I meant his posts are a wall for me to read on mobile. Meant to say this but phase change was about to pop.
Ahh my bad. Anyway I made the same mistake as 5qwerty (rip) and didn't read the OP properly, I thought there was a recruiting cult, not a cthulu-type cult (if the cult is even present in the set-up).
##Vote Bardothren - simply, I don't like that you have another gun and right now alarm bells are ringing saying you're Maf who just shot an inno and are covering it up; I wouldn't put it past you to shoot Juno and have her flip Maf for the sake of preservation.
I think you should move your vote off Bard. Ofc we haven't seen him shoot another gun yet so he
could be maf who got given a gun and either received another one last night or is bluffing, but I do think that would be a pretty risky and short-term focused strategy for mafia to take which I don't think would make sense when they're 2 people down. And since you're Marth and your vote is the one that counts...
That said I do find it strange that Bard shot 5q, especially since no one else had raised any suspicious of 5qwerty.
Also on the note of the gun I was given N0 and have been hanging on to. Assuming Bard is in fact Bowser Jr, I think the possibilities are either it's a real gun and Aldo was villager/Isabelle and gave me a gun (which would make sense -- he's the type to give out guns N0 and we've been mafia a few times so I guess he'd give it to a familiar face) or it's a fake gun and Lulu was maf-sided villager (though that begs the question of who the real PIkachu is, since she claimed Pikachu). Leaning towards the former but I'm not gonna shoot unless there's a strong enough reason to and there definitely isn't one yet.
Yeah I'm not really feeling scum Juno anymore
Metroid, Syn, EC/Desi (maybe Doof?) This group is where we'll find scum I think.
Thoughts on this, everyone?
##vote metroid
Also Rabi I think Bard's claim is believable for now (because who would have visited Del anyway? Makes sense if he's town Bowser jr getting guns from non-visits, though I am a little surprised if no one targeted Bard after he replaced in)
Can't really comment on Desi, I think I need another phase with him to get a proper feel since he just came in and EC is just naturally scummy imo. But I'd agree with two of Metroid / Syn / Doof (and I'm 50/50 throwing Juno on that list just based on what I said last phase + GP really pushing for a jd vote rather than a Juno vote).
Meta but Doof has been more on the quiet side in a lot of games recently but in those games where he's been mafia, he has made more of an effort rather than pretty much being completely absent. Whereas Syn has posted a fair amount of times but hasn't really offered any individual thinking at all.
With Marth around my vote is just a symbolic one but I'd go with
##vote Syndrome