Map Rating/Review Thread

[Binary]

thnx for ur suggestions Neti XD, ive created another map again...
Map Name: Spring Village
Game:FireRed
Comments: The starter town in my hack... pls rate,comment or suggest

Rate: 7.5/10
Reason: It looks like a pretty nice map. The placement of the trees is great. There are some empty spaces. The house without the door looks wierd in come way XD And I don't like the boulders. The map looks pretty good though.
Suggestions: Don't leave too many spaces empty and don't use too many boulders. It ruins the map. Try to add some more creativity to the map.

 

[Tyrantrum]

@riolu 9: Nice map, not that square, but some empty spaces.
8/10
----------------------
You see?!
People almost always skip my maps here! >_<
Could someone please rate them? :)
Click here.

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: SandBeach Town

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: Just made it! Brand new! Rate it!

Mapshot:

 

[Tyrantrum]

Could someone rate my maps please? >_<
(Second time people skipped me!!!)
Click here.

 

[KhaosKnight]

Map Name: SandBeach Town

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: Just made it! Brand new! Rate it!

Mapshot:

Rating: 5/10
Reason: To square, there are alot of unneaded paths, and the beach line is rather...dull.

 

[Banjora Marxvile]

Could someone rate my maps please? >_<
(Second time people skipped me!!!)
Click here.

Nice map. not too square and is nicely put. However, the path istoo bright in my eyes, but thats all I can see.

9/10, I'd say.

 

[Mr.Fury]

Could someone rate my maps please? >_<
(Second time people skipped me!!!)
Click here.

9/10
Everything is nicely done, i dont see any tile errors and it just looks great.
But i really dont like the rocks, i dont know why, it just doesnt seem to fit in.
And btw I checked out that map tutorial you sent me, it helped my maps greatly.
Thank you.

Heres one i made with the help of it:
Please rate. ^_^

 

[Luck]

Map Name: (No name) cave
Map Game: FireRed
Comments: This is my first map post, i made this map for my upcoming hack. pls rate this one, i will also accept any comments or suggestions :D

wow, this map is really good for the first try.
Before i rate it, i am wondering if you have read any tutorials before you made this.
well, the map looks really nice but straightforward.
It'd be better if you made it at least a bit more complex because the exit is only 10 steps away, and i just hate plain maps.
the mountain tiles were placed really good and professionally, it looks great because of that.
However, it doesn't make sense why its like that unless you plan to make it like mt. coronet.
7.5/10
suggestions: Make it more complex is all. It looks great otherwise.

thnx for ur suggestions Neti XD, ive created another map again...
Map Name: Spring Village
Game:FireRed
Comments: The starter town in my hack... pls rate,comment or suggest

Eh... i don't like it that much.
There are too much flowers on the right side, not enough on the left side.
there are too much rocks and the rocks seem really crowded.
The house has no purpose, but the vegetation(trees only) is placed good.
however, there could be more small trees on the left side.
The path seems nice, and its really peaceful.
6.5/10
Suggestions: More flowers, spread them apart, and less rocks.
also, remove the windowless, doorless house.
it looks creepy.

Could someone rate my maps please? >_<
(Second time people skipped me!!!)
Click here.

Its just me, but it would look better with the original tileset.
The path looks bad, there's only 3 flowers, and the skinny tree border seems...bad.
however, the other vegetation is good,and so is the placement of the ladge.
7/10
Suggestions: It would be better with the original tileset, add more flowers, don't make the path so fat, and fix the house placement.

I'll probably rate the other maps later, so don't worry.

 

[Tyrantrum]

Thanks, but you all do realize that there IS another map in the spoiler.

 

[Chimchar 9]

iv made route 1

rom game : fire red

map:

please rate

 

[Tyrantrum]

I guess I'll rate it now. :\

Rating: 9.6/10
Errors: N/A
Suggestions: Add 2 more flowers at the very top of your map and lessen the grass and your good. ;)
Comments: I really love the shape. :)
The ledges, some people won't exactly "approve" of them being like that, but I like it! XD

 

[Likewise]

hi! well here's the second route for my hack pokemon blue revelation! (also known as deep blue)
rome game:fire red
comments: well this is for the water sector of my hack!

 

[.:God:.]

hi! well here's the second route for my hack pokemon blue revelation! (also known as deep blue)
rome game:fire red
comments: well this is for the water sector of my hack!

Not very good graphics but....
WAY TOO MUCH GRASS!! It's boring, there are tile errors on the bottom of the pond and there are no consistent border blocks.
I give it 4.7/10

 

[Megiddo-san]

Game: Firered
A route I made with a lot of choices of where to go.

 

[Disturbed]

iv made route 1

rom game : fire red

map:

please rate

Rating, 5/10
Reason: WAY too much grass once again. Some of the trees have tile errors, and most of the ledges are completly unnecessary. Also, grass in unreachable places is not good and not original. Sorry to say that again, you don't have the shadows on the left side of the stairs. Fix all that up and it'll be a 9/10. Sorry if I sounded harsh.

hi! well here's the second route for my hack pokemon blue revelation! (also known as deep blue)
rome game:fire red
comments: well this is for the water sector of my hack!

Rating- 3/10
Reason: The map does not even need to be half that size. Too many empty areas throughout the whole map, and there are tile errors by the bottom. Also, the grass as a filler is horrible. It just needs to be fixed all over the place.

Game: Firered
A route I made with a lot of choices of where to go.

Rating: 6.5/10
Reason: I like this map. It seems to flow well. The grass is very well placed. It is a little square to me, and also, there are tile errors above the waterfall that need fixing.

 

[.Iramet]

I love your map meggido the one with the waterfall...but the mountans on th etop have tile errors but other than that i love it 8/10

 

[Osher99]

Map Name: Loret City

Map Game: FireRed

Comments: Just made it
Rate it Please =)

Mapshot:

 

[Tyrantrum]

@Osher99: You seem to have gotten a little better at mapping. :)
There are no tile errors, but, the only problem you are having with your maps are, that they are too square, and WAY too much unused space.
5.673/10

 

[Likewise]

well i know no one likes my maps but i decided to make one for my friends hack...
map name: tropica town

game base: fire red


comments: i did not make the marts color

map:

 

[+Sneasel™]

well i know no one likes my maps but i decided to make one for my friends hack...
map name: tropica town

game base: fire red


comments: i did not make the marts color

map:

I like this map, its simple yet perfect. The marts color is fine, I mean, it doesn't have to be blue! There are some tile errors near the waterfall, the cave should just extend into it, not curve up. All in all, great map, 9/10
Another suggestion is that I would make the rocks a little zigzag at the bottom, not just in a straight line, cause that's boring ;)