I agree with tImE, the second map looks much better than the first. Is this a starting town? I don't think I've seen a cave in a starting town before (at least not in a game I've played, there may be in progress games with that feature) so I'm not really used to that, but I suppose that depends on what it's for.
But yeah, good job, especially if you are a new mapper! You give me hope that I can do a good job when I start making serious maps :)
But yeah, good job, especially if you are a new mapper! You give me hope that I can do a good job when I start making serious maps :)