Just for reference, I own these two right now:
SoundMagic PL11
and JVC HA-S500
lol no those blue inner cups aren't a part of it. mine are black. the ones in the image are custom ones. just saiyan~
And, additionally, possess/have possessed in the past, these devices:
Sennheiser CX180 (earbuds)
Sennheiser HD180 (Headset)
Phillips SHE3590 (earbuds)
iBall Rocky (Headset)
In terms of audio quality, it'd be something like this:
JVC HA-S500 > SoundMagic PL11 > Sennheiser CX180 > Phillips SHE3590 > Sennheiser HD180 > iBall Rocky
So, Headset > Earbud > Earbud > Earbud > Headset > Headset. All falling in the same price bracket of $10-20. With the exception of the reigning champion JVC HA-S500 which costed me $39+ (it was a Christmas gift from my beloved bestie Jo <3 Better known here as
Fairy. LOVE YA JO!!!).
I don't like earbuds.Headphones are better because it is easier to carry and have a good sound clarity.
It is much easier to carry my PL11 earbuds around than my headset. Look at them above. Which one do you think would be easier to carry with you? I can put my earbuds in my pocket. Can't do that with the big guy. Also, sound clarity generally depends on the kind of earbud you possess. If you buy a $5 earbud or the ones you get for free with mobiles and compare them to some headphone you bought for a higher price then ofc they won't sound as good. :p
For example, I have a Sennheiser HD180 that costed me a little more than $10. And these PL11 earbuds costed me a little less than that. Even then, the sound quality on my PL11 is far, FAR superior. The clarity and sound quality differ with models so you can't exactly say that that's true for every case.
Ear buds are too small, hurt me ear, and the sound leaks out really bad. No thanks I don't want people hearing whatever I am doing.
Sound doesn't leak out if you're using in-ear earphones. They provide a great deal of noise isolation, to boot. Hurting ears - well, that's fair enough I guess.
headphones because I'd rather the music not be forced INTRUSIVELY into my ear canal. plus headphones are far more comfortable, if you get ones that aren't awful. and there's more of a range of sound which I have no evidence to back up but from my experience it's always been the case.
Like I pointed out earlier, as far as range of sound is concerned, an earbud can possibly do more as you go higher up the price chart. I think my PL11 covers a great range for an earphone its price and is even comparable to my headset for the most part. Headsets definitely give me a lot more bass response though. Like, much better. But you can't expect a skull-thumping bass response from a pair of earphones, can you? As far as clarity goes, I think sound clarity comparable to headsets is more or less achievable.
Headsets being better for your ear in general in the long run is an aspect I'd agree with you on, though.
Definitely headphones. I really hate earbuds, they hurt my ears a lot, they always fall out of my ears, they need to be cleaned if you don't want them to look and be disgusting, and the sound quality has never sounded quite right when I use buds.
I used to face the problem of 'em falling out of my ears quite a lot. But IEMs usually don't if you put em in properly. Mine almost never falls out. :p
As for what I prefer - Well, depends.
If I'm in college or going out on a walk - Earbuds. Much more easier to carry around. Provide great isolation too.
If in mood for some headbanging or for some peace at home - Headset. Also, since bass response is more and I'm a bass-freak, I prefer my headset whenever I wanna listen to tracks to "enjoy" music more thoroughly. :p
Although, if my headsets were as easy to carry around as my earbuds, I'd probably go with my headset at all times too. So I guess I prefer headsets in general.