Map Rating/Review Thread

[Quilava's Master]

Heres the forst town in my upcoming hack.

Map name:Greenleaf town.

Map Game:fire red

Comments:credit to x-buster and forgoten memmory for rom base.

eh...again with that rombase which was quite buggy (goto the Sevii Islands to get what im tlkin bout)
well there are WAY to many rocks...the floweres in a row no comment >.< This maybe the first town but jeeze add a little life into it..And it looks like you avoided the its too square comment by adding extra trees to tha bottom sides..

I give this map a 6/10

 

[Neti]

eh...again with that rombase which was quite buggy (goto the Sevii Islands to get what im tlkin bout)
well there are WAY to many rocks...the floweres in a row no comment >.< This maybe the first town but jeeze add a little life into it..And it looks like you avoided the its too square comment by adding extra trees to tha bottom sides..

I give this map a 6/10

wait... did you say there are too many rocks?

there are WAY to many rocks

oh yes, you really did...
Thre is not a SINGLE Rock on that map! Dude what are you talkin about?^^
btw its not good that there is no rock, but therefor there are too many bushes and flowers
and the flowers are too ordered like you already said

 

[Quilava's Master]

wait... did you say there are too many rocks?
oh yes, you really did...
Thre is not a SINGLE Rock on that map! Dude what are you talkin about?^^
btw its not good that there is no rock, but therefor there are too many bushes and flowers
and the flowers are too ordered like you already said

lol well i thought the green things were rocks...arent they? the thingies next to the door of the houses

 

[Neti]

those are bushes^^
i dont know no green rocks... maybe when theyre covered with moss

 

[Chimchar 9]

those are bushes^^
i dont know no green rocks... maybe when theyre covered with moss

yeah they could be lol and there are too many flowers and its too small i give it 3/10

 

[Quickster]

eh...again with that rombase which was quite buggy (goto the Sevii Islands to get what im tlkin bout)
well there are WAY to many rocks...the floweres in a row no comment >.< This maybe the first town but jeeze add a little life into it..And it looks like you avoided the its too square comment by adding extra trees to tha bottom sides..

I give this map a 6/10

could you maybe give me some tips on how to make it more lively and less squarish without the trees?

 

[MudMast]

I'm here again. (For my second? post)

Anyway:

Map Name: Twinleaf Town
Map Game: Pokémon Alpha (Ruby)
Comments: The first Town in my Hack. Set 20 Years Later than the events of DP.
I know there are no Signposts on Your /Your Rivals houses, they are meant to be like that.
I know the map is square in some parts.

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Rotel Town.

Map Game: FireRed.

Comments: Just Rate it. Thanks. ^^

Mapshot:

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Hey there!
I got a new map!
It's the first floor of Mt. ... Name Pending.

 

[PokemonRoxMed]

I don't know what to say! It's just awesome!!

 

[.Iramet]

NAME-fonley town
GAME-ruby
COMMENTS-supposed to be a harbor town

 

[PokemonRoxMed]

your probably a NewB like me, right? Lots of tile errors. Why is Raikou just standing there?

 

[loitraitim]

Map Name: Ishika Town
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: Just Rate it. Thanks. ^^ (tile by XRichie and leader group Marble)
Mapshot

 

[Quilava's Master]

Map Name: Ishika Town
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: Just Rate it. Thanks. ^^ (tile by XRichie and leader group Marble)
Mapshot

Loitraitim strikes again! Only thing i dont like is the random tree next to the house..Either add another tree to another house or jus remove it eihter way

9.5/10

 

[Neti]

just thought i should post a map here again^^
Map Name: Route 12
Game: FR BPRE
Comments: Theres a Sandstorm on that route
The South is blocked with a strength stone cause you will be able to get there later
The player will be comin from the right and leave tthe map at thee top left

Spoiler:

 

[.Iramet]

pokemonroxmed can you show me the tile errors other than the ones for the white things border^_^

 

[Binary]

just thought i should post a map here again^^
Map Name: Route 12
Game: FR BPRE
Comments: Theres a Sandstorm on that route
The South is blocked with a strength stone cause you will be able to get there later
The player will be comin from the right and leave tthe map at thee top left

Spoiler:

Rating: 9.5/10
Reason: An excellent map. I've never seen such a great desert type map before. It looks really nice with the tiles you've used and the placement of all the rocks and ledges is good.
The whole idea of the map looks superb. Nice!
Suggestions: None apparently, but I think you've used alot of those small rock tiles. Anyways, the map looks really good.

 

[destinedjagold]

Map Name: Ishika Town
Map Game: Fire Red
Comments: Just Rate it. Thanks. ^^ (tile by XRichie and leader group Marble)
Mapshot

COMMENT: the lab-like building is a bit thin, is it not?
RATINGS: 9/10
REASON: I truly love it.
SUGGESTION: The lab. Eek... >.<

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Rotel Town.

Map Game: FireRed.

Comments: Just Rate it. Thanks. ^^

Mapshot:

 

[Neti]

I think you already posted that one...
There are a lot of sqarish parts and straight lines of trees and mountains in it
also you have overdone it with paths and there are a lot of empty areas
just check the parts i marked:

the nred stuff are squarisch and straight things, the blue things are useless paths
and add some life to it.. maybe add some elevations or fences, that divide the town into parts