Well, wasn't just me, each scene was vote between the judges, twiggy voted for your too. I think ashpikastar chose forevers. /I don't think I should be telling you this. xD
Well, honestly, I think it's an amazing scene. It shows Paul's last moment in the anime, Ash shouting his fairwell to his rival, how it's set out at sunset, was a great touch too, mainly because of their other full battle a long time ago, Paul just seemingly walked off disappointed in Ash, but this time said they said their farewell, shaping up to Paul respecting Ash finally and pretty much with what Commanderpigg said, the whole impact of it, it certainly took my heart away. I misses DP. :'(
Did you want to know why I didn't pick yours?