Map Rating/Review Thread

[Disturbed]

here iv just made a map its for pokemon ever night hope you like it



please rate

I give it a 4/10 because it seems like the trees are perfectly lined up, and the fact that you seemed to use the grass as a filler. The mountains are also too perfect it seems, so it looks easily done.

Map Name: Galiel Town (Littelroot Town)

Map Game: Emerald Version

Comments: Just made it
(My II Map) I'm Begginer =/

Mapshot:

I kinda like this map, I'll give it an 7/10. I give you that because I like the placement of the houses. Also, the layout of the map is nice.

yeah i know i can make better maps but i havent had any support from anyone in ages so my maps have gone wrong and nobody supports my hacks the just let me down by saying you have too many hacks and thats what lets me down aw

That is because you can't get yourself straight. If people don't like your hacks, they won't support you. Also, if you honestly stick to one or two hacks, and actually put alot of effort into them instead of restarting all the time when one thing goes wrong, people may start to support the hack. And don't blame people for not supporting them.

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Hotel Path

Map Game: Emerald Version

Comments: My III Map

Mapshot:

 

[+Sneasel™]

Map Name: Hotel Path

Map Game: Emerald Version

Comments: My III Map

Mapshot:

Nice map, its great and simple, I give it an 8/10. To improve it I suggest just filling in some of that space at the top behind and between the two top houses. I don't know if this is a starting town or not, but if it isn't, I would give it something else, maybe another house (assuming you'd make it bigger).

 

[Mr.Fury]

I believe this got flooded out...repost!

Hello again fellas!
I have edited my two maps to my liking, hope they are to yours as well.
1-10 please. :D

Name: Sequil Village
Rom: Fire Red
Original: Pallet Town


Name: Edmond's Crossing
Rom: Fire Red
Original: Ocean bellow Pallet Town

 

[Disturbed]

I believe this got flooded out...repost!

Hello again fellas!
I have edited my two maps to my liking, hope they are to yours as well.
1-10 please. :D

Name: Sequil Village
Rom: Fire Red
Original: Pallet Town


Name: Edmond's Crossing
Rom: Fire Red
Original: Ocean bellow Pallet Town

I rather like them. But, due to tile errors all over the place in the first one, and a few in the second, here is my rating:

First Map: 5/10
Second Map: 7/10

 

[Ninja Caterpie]

Hummm...

Tis another map! BTW, that grass ist special!

 

[Mr.Fury]

Map Name: Hotel Path

Map Game: Emerald Version

Comments: My III Map

Mapshot:

I rather enjoy the house alignment and attention to detail. But the map is a bit to square try to make it less square, i guess, lol.
Also the tip of the trees are supposed to be passable so perhaps use the tree tile that connects to the base of another tree?

 

[Neti]

remember this map i posted a few days ago?

Spoiler:

i changed the things that you said were not so good and made a new palette.
i also inserted new mountain tiles, i think fallabors mountains fit way better into the desert than the FR ones.
Ratings pls:

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Tylly City (Petalburg City)

Map Game: Emerald Version

Comments: Whice u like more? (My IV Map) Yeah I'm Begginer =/

Mapshot (1):

Mapshot (2):

 

[Chimchar 9]

Map Name: Tylly City (Petalburg City)

Map Game: Emerald Version

Comments: Whice u like more? (My IV Map) Yeah I'm Begginer =/

Mapshot (1):

Mapshot (2):

i like the first map anyway them mini trees there not right did you know there are attched ones if you look on the tile set well i give the first map 6-10 and the second 4-10

 

[Binary]

Map Name: Tylly City (Petalburg City)

Map Game: Emerald Version

Comments: Whice u like more? (My IV Map) Yeah I'm Begginer =/

Mapshot (1):

Mapshot (2):

Nice to see someone actually use these tiles in a long while since I think Green Forest. The first map wouldn't load for me =(. Anyways, the maps are pretty good for a beginner I must say. But I think you should improve them a little more.
About the second map. I think you shouldn't stack the houses together like that, it looks pretty weird, especially on those tiles. The map is pretty much blank, there are alot of empty spaces. I think you can do far better than that. Try to use different kinds of trees. I don't like that style of tree for this map. The signposts don't match either..

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Cacti Town (Littelroot TOwn)

Map Game: Emerald Version

Comments: My 5 Map!.. (Begginer) Just Rate it ^^
Thanks ^_^

Mapshot:

 

[Disturbed]

@ Osher

I don't really think the bushes and the flowers really fit into the desert scene. It is one of your better maps though, I'll give you that.

7.5/10

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Path 300

Game: Fire Red

Comments: Just Rate it ^^ Thanks ^^

Mapshot:

Map Name: Path 150

Game: Emerald

Comments: Just Rate it ^^ Thanks ^^

Mapshot:

Rate Those 2 Just made it last night

 

[Mr.Fury]

New map!
3rd map ever!
Fire Red, that town with the ghost marrowak.
Also if anyone could tell me how to insert new tiles I would really enjoy it.
rate it ^_^

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Laty City

Map Game: Emerald

Comments: Just made it now.. rate it ^^ thanks.

Mapshot:

 

[Tyrantrum]

It's too square, a lot of empty space, the water is plain, and it's obvious it's an edited Slateport City...1.5/10

 

[Lollypop]

New map!
3rd map ever!
Fire Red, that town with the ghost marrowak.
Also if anyone could tell me how to insert new tiles I would really enjoy it.
rate it ^_^

Rating: 5/10.
The tiles do not go with the town. Tile errorsmake the map look weird and thats about it.

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Foret Island

Map Game: Fire Red.

Comments: Littel Island =) Rate it Thanks ^^

Mapshot:

 

[.:God:.]

Map Name: Foret Island

Map Game: Fire Red.

Comments: Littel Island =) Rate it Thanks ^^

Mapshot:

That map is really good! There is a 2 little tiles error in the corner or the mountain on the bottom, and the sand to grass has 2 tile errors, but it is really good! You really should make a hack!

That map is really good! There is a 2 little tiles error in the corner or the mountain on the bottom, and the sand to grass has 2 tile errors, but it is really good! You really should make a hack!