5th Gen Black vs White!

I've owned both these games, but I'll probably have to go with White. It's got Reshiram exclusive to it, which is my favorite of the duo. It also has access to Breloom, Honchkrow, and Whimsicott, which are three of my most favorite Pokémon. 8)

I've got both games myself, but it's Black that I'm voting for. I liked its version exclusives better, and I also loved that high-tech look of Opelucid City compared to its rustic look in White. I also liked Black City's design better.

Seeing as I have only owned White, I would have to vote for it. I found myself liking all the Triple Battles in it. I also enjoyed the version exclusive Legendary, which is Zekrom. Catching level five Pokemon in White Forest was also quite fun.

Don't the games have identical music?

I like white better mainly for Zekrom. I'm really not a big fan of Reshiram. I also think that the White Opelucid city looks much nicer. Plus it has Sydian's favorite Pokemon, Petilil in it so you know, what's not to like?

In regards to the new battle formats, I hated both of them so I really can't say one game was better than the other in that respect because ugh Triples and Rotation battles all suck!

White Forest having access to Pokemon also seems more useful than Black's trainer battles in my opinion.

Black because Reshiram. I'm biased towards Fire types to put it simply. ;3

Yeyinde said:

Edit; And either of these version have different cities that act like battle tower.

Click to expand...

I think you're thinking of them in Black 2 and White 2. They don't act that way in Black and White. Black City is filled with people who battle you, and some who sell you rare items. White Forest has special patches of wild Pokemon and items found on the ground. Personally, as a breeder, I preferred White Forest.

White! I prefer white over black plus it had Zekrom which was an electric type, one of my favorite types. *_* I was originally going to get Black but eventually leaned more towards the other version due to it having more version exclusives I'd prefer.

White, because then N can be Seto Kaiba.

Go, Blue-Eyes White Reshiram! Screw your ideals, I have GREEN HAIR!

I personally preferred Black version, though White version had some nice good points to it as well.

The feel of the game was just more enjoyable to me for some reason; I suppose I felt like if I wanted something more 'rustic', I should go play an older gen game instead, haha. The more advanced feeling of black felt better to me.

I also enjoyed the exclusives a lot more in Black. White's were decent, but Whimsicott trumps Lilligant in my opinion, design and game play wise. That's a personal opinion though, so I know others would disagree.

I personally liked White better, just because of Zekrom (:

I prefer the exclusive pokemon of pokemon white

I originally liked Zekrom more so I went with White as my main game, but I eventually grew to like Reshiram more. I like the rest of White's exclusives more than Black's, though, so i'd go with that. I already erased the saved data on my White, anyway, but that's my preference of the two.

I chose White because of its nature-feel and because Iris was a gymleader. Yet I like Reshiram a little bit more, and ended up having to trade for Whimsicott to get in White, the only version exclusive I really cared about.

Liked Zekrom better than Reshiram (I own both) so I'll go with White.

I only played White, and it was the first game I actually played seriously and finished. I chose it over Black because I preferred the old look of Opelucid City. It just felt more fitting having Castelia + Nimbasa + Driftveil as the modern cities of the region, and Icirrus + Opelucid + Lacunosa the more traditional cities. I also like White Forest better than Black City.

As for version exclusives, I don't really mind it that much; I didn't really care about the legendary genies, and non-legendaries are easy to trade for anyway.

I'm gunna go with White on this. The only reason being is that I love White Forest ^w^b

White has the edge for me. The breakdown:

The only Black version Unova pokemon I prefer is Sawk (and it's not even exclusive - it's just more difficult to catch in White). I'm about even on Reuniclus vs. Gothitelle, and prefer Braviary over Mandibuzz and Lilligant over Whimsicott. I generally don't bother with legendaries, and I particularly dislike the ones in BW because they're forced on me, so that's moot. And I prefer old Opelucid City to modern Opelucid City and White Forest to Black City.

The only thing that I prefer in Black beyond the relative ease of catching Sawk is a few of the version exclusive National Dex swarm pokemon - Houndour, Shroomish and Murkrow over Poochyena, Paras and Misdreavus.

I'm going with White because I like nature-based exclusives like White Forest, and I like Braviary and Reuniclus which are exclusive in White as well.