View Single Post
  #3    
Old March 3rd, 2013 (9:26 AM).
Esper's Avatar
Esper Esper is offline
Hug bear wants hugs
Silver Tier
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: California
Posts: 9,269
Okay, so let me see if I understand how this works:

You nominate a song for each tier, and you said that we're going in reverse order so I assume that the first tier we're nominating songs for is #100, or #100-91. Not entirely clear which. And if a song we nominate gets bumped out then it's gone completely?

So just for the sake of my understanding, if I nominate something like Rolling in the Deep right now it's never going to place better than the spot I (or someone else) nominates to? Even if I do it right now and every single person who posts after me says "Yes! That is the best song" and it's unanimously agreed upon to be one of PC's favorite songs ever? I would have to withhold my nomination for a better tier, hope someone else doesn't nominate it, and then hope it wins in the tier I do nominate it because even if it gets second place in the top tier it's gonna disappear from the rankings.

I'm not trying to ruin this. I'm just confused about how this is gonna work. I think the idea is a good one (even if a hundred songs sounds like it would take a year to get)
__________________

Plava Laguna
1982 CP

Noodle
1453 CP

Punk Pink
1511 CP


Calcifer
1716 CP

Agent 14
2070 CP

Mochi
2103 CP



Reply With Quote