• Our software update is now concluded. You will need to reset your password to log in. In order to do this, you will have to click "Log in" in the top right corner and then "Forgot your password?".
  • Welcome to PokéCommunity! Register now and join one of the best fan communities on the 'net to talk Pokémon and more! We are not affiliated with The Pokémon Company or Nintendo.

[Pokémon] The spiral of war

1
Posts
12
Years
  • Seen Feb 27, 2012
This is my new Pokémon FanFic project.

My natural language is Spanish, so feel free to let me know about any spelling mistake or misused expression.

Here is the Pilot episode.
Any comment you leave will be useful.

Chapter 00
Spoiler:


Thanks for reading.
 

bobandbill

one more time
16,921
Posts
16
Years
Firstly, there's no real need to put it in a spoiler, although I guess it's up to you. Just a bit odd with fics is all. And secondly, welcome to the forums!

The story was pretty decently written, especially considering that English isn't your first language. There's some small things here and there but overall it's understandable and also enjoyable to read. I quite liked the atmosphere of the first half of it, and the plot itself is also pretty interesting. I liked the narrator of the second half as well as he seemed more personally engaging than the man in the first part for myself - the latter seemed a bit more of a cardboard cutout so maybe consider showing some more character of the ambush Sharpedo guy. In short, it is a good beginning.

One thing I'd suggest to look out for is how you start sentences:
The ambush was just perfect… no contingency could crush that conviction.

The squad was the fastest one you could form in Hoenn. The Carvanha recruited for the mission belonged to professional swimmers. The Pelipper were caught at Evergrande City's cliffs.
For instance in the beginning a lot of sentences in a row started with 'The' which does start to get a bit repetitive after a while. On that note however this wasn't a common problem.
A Castform would summon a heavy rain which could conceal them from enemy's eyes.
'enemy eyes' is how the expression is often said, or alternatively you could go with 'the enemy's eyes' if you want to refer to a specific enemy, be it an individual or group.
They even had precious information about the rival captain: one out of the three Gyarados escorting his fleet, was able to perform electric attacks.
The comma after 'fleet' is unnecessary.
Seconds before the clash, a pale flash of light, followed by a deafening thunder, made them to bend down their heads.
Same here with the comma after 'thunder' (and arguably 'light' as well). I'll also add that 'made them to bend down their heads' sounds a bit clunky and wordy - keeping it to 'made them bend down their heads' says the same thing just fine ('to' is unnecessary).
Whit the Sharpedo's aquajet they dodged the first one and knocked down the rider of the next one, in the same quick movement.
'Whit' means a very little bit - maybe you meant to type With. Also the move is known as Aqua Jet (two words) so I'd suggest typing it as aqua jet given you're going the uncapitalised route with attacks.
No sooner were they submerged again, a weird light surrounded the fainted pokémon and was followed by its transformation into a pink little mass, with no defined form.
The first part sounded a bit odd, partly because it feels a bit disjointed with the rest on either side of the first comma. It also just sounds weird so I'd suggest rewording the sentence, or at least the first part. (And heh - I had guessed the extra Gyarados might have been a Ditto).
Among all the words I heard from him, these, the most casual and free from wonder, would be the ones I would curse and bless so many times; the ones able to survive my consciousness' indifference and, even after that, would keep echoing from my depths until being part of every action, latent, hidden like a Carvanha shoal beneath a dark wave… I'm sorry, future reader.
This one also sounded a bit weird in that it's a run on sentence and somewhat overwordy. Either cut down on the verbose description of the words' effect on him or split into two or even three sentences.

A neat beginning however! Good luck with the rest of your fic. =)
 

Cutlerine

Gone. May or may not return.
1,030
Posts
14
Years
I'd agree with bobandbill here: this is pretty good considering English isn't your first language. It's an intriguing introduction that drops us into the action right away, throwing up a lot of questions and answering very few of them. Perhaps it could've been a little longer, but you did intend it as a 'pilot', so that's fine.

In addition to what bobandbill pointed out, I have my own set of points to make. Let's start at the beginning.

The ambush was just perfect… no contingency could crush that conviction.

It's sufficient to say that the ambush was perfect; 'just perfect' is more of a conversational construction than a written one, and it's not often used anyway. Also, the word 'contingency' sounds a little out of place here. It means a predicted future event that may or may not happen (hence the common English phrase 'contingency plan'). I'd change it for something else - maybe just write 'nothing could crush that conviction'?

Although he was just about to hit one of the boats, the commander instinctively turned his head and managed to see the smoking fall of, at least, half of the birds.

The commas around 'at least' are unnecessary, and make the sentence more difficult to read. I'd remove them. Furthermore, you might want to change the word 'instinctively' for something that tells us a bit more - for instance, 'the commander saw something out of the corner of his eye and turned his head'. Saying that he 'instinctively' turned his head without any further mention of why strikes me as a bit strange. I don't know. Perhaps it's just me.

I think bobandbill covered most, if not all, of the other odd language uses and grammatical anomalies, so I'll move on to the positive now. I liked the way you return at the end to the same thought expressed at the beginning at the end; if you'd stopped there, you'd have had a really powerful prologue. There's something to consider - to increase the impact, you could put the italicised bit into Chapter One. Alternatively, leave it here; it's only a little thing and doesn't make much difference.

You've also demonstrated that you've got at least some grasp of how to use Pokémon moves creatively, which is good. The Ditto twist, the Castform's heavy rain... all this is great stuff, and if you keep on using moves in less than obvious ways and keeping in mind the fact that certain Pokémon can do certain very interesting things to the plot, you'll have a great story.

All in all, a very promising start. Good luck with it, and I look forward to more!

F.A.B.
 
Back
Top