This or That! (Pokemon Edition)

Rules are simple, first one asks "this" or "that" and next person answers and asks next one. Also tell us why you chose that one if you just can.

Example:

Poster 1: Cyndaquil or Charmander?
Poster 2: Cyndaquil because [insert reason here]. Bulbasaur or Chikorita?

And so on and so forth. You can do anything Pokemon related, such as Trainers, Items, etc etc.

To start off:

Cleffa or Igglybuff?

Cleffa, because of Magic Guard.

Pickup or Honey Gather?

Pickup because it provides us with more valuable things than Honey Gather.

Feebas or Magikarp?

Magikarp, because Gyarados (do I have to say anything more?)

Poke Ball or Park Ball?

Pokeball cause ya gotta keep it traditional


Celebi or Jirachi

Ehh tough choice. I think I'll have to go with Jirachi though.

Muk or Garbordor.

Muk, because Garbodor's design makes me cringe...

Dragonite or Hydreigon?

Dragonite, because its one of my two favorites pokemons.

Mew or Mewtwo?

New, it just is so epic


Contests or Musicals

Contest, because you actually got to get an award from beating it. (A Ribbon)

Ash or Red

Red, because he's like Ash except with talent ;P

Hoenn or Unova?

Hoenn because of the awesome legends. Groudon is a beast.
Gen 1 starters or Gen 2 starters? (overall)

Generation 1 Starters, because they are the original three and will always remain very close to me. :)

Cubchoo or Spheal?

Cubchoo, it's like an ice type teddiursa :3

Brock or Roark?

Brock all the way, sad he left the series


Moomoomilk or Casteliacones

MoomooMilk, because in the anime they could make many dairy products including Icecream too

Lum Berry or Sitrus Berry ?

Sitrus Berry, always thought it sounded tastier



Chimchar or also Chimchar

Just kidding

Berries or Poffins

Berries. Never really played a Gen IV game so no idea what poffins do :D

Conkeldurr or Machamp?

Conkeldurr, just because of his derpy name xD

Jirachi or Mew?

Mew, the original unobtainable Pokemon :3

Single or Dual typed Pokemon?