2nd Gen Pick one of these three.

[TheDeadEvilDead]

It's always been between cyndaquil and totodile for me, as a general rule i like fire types better than water but feraligatrs the only one ive ever gotten to level 100

so 50/50 between those 2, ive used chikorita before but its just not gonna be my favourite

 

[Data_Error]

Cyndaquil, full stop.

First Pokémon I ever owned. Loaded it up with whatever moves sounded best at the time, refused to evolve it for fear that it would stop listening to me akin to Ash's Charmeleon/Charizard (given, I was nine/ten at the time). He ended up being the star of my team, at least 15 levels above the next thing down by the time I'd reached Claire. A lot of good memories with that little guy. Besides, it's just downright adorable.

 

[HollyYoshi]

Totodile all the way. Though I've used all three starters in my playthroughs of the Gen II, there's something about Totodile that appeals to me. I think it's the design. It looks awesome - especially when it evolves into Feraligatr.

 

[Dedenne1]

Can I pick none cause those were my least favorite starters from all the gens if i had to pick one which i did in the game id pick typhlosion cause i like fire types quite a bit brw in recent polls Johto was the lowest approved starters :(