Only on trying to figure out which albums were even candidates, and coming up with very few more than I actually listened to in the whole year, did I realise what a truly horrific year for music 2014 was. Only the top two albums really hit me to any degree and even then #1 is the only one I've absolutely raved about. Ladies and gentlemen I present the most rubbish AotY list ever.
#5. Ruins by
Grouper
sample
This album is vacant as anything. I described it when I was listening to it as being alone at home on some totally uneventful night sat killing time by watching shit TV. So it kinda sounds weird that I'd put it in top 5 but it's the empty, almost flat atmosphere that it brings on which is the reason why I enjoyed it so much in the first place. It's a difficult task to describe really how exactly an album with so little going on can feel so... huge and all-engulfing, but it just kinda does. It just wraps you up in a load of nothing and I kinda loved it. It's hard to explain what I mean so just go listen to that link if you're interested.
#4. A U R O R A by
Ben Frost
sample
I will not lie to you. I dislike the sound that Ben Frost and his weird set of buttons makes. I dislike it more every time I listen to this album. It sounds tinny, flat, and like everything is struggling way too hard to be heard. ...but it's organised so goddamn beautifully and comes together in these huge crushing epiphanies that absolutely drown you in sound and oh my fucking god ben frost pls stop. It's rare that something that I dislike so much on the surface makes it into my good books - and pretty much novel that something like that'd get onto an AotY list - but despite my major issue with it I absolutely love the music he's created and how this album comes together to make an absolute spectacle of noise. Good show, Ben Frost.
#3. And the War Came by
Shakey Graves
sample (this one sounds kinda crap, but most of them are live otherwise)
I don't know how to describe this album because there's so much different stuff on it (and, invariably as you see with albums like that, there's some stuff that is... really not good) but for the most part it's done very well. It's kinda hard therefore for me to pin down exactly what it is about this album that does it for me, but... it's probably just the collection of nice things on it, haha. I actually had quite a hard time picking one song to source for this and if you do listen to what I linked and enjoy it I really recommend you check out the rest of the album too. It's a good, fun, interesting listen which takes you through quite a lot of different moods. Also I think his voice and guitar work is quite cool which is nice since that's mostly all there is too it, haha.
#2. Lost In The Dream by
The War On Drugs
sample
I genuinely believe that, as far as you can objectively say anything is the best in music anyway (protip: you can't really to any significant extent), this is, purely musically speaking, the best album of 2014. Full stop, hands down, this is it. This is just over an hour of some of the most fantastically crafted, meticulously thought-out, uplifting-without-being-obnoxious, "it just works" music that I have ever heard. This album is an absolute masterpiece of music for people who like music and want to listen to an album where everything is just where it should be and it all flows really smoothly. It's one of the most polished works that I've ever heard.
...and therein lies its problem, and why it isn't my #1 for this year. It's absolutely delightfully made but in that they've not allowed themselves any mistakes, any inconsistencies, any moments of them just getting the fuck into it and not caring if the end recording sounds a bit less consistent and a bit rougher around the edges (beyond towards the end of Red Eyes that is, maybe). The result is something brilliantly designed but also predictable, passive at points, and I'd even go to say unnatural and inexpressive to some degree. I can't listen to it without wishing they'd gone just that little bit further or done something just that little bit differently to really bring this thing to life. It's a brilliantly crafted album but I don't really feel much when I'm listening to it beyond "oh, this sounds really good". I found it disappointing on that front, so it's not getting the top spot from me.
#1. Three Love Songs by
Ricky Eat Acid
sample
Probably one of the most soul-crushing deeply emotional rollercoasters of electronic music that I have ever heard, which is weird since only at one point does it actually get even mildly rollercoaster-ish; you'll see what I mean if you've heard it. I don't know if it's the oddly specific track titles, the only real coherent vocals that are obviously talking about something related to the album being the opening track, or the just... sort of progressive nature of the album in terms of mood, but this is a story with almost no words. And it's one messed up story.
The album is a mess. It's unpolished, it's random at points, it's often directionless. It's a confused slew of sounds that aren't quite sure what they're doing or why they're there but they're doing their bit the best they can. And it's, I feel, perfectly representative of how the producer wanted it to be. From his other work with a different band you can tell this guy has a lot of shit to talk about and although he's not talking about it exactly here, this is what it'd sound like if you could put it into a series of un-coordinated bleeps, samples and textures. I don't think I have ever - and would honestly say I don't think I will ever again - heard this kind of complexity in a situation be expressed in so few words. This is one of the most incredible things I've ever heard.
Ya. Honourable mentions to releases by Caribou, The Birthday Massacre, Aphex Twin, Andy Stott and others.