character was good in Johto but by the time Hoenn started he begin to become a bit boring and when Sinnoh begin he become a pointless character that is not even anymore good.