Pidgy or Starly?

[Arazza]

Who do you think is better?

I think Starly because of it's ability?

 

[Fishyman]

Starly.

Pidgeot ain't got **** on Close Combat.

 

[Inferno1]

Starly i think by stats and moveset and looks it is better if my memory is correct about the 1st two

 

[*Charizard*]

Pidgy is the original and evolves into a strong flying...however both of them a basically exactly the same in game...well surve the same purpose... but design wise a reckon Pidgy and its evolutions are better...pretty much all the other main flying types i.e starly, taillow, hoothoot are all copys... but I don't really care.

 

[Pave Low]

Starly, staraptor csn learn awesome moves

 

[XxDawnfanxX]

I am an original Kanto fan of course, and Pidgeot is my favorite bird type pokemon. Although Staraptor is the stronger choice by quite the slim margin, Pidgeot will always be my favorite.

 

[milo05]

Starly ^_^

I <3 Starptor!

 

[RUBY8]

Personally it's hard to say this because pidgy was the first pokemon i caught in Pokemon Red but Starly when fully evolved into staraptor has the higest stats of any normal/flying pokemon and it learns close combat which is awesome. ^^

 

[Chaostorm]

Starly , because Staraptor has a deadly 120 base Attack and Close Combat , Pidgeot is nothing when compared with Staraptor .

and Staraptor is in BL , while Pidgeot is in NU ....

 

[Wings Don't Cry]

I chose Pidgey because there will always be a spot for it in my PC however I never catch Starly(s), they just don't appeal to me as much.

 

[Empty Pot]

Starly.

Pidgeot ain't got **** on Close Combat.

Good point, considering Close Combat is Not Very Effective or Does Not Effect on Pidgeot.

But this is a hard one. Statly is cute, but Pidgey has potential. o_o

 

[gothboyz1992]

I would say Pidgy Because I like the older Gen Pokemon more....lol

 

[Anxiety.]

Pidgey.
I can't help but love it. I did in Red, I will now.

 

[fango pango]

PIDGEY
why...why not is the shortest answer

 

[Pyrax]

Starly.
I almost never use pidgey :/

 

[Lycaeus]

Pidgey!! It looks better, and it's evos are twice as awesome.

 

[Manny626]

I like both of them but I like Starly better.

 

[icyace]

Starly offcourse. pidgey is noce to, but Starly rocks!

 

[Falcon Wing]

Pidgey! Come on it's the original! Starly is just a poor spin off of the Flying Pokemon that probably the first Pokemon we ever caught as kids. Come on, Pidgey hands down.

 

[TundraCanine]

Yea man, Everyone had pidgeys when Red, Blue and Yellow came out. Pidgeot was THE flying type to have.