Mizan Nix Zamnie said:
Where has all the insanity us writers are known for gone to? I thought we were crazier than this?
Picks me...
When I first got here, the Lounge was... well... a mess. IIRC I got here when you people were planning the Musica. What
ever happened to that?
Maybe it's the fact that end-of-year is close and we are all busy (in which case I'd have to ask if is this a cyclical thing?), or people are moving to other forums (I'm temporarily moving to Pokéteca right now, for example), or we are getting mentally tired of insanity, or something like that.
The thing is nowadays the Lounge is essentially the announcements and a criss-cross of bold topics. The last sort of insanity here was Misheard Whisper's Lounge drawing (so nice), and before that the one last actual, good, fun CRAZINESS was the whole "
genitally gently stroking" Freudian Slip
about three months ago! -- that' or I'll have to dig even deeper for the Index.
I'm inclined to believe we need to recharge the madness cells in our brains, which is why it seems that most Lounge people are moving away as well. Even Aurincha, who came back recently, seems to have moved to another forum, for example.
It's not something bad, I guess. A time for seriousness, and a period for new members to come without being scared of our particular style, it can be.
Back to the clothes thing...
The reason why I chose the "it's just there" thing is that, after reading Farla's rants for some time, I am convinced that some things don't have to be dug up, or they result in a
loss of quality no matter the gain in specificity. Heck, as a programmer myself, I have the belief that it is better to pursue quality (which can be assigned a discrete and finite measure such as Six Sigma) that specificity (which is an endless slope of backquestioning).
That, and the idea that it was humans who adapted certain Pokémon characteristics in the form of clothes (Kirlia), armor (Aggron), transport (Metagross), or weapons (Scyther) is actually
relevant to my interests useful for my plots. My vision of the Pokémon world, the one I reference in my fics, is that humans are the "bonus visitor" in a world made from and for Pokémon.
Now, if I were to look for an explanation as to why some Pokémon appear to wear clothes or whatever, and I did not want to take the "Pokémon first" approach, the most likely answer I'd come up would be actually yours, Mizan. It may sound less logical, yes, but anything beyond that would require overthinking too many aspects to make it workable (not to mention it would become an unfunny progress in a story). For example, the "Pokémon imitates humans" approach forces one to work around whether Hitmonchan wear box pants right off breaking their eggs, or why would Cubone/Marowak have adapted usage of their parents's (?) skull from humans if they already had (according to one of over 9.000 fanon theories) weak head tissue beforehand.
It's that, or there is a conspiracy where they use clothes to secretly mock us.
No... that's
even less logical. :P
And, seeing from the preview that
Bay is ninjaing me, I better check on this. I support the idea that trying to describe what a Pokémon's clothes look like, or why are they there, is not something necessary nor helpful (unless you are writing a Genesis story).
Going to previous topics...
What do you think is your greatest aspect in writing?
I'd have to say it's either character development, or the ability to put an amount of funny/obscure/both references to the Pokémon games and fandom (or other fandoms in general). I do lots of work with my characters and sometimes I'm all around watching them do stuff but not trying to guide them in any way. As for the references, it is one of the things I like to do. I did a weird one in "Sixth" with D/P/Pt because I thought it would be funny or interesting that even Pokémon see their world like that. No one ever commented on it, however.
We should welcome more people. What about a cake?