1. Reapers - 10/10 (Perfect)
This is quintessential Muse! Beautiful and crisp guitar runs matched with Bellamy's amazing falsetto. My new favorite Muse song...and that's saying a lot give their previous work.
2. Handler - 10/10 (Perfect)
This song makes you feel like a badass! There are elements of typical Muse, but the music feels evolved and distinct from previous work.
3. Mercy - 10/10 (Perfect)
Probably the best lyrics and I love the upbeat piano accompanied by the punching drum-line. Many are making Starlight comparisons, but I think beyond the piano it's distinctive as a track.
4. Dead Inside - 9/10 (Amazing)
Next Bond theme song! Maybe a bit overproduced that I would like, but I love the cohesion of the heavy bass + drumbeat clashing with Bellamy's falsetto. Probably the best lyrics and I love the bridge in particular.
5. Psycho - 8.5/10 (Great)
I love it, but I am not a big fan of the shouting drill sergeant and some of the riffs are unoriginal/recycled/typical. But, despite not being a masterpiece of originality, the track definitely is a go-to to jam out to.
6. Defector - 8/10 (Great)
I don't think it is a stand out, but I loved some of the instrumentals particularly the eery guitar rifts near the end. The Queen-like chorus is also fun.
7. Revolt - 7.5/10 (good)
It's not bad. A catchy tune, but not my favorite of the album.
8. Everything after - 4/10 (Poor)
Aftermath - I usually don't like when Muse tries to go for slow and contemplative songs that end up bordering on cheesy grandiosity. This one actually kind of works. and is relaxing and has appropriate build up, though I don't think it has completely escaped the cheesiness comletely.
Globalist - Like the second law, the symphonic grandiosity does elevate to a level of silliness is reminiscent of the 2nd law despite the beautiful execution. The music feels disjoint and overindulgent with trying to profound and contemplative. That piano + strings combo is literally the same as
Drones -I think it would have worked if Globalist wasn't preceding it. It serves as a closer, but maybe if the aftermath was tweaked it could have been a decent closer.
Showbiz - 8.5/10
Origin of Symmetry - 9.5/10
Absolution - 10/10
Black Holes and Revelations - 10/10
The Resistance - 6/10
The 2nd Law - 5/10
Drones - 9/10
Overall, I love this album.