Favourite Storyline

[Seeds Horizon]

It was a tie between I and V for me..But i picked I since it was the first, and the first is also the best, and the V the one with the hairy chest (switched it up <3). V's was pretty interesting, and most likely the best if you would have it based on the er..enemies? Rivals? Like, two rivals? Epic. I hope the next Gens have that. And Team Plasma? I was actually rooting for N, and you should have been able to figure out Ghetsis, so I was cursing him. I was so sad after I beat N...then insanely annoyed at having to fight Ghetsis right after..Then happy when I thwarted his plans! And gen I was just awesome. So it was a tie, with the tie breaker beeing I came before V <3

 

[XtinaIsMeLuvinWWE]

Gens II and III for me :)

Like others have said, II was a fantastically gripping and involved continuation of the first, and I loved III as well due to the storyline over land and sea, not just pokémon and therefore sort of bringing a moral side/argument to the equation, and having two teams to contend with as well :)

 

[Amore]

Well, I like them all...Gen I's storyline is simple yet effective, Gen II is continued on from Gen I, which is good (particularly as I have Hg/Ss, where you even get to battle Giovanni), and battling Lance and the true Champion, Red, is brilliant, and Gen IV is kinda epic, particularly how cold-hearted Cyrus was (and Mars is kinda cutely evil).

However, Gen III wins for nostaliga (first game), having two evil "teams" / mobs, and the region being nice. Gen V's evil team plot is way more detailed than the others, and the whole bit where N decides that he may not be the chosen one, so you should find a legendary as well is also pretty cool. However, the post-E4 plot is rather lacking.

So, whilst I voted for both Gen III and V, Gen III is better overall, Gen V is only better for the evil team part.

 

[Ho-Oh]

Gen 5, -though- the storyline from HGSS (not really G/S/C), cause of the dancing girls kinda made sense, though that wasn't really a storyline idk. :(

 

[ElectricScyther]

My vote goes to gen IV, particularly Platinum. The little changes between it and D/P made all the difference.

 

[blue]

Generation III always appealed to me, it just had an intresting storyline, quite unique.

 

[BenjiTheKid]

Generation 1 and generation 5. One gets part of my vote for the nostalgia. Even though the story line wasn't well developed, that was okay because video gaming wasn't as far as it is today. Generation 5 gets the other part of my vote because the plot was just awesome and also... cut scenes!

 

[West the Hardcore Nerd]

Generation V, of course! Game Freak really put some effort into it, that goes without saying.

 

[Rai]

Generation V by far. It is so well thought out. I am a picky writing major so if I think a story is good it's good :P It makes me feel like my pokemon journey is even more worthwhile.

 

[solarowl]

I REALLY loved the Gen V storyline. It was very interesting. There were Characters with an actual Backstory. But the only downside is that Team Plasma didn't have a very good motive. I mean, it's a motive, but I felt it just made them look even more stupid.

 

[NamelessGuy]

Gen V's storyline was much more involved, but I felt that Team Plasma lacked a true "evil conspirator" persona. They had no motive, just a mentally disturbed guy who uses an illegal Hydreigon.

 

[Dragoniteisliberal]

Gen 1 will always have my vote :D

 

[amberfunk]

I liked emerald's in generation 3, platinum's in generation 4, but I have the feeling that generation five will be my favorite. I haven't finished the game yet so I'm not sure.